TL;DR
This paper demonstrates the BOOST method for phosphotyrosine proteomics in scarce mouse primary T cells, achieving unprecedented depth and identifying over 2,000 unique pTyr sites with minimal protein input. Crucially, disabling the ΦSDM acquisition parameter significantly enhances quantitation depth, accuracy, and precision, particularly for low-abundance samples.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Tyrosine phosphorylation plays a critical role in T cell signaling, but its low abundance in primary T cells makes it challenging to study using traditional proteomics methods. Existing techniques often require large cell numbers and protein input, which is impractical for scarce primary samples. While the BOOST method has shown promise in cell lines, its application to primary mouse T cells, which are more biologically relevant but even scarcer, remained undemonstrated. Furthermore, the impact of specific mass spectrometry acquisition parameters, like the phase-constrained spectrum deconvolution method (ΦSDM), on the quantitative depth and accuracy in these challenging low-abundance scenarios was not well understood.
Methods
The researchers applied the BOOST (Broad Spectrum Optimization of Selective Triggering) method, which utilizes a pervanadate (PV)-treated sample as a carrier channel in multiplexed TMT (Tandem Mass Tag) experiments. This approach aims to increase precursor ion triggering and fragmentation of phosphotyrosine-containing peptides. They also investigated the effect of the phase-constrained spectrum deconvolution method (ΦSDM), a computational parameter on Orbitrap instruments, by acquiring data both with and without it enabled. Standard sample processing involved lysis, reduction, alkylation, digestion (FASP method), desalting, TMT labeling, and enrichment for phosphotyrosine peptides using a superbinder SH2 method. Data acquisition was performed on an Orbitrap Eclipse Tribrid mass spectrometer using SPS-MS3. Data analysis was carried out using MaxQuant and custom Python scripts.
Datasets
The study utilized primary T cells isolated from B6 mice. The experimental design involved multiplexed TMT experiments with varying protein input amounts (1.0 mg, 0.3 mg, and 0.1 mg) from stimulated primary T cells. The data was compared to previously published BOOST experiments on Jurkat T cells.
Key Insights and Ideas
- BOOST shines in scarce primary cells: The study successfully adapted and validated the BOOST method for primary mouse T cells, demonstrating its ability to achieve deep phosphotyrosine profiling even with limited protein input. This opens doors for studying rare cell populations.
- ΦSDM is a double-edged sword: Disabling the ΦSDM parameter, contrary to expectations, significantly improved quantitation depth, accuracy, and precision, especially in low-abundance samples. This suggests that for certain experimental setups, particularly those involving carrier channels and low protein input, ΦSDM might hinder optimal data acquisition.
- Carrier channel effectiveness: The inclusion of a PV-treated carrier channel in BOOST experiments was shown to be effective in increasing quantitative yield without introducing significant reporter ion leakage or ratio compression, addressing a potential concern with this approach.
- Identification of critical pTyr sites: The BOOST method enabled the identification of key phosphotyrosine sites on proteins critical for T cell receptor signaling, including those on ITAMs, Zap70, Tec, Itk, and CD45, some of which might have been missed with other methods.
Key Results
- Unprecedented depth: The study identified over 2,000 unique pTyr sites and more than 3,000 unique pTyr peptide PSMs from just 1 mg of protein from stimulated primary mouse T cells.
- ΦSDM impact: Disabling ΦSDM led to a 2.3-fold increase in quantifiable pTyr peptide PSMs in BOOST experiments at 1.0 mg protein input, and even larger increases (up to 3.6-fold) at lower protein inputs. It also reduced missing values and improved replicate reproducibility.
- BOOST yield: Using the BOOST method without ΦSDM resulted in a 7.6-fold increase in unique pTyr peptide PSMs quantified at 1.0 mg protein input compared to control experiments without ΦSDM.
- Accuracy and Precision: Disabling ΦSDM improved accuracy, as evidenced by tighter clustering around theoretical ratios, and increased quantitative precision, with a significant reduction in the coefficient of variation for low-abundance samples.
- BOOST factor: The study found that disabling ΦSDM increased the magnitude of BOOST factors, indicating a greater enrichment of scarce peptides.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that while BOOST increases the detection of significantly changed pTyr peptides, there was an observed increase in the median coefficient of variation when using BOOST. However, they argue that this did not impact the number of statistically significant changes. Future work could focus on further optimizing the interplay between experimental parameters like BOOST and computational methods like ΦSDM to maximize data quality and yield across a broader range of biological samples and experimental conditions. The study also suggests that this work serves as a benchmark for future pTyr proteome studies in primary T cells, potentially enabling research with even less sample.
Summary updated