Monte Carlo-Based Optical Simulation of Optical Distribution in Deep Brain Tissues Using Sixteen Optical Sources

Xi Yang, Chengpeng Chai, Hongzhi Zuo, Yun-Hsuan Chen, Junhui Shi, Cheng Ma, Mohamad SawanBioengineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses Monte Carlo simulations to explore how different optical source types affect light distribution in a simplified brain model. The goal is to identify optimal light sources for deep brain imaging applications by evaluating their propagation depth and resolution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optical imaging techniques like fNIRS and photoacoustic imaging offer safe and specific ways to study the brain. However, their effectiveness is often hampered by the complex structure of brain tissues, particularly the skull, which can attenuate and distort optical signals. Choosing the right optical source is crucial for maximizing signal penetration and resolution in these challenging environments. While various optical sources exist, there's a lack of systematic studies comparing their performance specifically for brain imaging applications. This paper aims to fill that gap by simulating the optical distribution from sixteen different source types within a multi-layered brain model.

Methods

The core of this research is a Monte Carlo (MC) simulation using the mcxlab MATLAB toolbox. This method is considered the gold standard for optical simulations in biological tissues due to its accuracy and ability to handle complex scattering and absorption phenomena without the limitations of simpler models like the diffusion equation.

The researchers developed a simplified four-layer brain model (scalp, skull, cerebrospinal fluid, and gray matter) with defined optical properties at an 800 nm wavelength. They then simulated the propagation of 10⁸ photons from sixteen distinct optical source types. These sources were categorized into three main groups: point, line, and surface sources, each with specific geometric and intensity distributions (e.g., pencil beam, isotropic, Gaussian, disk, ring).

To quantitatively evaluate the performance of these sources, the paper introduces two key metrics:

  • Optical Energy Percentage (EP): This measures the percentage of light (fluence or absorption) that reaches each tissue layer, indicating the propagating depth.
  • Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM): This metric is used to assess the optical field width, serving as an indicator of resolution.

The analysis involved evaluating EP across layers and then focusing on maximum propagating depth at specific low energy levels (1%, 0.1%, and 0.01% of maximum fluence/absorption) and FWHM at a depth of 12 mm.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a simulated brain model with optical properties derived from existing literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Source type matters significantly: The choice of optical source has a discernible impact on how light penetrates and distributes within brain tissue, influencing both depth and resolution.
  • Layer-specific optimization: The "best" optical source isn't universal; optimal sources vary depending on the specific tissue layer being targeted due to differences in optical properties (absorption and scattering).
  • Depth vs. surface performance: Sources that perform well at the surface (e.g., those with broad diffusion) may not be optimal for deep penetration, and vice-versa.
  • FWHM as a resolution proxy: The FWHM analysis reveals differences in the lateral spread of light, offering insights into the potential resolution achievable with different sources.

Key Results

  • Optical Fluence Percentage (FP): FP generally decreased with depth. The scalp layer received the highest FP (66.48-68.46%), followed by the skull (27.48-29.18%), CSF (2.31-2.47%), and gray matter (1.75-1.87%).
  • Optical Absorption Percentage (AP): AP showed a different trend, decreasing then increasing in the gray matter. Scalp had the highest AP (68.77-70.68%), then skull (25.19-26.81%), CSF (0.51-0.55%), and gray matter (3.61-3.87%).
  • Optimal Sources per Layer:
    • Scalp: Hyperboloid Gaussian, isotropic, and line sources showed the highest FP.
  • Skull: Pencil, ring, and disk sources were top performers for FP.
  • CSF: Spatial frequency Fourier, pencil array, and ring sources led in FP.
  • Gray Matter: Spatial frequency Fourier, pencil, and 1D Fourier sources were best for FP.
  • Deep Propagation Depth: The collimated Gaussian source consistently demonstrated the maximum propagating depth across various low energy levels (1%, 0.1%, 0.01%) for both fluence and absorption. Planar and disk sources also showed good deep penetration.
  • Resolution (FWHM): At a depth of 12 mm, the FWHM of fluence and absorption were similar. However, differences were observed between X and Y axes.
  • Larger diffusion (wider FWHM): Slit, collimated Gaussian, and ring sources on the Y-axis; spatial frequency Fourier, slit, and disk sources on the X-axis.
  • Less diffusion (narrower FWHM): Pencil, angular Gaussian, and 1D Fourier sources on the Y-axis; isotropic, angular Gaussian, and ring sources on the X-axis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Source Size and Distribution: The paper acknowledges that the distribution size of point, line, and surface sources can differ, impacting comparisons. Future work could standardize these or explore the effect of varying sizes.
  • Source Number and Intensity: The current study used single sources. Increasing the number and intensity of sources could be investigated for deeper imaging, while considering optical safety.
  • Experimental Validation: The current work is purely simulation-based. Experimental validation is crucial to confirm these findings in real-world scenarios.
  • Tissue Variability: The study used a simplified brain model with fixed properties. Future research should explore more complex brain models with varying tissue properties and thicknesses.
  • Incident Energy and Distribution: The impact of incident energy and the spatial distribution of multiple sources warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optical-based imaging has improved from early single-location research to further sophisticated imaging in 2D topography and 3D tomography. These techniques have the benefit of high specificity and non-radiative safety for brain detection and therapy. However, their performance is limited by complex tissue structures. To overcome the difficulty in successful brain imaging applications, we conducted a simulation using 16 optical source types within a brain model that is based on the Monte Carlo method. In addition, we propose an evaluation method of the optical propagating depth and resolution, specifically one based on the optical distribution for brain applications. Based on the results, the best optical source types were determined in each layer. The maximum propagating depth and corresponding source were extracted. The optical source propagating field width was acquired in different depths. The maximum and minimum widths, as well as the corresponding source, were determined. This paper provides a reference for evaluating the optical propagating depth and resolution from an optical simulation aspect, and it has the potential to optimize the performance of optical-based techniques.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2024monte,
  author = {Xi Yang and Chengpeng Chai and Hongzhi Zuo and Yun-Hsuan Chen and Junhui Shi and Cheng Ma and Mohamad Sawan},
  title = {{Monte Carlo-Based Optical Simulation of Optical Distribution in Deep Brain Tissues Using Sixteen Optical Sources}},
  booktitle = {Bioengineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/bioengineering11030260},
}
Figure