Movement initiation and grasp representation in premotor and primary motor cortex mirror neurons

Steven Jack Jerjian, Maneesh Sahani, Alexander KraskoveLife 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while premotor cortex (F5) neurons represent grasping actions similarly during execution and observation, primary motor cortex (M1) neurons show distinct population activity during observation, more closely resembling "NoGo" (withholding) signals. This suggests M1 plays a crucial role in dissociating movement initiation from grasp representation, enabling flexible behavioral control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The discovery of "mirror neurons" (MNs) – neurons active both when performing an action and observing it – has long fascinated neuroscientists. While initially thought to be primarily in premotor cortex (F5), MNs have since been found in other areas, including primary motor cortex (M1). A key puzzle is how M1 neurons, which directly influence spinal cord activity for movement execution, can also be active during action observation without causing overt movement. Previous hypotheses suggested this might be due to a general disfacilitation of spinal outputs. However, this study investigates whether there's a more nuanced, state-based explanation, particularly in M1, by comparing neural activity during action execution, observation, and explicit movement withholding (NoGo). Understanding these differences is crucial for deciphering how the brain represents potential actions and controls actual movements.

Methods

The researchers recorded from single neurons in the rostral ventral premotor cortex (F5) and primary motor cortex (M1) of two adult male macaques. These monkeys were trained to perform, observe, or withhold reach-to-grasp actions. To identify pyramidal tract neurons (PTNs), a subset of M1 neurons, they used electrical stimulation of the medullary pyramid.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Electromyography (EMG): Recorded from multiple hand and arm muscles to ensure observed actions were not confounded by subtle muscle activity.
  • Statistical analysis: Two-way ANOVAs were used to assess neuronal modulation during different task epochs and grasps.
  • Correlation analysis: Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated to quantify the similarity in neural activity patterns between execution and observation across different time points and task epochs.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Used to define "movement subspaces" based on execution activity and then project observation and NoGo activity onto these subspaces. This allowed for a low-dimensional comparison of neural trajectories.
  • Decoding analysis: A maximum correlation coefficient classifier was trained to distinguish between execution, observation, and NoGo conditions.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from two adult male rhesus macaques (M48 and M49) performing a custom reach-to-grasp task. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • F5 vs. M1 Divergence: The most striking finding is the differential representation of actions in F5 and M1. F5 neurons seem to maintain a consistent "grasping action" representation, regardless of whether the monkey is performing or observing. M1, however, shows a distinct population activity during observation.
  • M1 Observation Activity Resembles "Withholding": M1 population activity during action observation was found to be more aligned with activity during "NoGo" trials (where monkeys were explicitly cued to withhold movement) than with execution activity. This suggests that observation in M1 might engage a mechanism for suppressing self-movement.
  • Dissociation of Initiation and Representation: The study proposes that M1, through its distinct activity patterns, might be responsible for dissociating the initiation of movement from the representation of a grasp. This allows for flexible behavioral control, enabling the brain to plan and represent actions without necessarily executing them.
  • Temporal Dynamics Matter: The differences in neural activity between execution and observation were particularly pronounced in the lead-up to movement onset, highlighting the importance of temporal dynamics in understanding these neural processes.

Key Results

  • F5 Mirror Neurons: F5 neurons showed similar modulation depth and profile during both execution and observation of grasping actions.
  • M1 Mirror Neurons: While many individual M1 neurons showed mirror properties, the population activity in M1 during observation was distinct from execution. Specifically, M1-PTN (pyramidal tract neuron) facilitation-facilitation (F-F) neurons showed a 3- to 4-fold reduction in activity during observation compared to execution.
  • Correlation Analysis: Correlations between execution and observation activity were strong in F5 but significantly weaker in M1, especially during the early reach phase.
  • Subspace Analysis: PCA revealed that observation activity in M1 populations (PTNs and UIDs) did not align well with the movement subspace defined by execution. Instead, M1 observation activity showed greater overlap with the "NoGo" (withholding) subspace. F5, in contrast, showed more similar trajectories for execution and observation.
  • Decoding: A classifier could distinguish between execution, observation, and NoGo conditions with high accuracy in all populations after the Go cue. However, distinguishing between observation and NoGo took longer in M1 populations than in F5, further supporting the idea of shared underlying mechanisms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EMG Contamination: While efforts were made to exclude trials with EMG activity, the authors acknowledge that subtle EMG increases during observation might still have slightly influenced M1-PTN alignment, suggesting a need for careful control in future studies.
  • Task Specificity: The study was conducted in a specific peri-personal space reach-to-grasp task. The authors suggest that alternative task setups (e.g., block designs, extra-personal space observation) might yield different results.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose several avenues for future research:
  • Wider Sampling: Recording from more neurons simultaneously and exploring a broader range of grasping behaviors.
  • Causal Perturbation: Using techniques like inactivation or stimulation to directly test the role of specific neural populations in movement suppression during observation.
  • Eye Movements: Investigating the influence of eye gaze on mirror neuron activity, as monkeys had free gaze in this task.
  • Stop-Signal Reaction Time (SSRT) Tasks: Further characterizing the "withholding subspace" using tasks designed to probe response inhibition.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pyramidal tract neurons (PTNs) within macaque rostral ventral premotor cortex (F5) and (M1) provide direct input to spinal circuitry and are critical for skilled movement control. Contrary to initial hypotheses, they can also be active during action observation, in the absence of any movement. A population-level understanding of this phenomenon is currently lacking. We recorded from single neurons, including identified PTNs, in (M1) (n = 187), and F5 (n = 115) as two adult male macaques executed, observed, or withheld (NoGo) reach-to-grasp actions. F5 maintained a similar representation of grasping actions during both execution and observation. In contrast, although many individual M1 neurons were active during observation, M1 population activity was distinct from execution, and more closely aligned to NoGo activity, suggesting this activity contributes to withholding of self-movement. M1 and its outputs may dissociate initiation of movement from representation of grasp in order to flexibly guide behaviour.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jerjian2020movement,
  author = {Steven Jack Jerjian and Maneesh Sahani and Alexander Kraskov},
  title = {{Movement initiation and grasp representation in premotor and primary motor cortex mirror neurons}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.54139},
}
Figure