Moonshine and the meaning of life

Yang‐Hui He, John McKayContemporary 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

With a jocund air, we present an observation on the first 24 coefficients of the modular invariant and of the modular discriminant. The observation is purely for the sake of entertainment and could be of some diversion to a mathematical audience.

Introduction

In the realm of number theory, certain "coincidences" have historically served as the gateway to profound mathematical discoveries. The most famous of these is "Monstrous Moonshine," which began with the observation that the first non-trivial coefficient of the $j$-invariant is almost exactly the dimension of the smallest non-trivial irreducible representation of the Monster group. In this spirit of playful exploration, we examine the first 24 coefficients of two fundamental modular functions: the $j$-invariant and the modular discriminant.

Mathematical Foundations

The study centers on two cornerstone functions in the theory of modular forms:

  1. The $j$-invariant ($j(q)$): A modular function of weight zero for the full modular group, with a Fourier expansion $j(q) = \sum_{m=-1}^{\infty} c_m q^m$.
  2. The modular discriminant ($\Delta(q)$): A cusp form of weight 12, whose coefficients are the Ramanujan tau numbers, $\Delta(q) = \sum_{m=1}^{\infty} \tau_m q^m$.

The choice of the number 24 is significant in lattice theory and string theory, most notably as the dimension of the Leech lattice. Furthermore, 24 is the unique integer $n > 1$ that solves the "square pyramid problem"—the sum of the first 24 squares is a perfect square: $$\sum_{i=1}^{24} i^2 = 1^2 + 2^2 + \dots + 24^2 = 4900 = 70^2$$ This identity, proven by G.N. Watson, provides the modulus (70) used in our observations.

The Observations

By performing modular arithmetic on the sums of the squares of the first 24 coefficients of these functions, a curious pattern emerges.

The [JM] Congruence

For the $j$-invariant coefficients $c_m$ (where $c_1 = 196884, c_2 = 21493760, \dots$), we consider the sum of their squares for $m=1$ to 24. Modulo 70, the result is: $$\sum_{m=1}^{24} c_m^2 \equiv 42 \pmod{70}$$

The [YHH] Congruence

Similarly, for the Ramanujan tau coefficients $\tau_m$ (where $\tau_1 = 1, \tau_2 = -24, \dots$), the sum of the squares for the first 24 terms yields the same remainder: $$\sum_{m=1}^{24} \tau_m^2 \equiv 42 \pmod{70}$$

Discussion

The appearance of the number 42—famously cited by Douglas Adams as the "Answer to Life, the Universe, and Everything"—is presented here as a "jocund" tribute. However, the history of Moonshine suggests that numerical coincidences involving the number 24 and modular coefficients often point toward deep underlying structures.

John McKay’s 1978 observation that $196884 = 196883 + 1$ was initially dismissed by some as a fluke, yet it eventually led to the development of vertex operator algebras and Richard Borcherds' proof of the Moonshine conjectures. While the current congruences are offered for entertainment, they highlight the persistent and mysterious role of the Leech lattice dimension in the landscape of modular forms.

Conclusion

While no formal proof is offered for why these sums result in 42, the alignment of the $j$-function and the $\Delta$-function under the modulus of 70 is a striking numerical curiosity. Whether this is a mere "diversion" or the tip of a new mathematical iceberg remains to be seen.

Summary updated

Abstract

With a jocund air, we present an observation on the first 24 coefficients of the modular invariant and of the modular discriminant. The observation is purely for the sake of entertainment and could be of some diversion to a mathematical audience.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2017moonshine,
  author = {Yang‐Hui He and John McKay},
  title = {{Moonshine and the meaning of life}},
  booktitle = {Contemporary},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1090/conm/694/13956},
}

Loading related content...

Figure