Monte Carlo study of strongly interacting degenerate fermions: A model for voltage-biased bilayer graphene

Wesley Armour, Simon Hands, Costas StrouthosPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We formulate a model of $N_f=4$ flavors of relativistic fermion in $2+1d$ in the presence of a chemical potential $\mu$ coupled to two flavor doublets with opposite sign, akin to isospin chemical potential in QCD. This is argued to be an effective theory for low energy electronic excitations in bilayer graphene, in which an applied voltage between the layers ensures equal populations of particles on one layer and holes on the other. The model is then reformulated on a spacetime lattice using staggered fermions, and in the absence of a sign problem, simulated using an orthodox hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm. With the coupling strength chosen to be close to a quantum critical point believed to exist for $N_f < N_{fc} \approx 4.8$, a range of $\mu$ below saturation is found where both the carrier density and a particle-hole "excitonic" condensate scale anomalously with increasing $\mu$, much more rapidly that the corresponding quantities in free field theory, while the conventional chiral condensate is strongly suppressed. The corresponding ground state is speculated to be a strongly correlated degenerate fermion system, with a remnant Fermi surface distorted by a superfluid excitonic condensate. The model thus shows qualitatively different behavior to any model with $\mu \ne 0$ previously studied by lattice simulation.

Introduction

Bilayer graphene, consisting of two sheets of carbon atoms, presents a unique playground for studying strongly interacting relativistic fermions. When a voltage bias is applied between the layers, it creates a density of electrons on one sheet and holes on the other. This configuration is theoretically predicted to lead to "excitonic condensation," where electron-hole pairs form a superfluid, potentially opening an energy gap useful for electronic applications.

However, the strong interactions between these particles make standard perturbative mathematical approaches unreliable. Numerical simulations, such as Monte Carlo methods, are typically used to study such systems. A major challenge in this field is the "sign problem," where the introduction of a chemical potential (representing voltage or density) causes simulation probabilities to become complex numbers, rendering standard algorithms ineffective. This study circumvents this issue to explore the behavior of bilayer graphene near a Quantum Critical Point (QCP).

Methodology

To model the system, the researchers employed an effective field theory with $N_f = 4$ flavors of fermions in $2+1$ dimensions. The key innovation to bypass the sign problem was mapping the voltage bias to an "isospin chemical potential." By assigning opposite chemical potentials to different fermion flavors, the total mathematical weight of the system remains real and positive.

The theory was reformulated on a spacetime lattice using staggered fermions and simulated using a standard Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC) algorithm on large lattice volumes (up to $48^3$). The coupling strength was specifically tuned to be near the suspected QCP to investigate non-perturbative, anomalous behavior that deviates from free-field theory.

Results: Anomalous Scaling and Condensate Competition

The simulations revealed a complex interplay between different physical states as the chemical potential $\mu$ increased. A primary finding is the competition between the "chiral" condensate (representing intra-layer pairing) and the "excitonic" condensate (representing inter-layer pairing). As the voltage bias increases, the chiral condensate is aggressively suppressed, while the excitonic condensate and carrier density grow rapidly.

Evolution of condensates and carrier density with chemical potential $\mu$.

As shown in the figure above, the carrier density $n_c$ and the excitonic condensate $\langle \Psi\Psi \rangle$ exhibit anomalous scaling. In a weakly interacting system, carrier density is expected to scale as $\mu^2$; however, this model found a much steeper scaling of $\mu^{3.32}$. Similarly, the excitonic condensate scaled as $\mu^{2.39}$, significantly exceeding the linear scaling predicted by standard BCS theory. These results suggest that the fermions are "self-binding" due to strong many-body effects, creating a ground state characterized as a strongly correlated degenerate fermion system with a distorted Fermi surface.

Discussion and Future Directions

This study marks a significant departure from previously studied lattice models with non-zero chemical potential, identifying a new regime of strongly correlated behavior. Preliminary energy spectrum calculations suggest the voltage bias induces an energy gap, a hallmark of a superfluid or insulating phase.

While these results are promising, the model currently uses a local "contact" interaction rather than long-range Coulomb interactions. Although screening near the QCP may justify this approximation, future work should incorporate long-range effects for greater realism. Additionally, further studies at non-zero momentum ($k \neq 0$) are required to fully confirm the speculated distortion of the Fermi surface and to bridge the gap between these theoretical lattice units and experimental graphene measurements.

Summary updated

Abstract

We formulate a model of ${N}_{f}=4$ flavors of relativistic fermion in $2+1d$ in the presence of a chemical potential $\ensuremath{\mu}$ coupled to two flavor doublets with opposite sign, akin to isospin chemical potential in QCD. This is argued to be an effective theory for low energy electronic excitations in bilayer graphene, in which an applied voltage between the layers ensures equal populations of particles on one layer and holes on the other. The model is then reformulated on a spacetime lattice using staggered fermions, and in the absence of a sign problem, simulated using an orthodox hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm. With the coupling strength chosen to be close to a quantum critical point believed to exist for ${N}_{f}&lt;{N}_{fc}\ensuremath{\approx}4.8$, a range of $\ensuremath{\mu}$ below saturation is found where both the carrier density and a particle-hole ``excitonic'' condensate scale anomalously with increasing $\ensuremath{\mu}$, much more rapidly that the corresponding quantities in free field theory, while the conventional chiral condensate is strongly suppressed. The corresponding ground state is speculated to be a strongly correlated degenerate fermion system, with a remnant Fermi surface distorted by a superfluid excitonic condensate. The model thus shows qualitatively different behavior to any model with $\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\ne}0$ previously studied by lattice simulation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{armour2013monte,
  author = {Wesley Armour and Simon Hands and Costas Strouthos},
  title = {{Monte Carlo study of strongly interacting degenerate fermions: A model for voltage-biased bilayer graphene}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.87.065010},
}
Figure