Mosquito feeding behavior and how it influences residual malaria transmission across Africa

Ellie Sherrard-Smith, Janetta Skarp, Andrew D. Beale, Christen Fornadel, L.c. Norris, Sarah Moore, Selam Mihreteab, J. D. Charlwood, Samir Bhatt, Peter Winskill, Jamie T. Griffin, Thomas S. ChurcherProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that a significant portion of malaria transmission occurs outside the protective window of current vector control tools like insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS). By quantifying this "outdoor biting," the study estimates that it could lead to millions of additional malaria cases annually, highlighting the urgent need for new control strategies that address this persistent transmission.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Malaria control efforts, primarily through long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS), have been remarkably successful in reducing clinical cases. These interventions are designed to kill mosquitoes when they rest indoors or bite people while they sleep. However, a significant challenge remains: "residual transmission," which refers to malaria transmission that persists even when these tools are used optimally. A key contributor to this residual transmission is believed to be mosquito bites that occur when people are outdoors or awake, outside the protective reach of LLINs and IRS. The extent of this "outdoor biting" behavior and its impact on the overall effectiveness of current malaria control strategies have been poorly understood, making it difficult to design effective interventions to combat the remaining cases.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive systematic meta-analysis approach. They collated data from a systematic literature review and country-level reports from the President's Malaria Initiative (PMI) to quantify two critical parameters:

  1. Proportion of mosquito bites occurring indoors ($\phi_I$): This measures the likelihood of a mosquito biting a human indoors, irrespective of whether the person is in bed.
  2. Proportion of mosquito bites occurring in bed ($\phi_B$): This specifically measures the likelihood of a mosquito biting a human while they are in bed.

They combined this mosquito biting behavior data with data on human activity patterns (when people are indoors or in bed) to estimate the "mosquito biting risk." This risk was then used in a transmission dynamics model to simulate the public health impact of outdoor biting and its interaction with insecticide resistance.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  1. Systematic Literature Review Data: This involved a comprehensive search of published literature to identify studies reporting on the hourly activity and biting times of key malaria vectors (Anopheles gambiae s.l., Anopheles arabiensis, and Anopheles funestus s.l.) indoors and outdoors. This yielded 132 distributions of mosquito indoor and outdoor behavior data.
  2. President's Malaria Initiative (PMI) Country-Level Reports: Data from PMI reports across 22 African countries were incorporated, providing an additional 128 distributions of mosquito activity patterns. These reports also sometimes included data on insecticide resistance.

Crucially, the study also incorporated human activity data from a smaller set of studies (9 papers for indoor activity, 6 for in-bed activity) to inform the models, acknowledging that this human behavior data was less extensive than the mosquito data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Outdoor Biting is More Prevalent Than Previously Thought: The study's revised estimates suggest a significantly higher proportion of mosquito bites occur when people are not protected by LLINs or IRS, challenging previous assumptions.
  • Temporal Shift in Biting Behavior: There's evidence of a trend towards more outdoor biting over time, potentially influenced by increased vector control efforts.
  • Interaction with Insecticide Resistance: While outdoor biting and physiological resistance to insecticides are both factors that reduce LLIN effectiveness, the study found no direct association between them. However, their combined effect can be particularly detrimental.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity is Key: The effectiveness of malaria control varies significantly across Africa, likely due to differences in mosquito biting behavior and local resistance levels.

Key Results

  • Revised Bite Proportions: The study estimates that, on average, 79% of bites by major malaria vectors occur when people are in bed (down from previous estimates). Similarly, 87.5% of bites occur when people are indoors. This represents a nearly 10% lower proportion of bites occurring during protected times compared to earlier predictions.
  • Projected Malaria Cases: If universal LLIN and IRS coverage were achieved, the increased outdoor transmission is predicted to result in an estimated 10.6 million additional malaria cases annually across Africa.
  • LLIN Effectiveness Reduction: Higher outdoor biting can diminish the number of malaria cases averted by vector control. The study suggests that a 10% increase in outdoor biting could reduce LLIN efficacy by up to 12% in simulated scenarios.
  • Resistance Impact: Physiological resistance to pyrethroids can have a more substantial impact on LLIN efficacy than outdoor biting alone, potentially reducing efficacy by up to 36%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Aggregation: The analysis aggregated mosquito and human data to a community or continental level. However, malaria transmission is often driven by a small proportion of highly infectious individuals, and their specific biting times and infectivity might vary.
  • Human Behavior Simplification: The assumption that average human indoor and in-bed behavior is representative across all locations and times is a significant oversimplification. Human behavior can be influenced by season, age, gender, and net use.
  • Limited Data on Specific Species: The meta-analysis had insufficient data to differentiate within the An. gambiae complex, and other mosquito species not investigated could also influence residual transmission.
  • Measurement of Outdoor Biting: The observed increase in outdoor biting could be influenced by short-term plasticity in mosquito behavior or an evolutionary response, and further experiments are needed to clarify this.

Future work should focus on collecting more detailed, site-specific data on both human activity and mosquito biting patterns, particularly in areas where LLINs and IRS are underperforming. The development of new vector control tools that target mosquitoes outdoors or employ novel insecticides will be crucial to address the persistent challenge of residual malaria transmission.

Summary updated

Abstract

The antimalarial efficacy of the most important vector control interventions-long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS)-primarily protect against mosquitoes' biting people when they are in bed and indoors. Mosquito bites taken outside of these times contribute to residual transmission which determines the maximum effectiveness of current malaria prevention. The likelihood mosquitoes feed outside the time of day when LLINs and IRS can protect people is poorly understood, and the proportion of bites received outdoors may be higher after prolonged vector control. A systematic review of mosquito and human behavior is used to quantify and estimate the public health impact of outdoor biting across Africa. On average 79% of bites by the major malaria vectors occur during the time when people are in bed. This estimate is substantially lower than previous predictions, with results suggesting a nearly 10% lower proportion of bites taken at the time when people are beneath LLINs since the year 2000. Across Africa, this higher outdoor transmission is predicted to result in an estimated 10.6 million additional malaria cases annually if universal LLIN and IRS coverage was achieved. Higher outdoor biting diminishes the cases of malaria averted by vector control. This reduction in LLIN effectiveness appears to be exacerbated in areas where mosquito populations are resistant to insecticides used in bed nets, but no association was found between physiological resistance and outdoor biting. Substantial spatial heterogeneity in mosquito biting behavior between communities could contribute to differences in effectiveness of malaria control across Africa.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sherrardsmith2019mosquito,
  author = {Ellie Sherrard-Smith and Janetta Skarp and Andrew D. Beale and Christen Fornadel and L.C. Norris and Sarah Moore and Selam Mihreteab and J. D. Charlwood and Samir Bhatt and Peter Winskill and Jamie T. Griffin and Thomas S. Churcher},
  title = {{Mosquito feeding behavior and how it influences residual malaria transmission across Africa}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1820646116},
}

Loading related content...

Figure