Morpholino-mediated knockdown of the brain mineralocorticoid receptor affects glucocorticoid signaling and neuroplasticity in wild ocellated wrasse ( Symphodus ocellatus )

Bridget M. Nugent, Kelly A. Stiver, Jiawei Han, Holly K. Kindsvater, Susan E. Marsh‐Rollo, Hans A. Hofmann, Suzanne H. AlonzobioRxiv 2021 · DOI

This study represents a significant technical and conceptual milestone in behavioral ecology: performing precise molecular manipulations on wild animals in their natural habitat to uncover the "gears" of evolution.

TL;DR

Researchers used molecular "knockdown" tools to silence a specific stress receptor (MR) in the brains of wild Mediterranean fish. While the fish maintained their social status and reproductive habits, the intervention fundamentally rewired their internal molecular state and stress response, revealing how brain plasticity directly links to evolutionary fitness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biologists have long known that the "stress axis" (the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal/interrenal axis) is a master regulator of behavior across all vertebrates. However, most of what we know comes from highly controlled laboratory settings.

The "Phenotypic Gambit" is a common assumption in evolutionary biology that we can understand the evolution of a trait (like aggression or parenting) without knowing its underlying genetics or physiology. The authors of this paper challenge that gambit. They wanted to know: if you break a specific link in the neuroendocrine chain—the mineralocorticoid receptor (MR)—in a wild environment, how does the whole system (behavior, brain chemistry, and reproductive success) compensate?

Methods

The team studied the ocellated wrasse (Symphodus ocellatus) off the coast of Corsica. These fish are famous for their "alternative reproductive tactics": dominant nesting males, helpful satellite males, and sneaky sneaker males.

  1. Molecular Surgery in the Wild: Divers captured nesting males, brought them to a field lab, and performed intracerebroventricular (ICV) injections.
  2. The Tool: They used antisense morpholino oligonucleotides. Unlike traditional drugs that block a receptor's "pocket," morpholinos prevent the cell from ever building the receptor protein in the first place.
  3. Field Observation: The fish were released back to their specific nests. Researchers then filmed their behavior, measured their reproductive success (larval counts), and eventually analyzed gene expression in three key brain regions: the POA (social behavior center), the Dl (the fish version of the hippocampus), and the Dm (the fish version of the amygdala).

Datasets

The study relied on several integrated data streams:

  • Behavioral Metrics: 10-minute video segments scoring aggression, courtship, and "catch latency" (how hard it was to re-capture the fish).
  • Physiological Data: Plasma levels of Cortisol (CORT) and 11-ketotestosterone (11-KT).
  • Gene Expression: Quantitative PCR (qPCR) data for seven candidate genes (including c-Fos for neural activity and BDNF for plasticity) across three brain regions.
  • Fitness Data: Paternity assignment of 691 larvae using six microsatellite loci to determine exactly how many offspring the manipulated males actually sired.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Catch Latency" Clue: Interestingly, the MR-knockdown didn't make the fish stop guarding their nests or courting females. However, it made them significantly harder to catch. This suggests that MR in the brain might be less about "social rules" and more about risk assessment, fear, or memory of the initial capture.
  • Molecular Compensation: Even though behavior looked "normal" on the surface, the fish's brains were in a state of high-alert compensation. Circulating cortisol levels spiked, and genes involved in brain plasticity (like BDNF and DXC) were significantly altered.
  • Phenotypic Integration: The study found that individual variation in brain plasticity was strongly associated with fitness. For example, gene expression in the "hippocampus-like" region (Dl) clustered with the proportion of offspring sired. This suggests that a male's ability to "rewire" his brain in response to his environment is a direct target of natural selection.

Key Results

  • Physiology: MR-knockdown males had significantly higher levels of free plasma cortisol (p=0.05) compared to controls, confirming MR's role in the negative feedback loop of the stress axis.
  • Behavior: No significant change in courtship or aggression, but a significant increase in Catch Latency (p=0.01).
  • Brain Region Specificity: The POA and Dl showed the strongest gene expression changes. In the POA, markers for neural activity (c-Fos) and plasticity (DXC) were upregulated, suggesting the brain was trying to "work around" the missing MR signaling.
  • Fitness: There was no immediate drop in the number of larvae produced, but the integration analysis showed that brain-region-specific gene expression profiles were robustly correlated with reproductive success.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study used a relatively small sample (n=18 total for the final analysis), which is a common trade-off when performing complex surgeries on wild animals.
  • Uncontrolled Variables: In the wild, you can't control the "nest cycle." Some males might have been at the peak of spawning while others were transitioning to parenting, which adds noise to the behavioral data.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest moving from "candidate gene" approaches to full transcriptomics (RNA-seq) in the wild. This would allow researchers to see the entire molecular landscape of the brain as it responds to environmental challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Uncovering the genetic, physiological, and developmental mechanisms underlying phenotypic variation is necessary for understanding how genetic and genomic variation shape phenotypic variation and for discovering possible targets of selection. Although the neural and endocrine mechanisms underlying social behavior are evolutionarily ancient, we lack an understanding of the proximate causes and evolutionary consequences of variation in these mechanisms. Here, we examine in the natural environment the behavioral, neuromolecular, and fitness consequences of a morpholino-mediated knockdown of the mineralocorticoid receptor (MR) in the brain of nesting males of the ocellated wrasse, Symphodus ocellatus , a species with male alternative reproductive tactics. Even though MR knockdown did not significantly change male behavior directly, this experimental manipulation strongly altered glucocorticoid signaling and neuroplasticity in the preoptic area, the putative hippocampus homolog, and the putative basolateral amygdala homolog. We also found that individual variation in stress axis gene expression and neuroplasticity is strongly associated with variation in male behavior and fitness-related traits. The brain region-specific effects of MR knockdown on phenotypic integration in the wild reported here suggest specific neuroendocrine and neuroplasticity pathways that may be targets of selection.
BibTeX
@misc{nugent2021morpholino,
  author = {Bridget M. Nugent and Kelly A. Stiver and Jiawei Han and Holly K. Kindsvater and Susan E. Marsh‐Rollo and Hans A. Hofmann and Suzanne H. Alonzo},
  title = {{Morpholino-mediated knockdown of the brain mineralocorticoid receptor affects glucocorticoid signaling and neuroplasticity in wild ocellated wrasse ( <i>Symphodus ocellatus</i> )}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.11.17.468986},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure