Monte Carlo simulation of the semimetal-insulator phase transition in monolayer graphene

Wesley Armour, Simon Hands, Costas StrouthosPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A $2+1$-dimensional fermion field theory is proposed as a model for the low-energy electronic excitations in monolayer graphene. The model consists of $N_f=2$ four-component Dirac fermions moving in the plane and interacting via a contact interaction between charge densities. For strong couplings, there is a continuous transition to a Mott insulating phase. We present results of an extensive numerical study of the model's critical region, including the order parameter, its associated susceptibility, and the quasiparticle propagator. The data enable an extraction of the critical exponents at the transition (including the dynamical critical exponent) which are hypothesized to be universal features of a quantum critical point. The relation of our model with others in the literature is discussed along with the implications for physical graphene following from our value of the critical coupling.

Introduction: The Semimetal-Insulator Transition

Graphene is renowned for its "Dirac fermions"—electrons that behave as if they are massless, traveling at a constant fraction of the speed of light. Under standard conditions, graphene acts as a semimetal. However, theoretical predictions suggest that sufficiently strong electrostatic interactions between electrons can trigger a phase transition into a "Mott insulator," where mutual repulsion locks electrons into place.

This transition is a manifestation of chiral symmetry breaking, a concept central to particle physics. Because these interactions are intrinsically "strong" near the transition point, they cannot be accurately described using standard perturbative methods like Feynman diagrams. This study aims to pinpoint the critical coupling (the "tipping point") for this transition and determine the universal critical exponents that govern the physics near this quantum critical point.

Methodology: Lattice Field Theory and HMC

The researchers employed a $2+1$ dimensional fermion field theory (two spatial dimensions plus one time dimension) to model graphene's electronic structure.

  • The Model: A non-covariant version of the Thirring model was used. Unlike previous 3+1D gauge theory formulations, this model remains strictly within the 2D plane of the graphene, simplifying the dynamics while preserving the essential physics.
  • The Simulation: The theory was discretized onto a spacetime lattice and solved using the Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC) algorithm. This "first-principles" numerical approach avoids uncontrolled approximations. The project required approximately 1,000,000 CPU core hours on high-performance computing clusters.
  • Quasiparticle Propagator: By avoiding gauge theory formulations, the authors directly calculated the quasiparticle propagator without the noise inherent in gauge-fixing. This allowed for a direct extraction of the dispersion relation—the relationship between an electron's energy and its momentum.

Results: Identifying the Critical Point

The study involved an extensive numerical analysis across various lattice sizes to account for finite-size effects. Spatial volumes ($L_s$) ranged from $16^2$ to $48^2$, with temporal extents ($L_t$) up to 84.

The chiral condensate $\langle \bar{\chi}\chi \rangle$ (order parameter) as a function of inverse coupling $g^{-2}$ for various (a) spatial volumes and (b) temporal extents. The data shows the transition from the semimetal phase (low $\langle \bar{\chi}\chi \rangle$) to the insulator phase (high $\langle \bar{\chi}\chi \rangle$).

Critical Coupling and Exponents

The transition to an insulating phase was identified at a critical coupling of $g_c^{-2} = 0.609(2)$. The extracted critical exponents, $\delta = 2.66(3)$ and $\beta = 0.71(2)$, define the "universality class" of graphene. Notably, the value of $\delta$ differs significantly from the strong-coupling limit ($\delta \approx 5.5$), indicating that the physics is highly sensitive to the number of electron flavors ($N_f$).

Dynamical Scaling and Fermi Velocity

The dynamical critical exponent was estimated at $z \approx 0.90$. While $z$ is often exactly 1 in relativistic systems, a value of $z < 1$ suggests that quasiparticles in graphene are exceptionally stable. Furthermore, the simulations revealed that quantum interactions "renormalize" the Fermi velocity ($v_F$), slowing electrons to approximately 70% of their non-interacting speed ($v_{FR} \approx 0.7 v_F$) even in the conducting phase.

Physical Implications and Outlook

Mapping these lattice results to physical units yields a critical interaction strength $\lambda_c \approx 2.6$. This provides a predictive framework for different graphene environments:

  • Graphene on $SiO_2$: With $\lambda \approx 1.25$, the model predicts it remains a conductor, consistent with experimental observations.
  • Suspended Graphene: With $\lambda \approx 3.4$, the model predicts an insulating state, supporting the hypothesis that removing the substrate can induce a phase transition.

While the "contact" interaction model captures the core universality, real-world Coulomb forces are long-range ($1/r$). Future work should address whether this distinction alters the critical behavior. Additionally, direct measurement of the dynamical exponent $z$ from dispersion relations on larger lattices is needed to confirm the indirect "hyperscaling" results presented here.

Summary updated

Abstract

A $2+1$-dimensional fermion field theory is proposed as a model for the low-energy electronic excitations in monolayer graphene. The model consists of ${N}_{f}=2$ four-component Dirac fermions moving in the plane and interacting via a contact interaction between charge densities. For strong couplings there is a continuous transition to a Mott insulating phase. We present results of an extensive numerical study of the model's critical region, including the order parameter, its associated susceptibility, and the quasiparticle propagator. The data enable an extraction of the critical exponents at the transition (including the dynamical critical exponent) which are hypothesized to be universal features of a quantum critical point. The relation of our model with others in the literature is discussed along with the implications for physical graphene following from our value of the critical coupling.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{armour2010monte,
  author = {Wesley Armour and Simon Hands and Costas Strouthos},
  title = {{Monte Carlo simulation of the semimetal-insulator phase transition in monolayer graphene}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.81.125105},
}
Figure