Abstract
Aside from some common movement regularities, significant inter-individual and inter-trial variation within the same individual exists in motor system output. However, there is still a lack of a robust and widely adopted solution for quantifying the degree of similarity between movements. We therefore developed an innovative approach based on the Procrustes transformation to compute 'motor distance' between pairs of kinematic data. As a proof of concept, we tested this on a dataset of reach-to-grasp movements performed by 16 participants while acting with the same confederate. Using the information of wrist velocity, acceleration, and jerk, the proposed technique was able to correctly estimate smaller distances between movements performed by the confederate compared with those of participants. Moreover, the reconstructed pattern of inter-subject distances was consistent when computed either on precision grip prehension or whole hand prehension, suggesting its suitability for the investigation of 'motor styles'. The definition of a solid approach to 'motor distance' computation, therefore, opens the way to new research lines in the field of movement kinematics.
Introduction
Human movement is characterized by remarkable variability. Even when executing the same goal-directed task, no two individuals move in exactly the same way, and even a single individual exhibits trial-to-trial fluctuations. Traditionally, this variability has been dismissed as stochastic noise. However, recent research suggests that these idiosyncratic patterns constitute a "motor style"—a stable, individual-specific signature of motor control.
Despite the potential importance of motor styles, the field of kinematics has lacked a robust, standardized methodology for quantifying the similarity between movements. Existing approaches, such as Earth Mover’s Distance (EMD) or Individual Motor Signature (IMS), often suffer from limitations: they typically analyze kinematic variables (like velocity) in isolation or fail to account for the integrated temporal evolution of the movement. This paper introduces a multidimensional computational framework that treats movement sequences as "shapes" in kinematic space, allowing for the formal operationalization of "motor distance."
Methodology: The Procrustes Framework
The authors propose a two-step framework centered on the Procrustes transformation, a technique from geometric morphometrics used to compare shapes by removing variations in translation, scale, and reflection. This allows researchers to focus purely on the "shape" of the kinematic trajectory.
- Inter-trial Alignment: To represent an individual's characteristic movement, the reach-to-grasp phase is divided into 10 time-normalized deciles. For each decile, three key kinematic variables are extracted: Wrist Velocity (WV), Wrist Acceleration (WA), and Wrist Jerk (WJ). This data is organized into a $10 \times 3$ matrix. The Procrustes transformation is then used to align multiple trials from the same subject, which are averaged into a single Final Procrustes-transformed (FPT) trial.
- Inter-subject Distance Computation: To compare the motor styles of two individuals, the framework calculates the Procrustes distance between their respective FPT trials. This distance is defined as the sum of squared differences between corresponding points in their multidimensional kinematic shapes.
This approach is novel because it jointly models multiple kinematic features, capturing the complex interactions between velocity, acceleration, and jerk over the course of a movement.
Experimental Design and Validation
The framework was validated using a dataset of reach-to-grasp movements involving 16 right-handed participants and a single male confederate. The confederate served as a "ground truth" benchmark; by performing the task with every participant, he provided 16 separate instances of the same motor style. The goal was to determine if the algorithm could correctly identify these instances as being more similar to each other than to the participants' movements.
Participants performed the task using two different types of grasp: Precision Grip (PG) and Whole-Hand Prehension (WHP). Kinematic data were captured using an 8-camera Vicon motion-capture system at a sampling rate of 100 Hz.
Key Results and Insights
Motor Style as a Stable Trait
A primary finding was the high correlation ($r = 0.78$) between motor distances calculated during precision grips and those during whole-hand grasps. This suggests that motor style is a stable individual characteristic that persists across different mechanical task constraints.
Discriminative Power and Robustness
The framework demonstrated high discriminative power. The average motor distance for confederate–confederate pairs (same person) was 0.09, whereas the average for confederate–participant pairs was 0.39. Permutation testing confirmed that this difference was statistically significant ($p = 0.023$). Additionally, the method proved highly stable; even when the number of trials used to generate the FPT was reduced by 80% (leaving only approximately 4 trials), the resulting motor distance remained highly consistent (ICC = 0.958).
Visualization of Motor Distances
Multidimensional Scaling (MDS) plots provided a clear visual representation of these distances. The confederate's instances formed a tight cluster, while the participants' data points were widely scattered, reflecting their unique and diverse individual motor styles.
Discussion and Conclusion
This framework opens new avenues for research in movement kinematics by providing a solid mathematical foundation for the concept of motor distance. While the current study focused on transitive, goal-directed movements, future work could explore its application to intransitive or cyclic movements, such as gait analysis.
Furthermore, the ability to quantify individual motor signatures has significant clinical implications. It could be used to identify motor biomarkers in neurodevelopmental conditions like Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) or to provide objective metrics for tracking motor recovery and the effectiveness of rehabilitation following a stroke. By treating movement as a multidimensional shape, the Procrustes-based approach offers a more holistic and precise signature of human motor behavior.
Summary updated