Motivation mechanism of gamification in crowdsourcing projects

Zhiyuan Zeng, Jian Tang, Tianmei WangInternational Journal of Crowd Science 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to study the participation behaviors in the context of crowdsourcing projects from the perspective of gamification. Design/methodology/approach: This paper first proposed a model to depict the effect of four categories of game elements on three types of motivation based upon several motivation theories, which may, in turn, influence user participation. Then, 5 × 2 between-subject Web experiments were designed for collecting data and validating this model. Findings: Game elements which provide participants with rewards and recognitions or remind participants of the completion progress of their tasks may positively influence the extrinsic motivation, whereas game elements which can help create a fantasy scene may strengthen intrinsic motivation. Besides, recognition-kind and progress-kind game elements may trigger the internalization of extrinsic motivation. In addition, when a task is of high complexity, the effects from game elements on extrinsic motivation and intrinsic motivation will be less prominent, whereas the internalization of extrinsic motivation may benefit from the increase of task complexity. Originality/value: This study may uncover the motivation mechanism of several different kinds of game elements, which may help to find which game elements are more effective in enhancing engagement and participation in crowdsourcing projects. Besides, as task complexity is used as a moderator, one may be able to identify whether task complexity is able to influence the effects from game elements on motivations. Last, but not the least, this study will indicate the interrelationship between game elements, individual motivation and user participation, which can be adapted by other scholars.

Introduction

Crowdsourcing projects, such as Wikipedia or Foldit, rely entirely on the sustained engagement of a distributed workforce. However, many projects struggle to attract and retain participants. While gamification—the use of game design elements in non-game contexts—is often proposed as a solution, it is frequently applied as a "one-size-fits-all" fix. Most existing research fails to explain why specific mechanics, like leaderboards, work for certain tasks but fail in others. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the "motivation mechanism": the specific pathways through which different categories of game elements influence user participation, particularly when moderated by task complexity.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers move beyond the standard "points and badges" approach by applying Self-Determination Theory (SDT). SDT allows for a nuanced view of human drive, categorizing motivation into three distinct types:

  1. Intrinsic Motivation: Engaging in an activity for the inherent satisfaction of the task itself (e.g., fun or curiosity).
  2. Extrinsic Motivation: Engaging in an activity to attain a separable outcome (e.g., rewards or status).
  3. Internalized Extrinsic Motivation: The process of transforming an external regulation into an internal value, leading to a sense of achievement or self-efficacy.
Figure 1: The proposed research model illustrating the pathways from game elements to user participation.

To validate the relationships shown in the model, the authors designed a 5 × 2 between-subject Web experiment. Participants performed a clothing preference task (dressing virtual models). The experiment manipulated two variables:

  • Game Categories: Control (no elements), Reward (gifts), Progress (progress bars), Fantasy (storytelling), and Recognition (leaderboards).
  • Task Complexity: Low vs. high choice sizes.

Analysis of Motivation Mechanisms

The study identifies that different game elements act on distinct psychological levers. While "Fantasy" elements are unique in their ability to foster intrinsic motivation by creating a state of "flow," elements like "Recognition" and "Progress" serve a more complex role. They do more than provide extrinsic pressure; they trigger internalization, helping users feel a sense of competence.

Table II: Mapping specific motives to game elements in crowdsourcing projects.

Key Results and the Role of Task Complexity

The empirical findings suggest several critical relationships:

  • Extrinsic Drivers: Reward, Recognition, and Progress elements are positively associated with extrinsic motivation.
  • Intrinsic Drivers: Fantasy is the primary driver for intrinsic motivation, immersing the user in a narrative.
  • Internalization Drivers: Recognition and Progress elements are key to fostering internalized extrinsic motivation.

Perhaps the most significant finding involves Task Complexity as a moderator. As tasks become more complex, the effectiveness of simple rewards and intrinsic fun actually decreases. However, the power of elements that aid internalization (like progress bars) increases. In high-complexity scenarios, a progress bar acts as a vital anchor, reducing anxiety and providing a steady sense of achievement that simple "fun" elements cannot provide.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a theoretical roadmap for designers to move beyond haphazard gamification. By matching game elements to the desired motivational outcome and the complexity of the task, project managers can better sustain crowd engagement.

Future research should explore the generalizability of these findings in more technical crowdsourcing environments, such as scientific data analysis or bug-bounty programs. Additionally, exploring how individual user personality traits (e.g., "achievers" vs. "explorers") interact with these game elements could further refine the proposed motivation mechanism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to study the participation behaviors in the context of crowdsourcing projects from the perspective of gamification. Design/methodology/approach This paper first proposed a model to depict the effect of four categories of game elements on three types of motivation based upon several motivation theories, which may, in turn, influence user participation. Then, 5 × 2 between-subject Web experiments were designed for collecting data and validating this model. Findings Game elements which provide participants with rewards and recognitions or remind participants of the completion progress of their tasks may positively influence the extrinsic motivation, whereas game elements which can help create a fantasy scene may strengthen intrinsic motivation. Besides, recognition-kind and progress-kind game elements may trigger the internalization of extrinsic motivation. In addition, when a task is of high complexity, the effects from game elements on extrinsic motivation and intrinsic motivation will be less prominent, whereas the internalization of extrinsic motivation may benefit from the increase of task complexity. Originality/value This study may uncover the motivation mechanism of several different kinds of game elements, which may help to find which game elements are more effective in enhancing engagement and participation in crowdsourcing projects. Besides, as task complexity is used as a moderator, one may be able to identify whether task complexity is able to influence the effects from game elements on motivations. Last, but not the least, this study will indicate the interrelationship between game elements, individual motivation and user participation, which can be adapted by other scholars.
BibTeX
@article{zeng2017motivation,
  author = {Zhiyuan Zeng and Jian Tang and Tianmei Wang},
  title = {{Motivation mechanism of gamification in crowdsourcing projects}},
  journal = {International Journal of Crowd Science},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1108/ijcs-12-2016-0001},
}
Figure