Monolithic wavelength-selective switches and cross connects with integrated MEMS mirror array

Chao-Hsi Chi, Ming C. WuProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to creating monolithic wavelength-selective switches (WSSs) and cross-connects (WSXCs) on a single silicon-on-insulator (SOI) chip, integrating optical waveguides, gratings, and MEMS micromirrors. This integration promises more flexible and cost-effective WDM networks by enabling wavelength-level switching without complex alignment or external components.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern optical communication networks are experiencing a massive surge in traffic, necessitating higher bandwidth and greater flexibility. Wavelength-Division Multiplexing (WDM) is a key technology for increasing capacity, but managing individual wavelength channels efficiently requires sophisticated switching. Existing solutions for Wavelength-Selective Switches (WSSs) and Wavelength-Selective Cross-Connects (WSXCs) often rely on bulky free-space optics with MEMS or liquid crystal beamsteering, or complex planar lightwave circuits with cascaded thermal switches. These approaches can be expensive, difficult to align, and lack scalability. The authors aim to address this by developing a fully monolithic, integrated solution on a single SOI chip.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the monolithic integration of optical and micro-mechanical components on an SOI substrate using a single etching process.

  • Optical Components: Waveguides, microgratings (for wavelength demultiplexing), and parabolic reflectors (for collimating and focusing light) are fabricated directly on the SOI chip.
  • MEMS Micromirrors: Arrays of micro-electro-mechanical-systems (MEMS) micromirrors are integrated at the focal plane of the optical system. These mirrors are actuated by comb-drive mechanisms (rotary and lateral) to steer the reflected light.
  • Monolithic Fabrication: A key aspect is the "one-step etching process" that fabricates all these components simultaneously, eliminating the need for complex assembly and alignment. This includes using i-line optical lithography and deep reactive ion etching (DRIE).
  • Solid Immersion Micromirror (SIM): To enhance the scanning angle and reduce diffraction loss, a novel solid immersion micromirror design is introduced, which leverages the silicon-air interface and a curved mirror surface.
  • WSXC Architecture: The 4x4 WSXC is built by interconnecting four 1x4 splitters and four 4x1 WSSs on the same chip, using waveguide bends and crossings to route signals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involve testing the fabricated devices with external optical sources and measuring their performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • True Monolithic Integration: The ability to fabricate both complex optical structures (gratings, reflectors) and precise MEMS actuators on the same chip in a single process is a significant engineering feat. This drastically simplifies manufacturing and reduces alignment challenges.
  • MEMS for Wavelength Switching: MEMS micromirrors offer a scalable and efficient way to achieve wavelength-level switching, overcoming limitations of thermal switches (speed, power) and liquid crystals (speed).
  • Solid Immersion Micromirror Advantage: The SIM design shows a promising way to increase the angular deflection of MEMS mirrors, which is crucial for scaling to more ports and finer channel spacing, while also reducing optical losses.
  • WSXC Design Efficiency: The architecture for the 4x4 WSXC, using splitters and WSSs on-chip, demonstrates a compact and functional approach to complex optical routing.

Key Results

  • 1x4 WSS:
    • Chip area: 1x2 cm²
    • Channel spacing: CWDM (20-nm)
    • Fiber-to-fiber insertion loss: 11.7 dB
    • Switching time: 0.5 msec
    • Crosstalk: < -27 dB
  • 4x4 WSXC:
    • Chip area: 3.2x4.6 cm²
    • Fiber-to-fiber insertion loss: 24 dB (includes 6-dB splitting loss)
    • Supports unicast, multicast, and broadcast functions.
  • Tested with six CWDM channels (1460-1580 nm).
  • MEMS Micromirrors:
    • 400-µm-pitched micromirror (rotary comb-drive): Max scan angle of 7.4° at 101 V.
  • 75-µm-pitched micromirror (lateral comb-drive): Max scan angle of 8° at 180 V. This pitch is crucial for scaling to DWDM.
  • Solid Immersion Micromirror: Achieved approximately 3.5 times enhancement of scan angle compared to conventional flat micromirrors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Insertion Loss: The insertion loss for both the WSS (11.7 dB) and WSXC (24 dB) is relatively high. The paper attributes a significant portion of this to grating loss and coupling losses, suggesting improvements could be made with reflective gratings and optimized coupling.
  • Scaling to DWDM: While the 75-µm-pitched micromirror is designed for DWDM (100-GHz spacing), the paper doesn't present experimental results for DWDM operation, only stating its capability. Further work would be needed to demonstrate this.
  • Optical Alignment: Although monolithic, the coupling of light into and out of the chip via fibers still requires precise alignment.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the devices can be further scaled to DWDM (100-GHz) channel spacing. The development of the solid immersion micromirror is also a step towards improved performance for future devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wavelength-selective switches (WSSs) and wavelength-selective cross connects (WSXCs) enable flexible, intelligent wavelength-division-multiplexed (WDM) networks as well as reduce the operating cost. In a 1×N WSS, the wavelengths from the input port can be independently switched to any of the N output ports. WSXC allows switching of optical signals at wavelength level between N input ports and N output ports. Most of the WSS and WSXC reported to date are realized by free-space optical systems with either micro-electro-mechanical-systems (MEMS) or liquid crystal (LC) beamsteering array, or by silica-based planar lightwave circuits with cascaded 2×2 thermal optical switches. In this paper, we report on the approach to monolithically integrate the WSS and WSXC on a single silicon-on-insulator (SOI) chip. Optical waveguides, microgratings, parabolic reflectors, as well as MEMS active switching micromirrors are fabricated on the same substrate using a one-step etching process. We have successfully fabricated a 1×4 WSS with CWDM (20- nm) channel spacing on a 1×2-cm<sup>2</sup> chip, and achieved a fiber-to-fiber insertion loss of 11.7 dB, and a switching time of 0.5 msec. The monolithic 4x4 WSXC is realized by integrating four 4×1 WSSs and four 1×4 multi-mode interference (MMI) splitters on the same wafer. No fiber connections or external splitter are required. The fabricated 4×4 WSXC has a chip area of 3.2×4.6 cm<sup>2</sup> and an insertion loss of 24 dB, including a 6-dB splitting loss. The WSXC supports unicast, multicast, and broadcast functions. The devices can be further scaled to DWDM (100-GHz) channel spacing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chi2006monolithic,
  author = {Chao-Hsi Chi and Ming C. Wu},
  title = {{Monolithic wavelength-selective switches and cross connects with integrated MEMS mirror array}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1117/12.687121},
}
Figure