Monocyte‐to‐Lymphocyte Ratio Was an Independent Factor of the Severity of Spinal Tuberculosis

Liyi Chen, Chong Liu, Tuo Liang, Zhen Ye, Shengsheng Huang, Jiarui Chen, Xuhua Sun, Ming Yi, Jie Jiang, Tianyou Chen, Hao Li, Wuhua Chen, Hao Guo, Yuanlin Yao, Shian Liao, Chaojie Yu, Shaofeng Wu, Binguang Fan, Zhaoping Gan, Xinli ZhanOxidative 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies the Monocyte-to-Lymphocyte Ratio (MLR) as a significant independent factor in diagnosing spinal tuberculosis and assessing its severity. The research proposes a novel nomogram incorporating MLR and other clinical parameters to predict the risk of spinal tuberculosis, offering a potentially more accessible diagnostic tool.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Spinal tuberculosis (STB) poses a significant global health challenge, often presenting with diagnostic difficulties. Traditional methods like sputum smear microscopy have low sensitivity, while bacterial culture and genetic testing are time-consuming or not universally available. Pathological examination, while more definitive, also has limitations in sensitivity. Existing diagnostic approaches for STB are often indirect or rely on invasive procedures. This paper aims to address this diagnostic gap by exploring the potential of MLR, a readily available blood parameter, as a marker for STB diagnosis and severity assessment.

Methods

The researchers employed a retrospective study design, collecting clinical data from 1000 patients. They utilized a two-stage approach: a training set of 700 cases and an external validation set of 300 cases.

Key methodological components include:

  • LASSO Regression: This statistical technique was used to select the most relevant parameters from a comprehensive list of clinical and laboratory data for building a predictive model. LASSO helps in feature selection by shrinking the coefficients of less important variables to zero.
  • Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) Curve Analysis: ROC curves were used to evaluate the diagnostic performance of individual parameters and the developed nomogram, quantifying their ability to discriminate between spinal tuberculosis and non-spinal tuberculosis.
  • Nomogram Construction: Based on the parameters identified by LASSO regression and validated by ROC analysis, a nomogram was constructed. This visual tool allows for the calculation of an individual's risk of having spinal tuberculosis based on their specific parameter values.
  • Model Evaluation: The nomogram's predictive ability and accuracy were rigorously assessed using metrics such as the C-index, calibration curves (to check for agreement between predicted and observed probabilities), ROC curves, and Decision Curve Analysis (DCA) to evaluate its clinical utility.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 1000 clinical cases. This dataset was divided into:

  • Training Set: 700 cases used for developing the predictive model (nomogram).
  • External Validation Set: 300 cases used to independently assess the performance and generalizability of the developed model.

The dataset included:

  • Spinal Tuberculosis Cases: 496 cases.
  • Non-spinal Tuberculosis Cases: 504 cases.

The data collected included general information (gender, age, BMI) and extensive laboratory blood results (CRP, ESR, WBC, HGB, PLT, neutrophil and lymphocyte counts and percentages, monocyte count and percentage, MLR, PMR, PLR, NLR, PNR). Clinical scores such as ODI, VAS, and ASIA were also collected for severity assessment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MLR as a Diagnostic Marker: The study strongly suggests that MLR is not just correlated with inflammation but is a significant, independent factor in diagnosing spinal tuberculosis. This is a crucial finding as MLR is a simple blood test parameter.
  • MLR and Disease Severity: The research demonstrates a clear association between higher MLR values and increased severity of spinal tuberculosis, as indicated by higher ODI and VAS scores. This suggests MLR can provide insights into the extent of the disease.
  • Predictive Nomogram for STB: The development of a nomogram incorporating MLR, age, percentage of monocytes, and PLR offers a practical tool for risk stratification and early identification of individuals at higher risk for spinal tuberculosis. This could streamline diagnostic pathways.
  • Distinguishing STB from Pneumonia: The findings suggest that ESR and CRP, while common inflammatory markers, may have limited diagnostic value for STB itself, potentially helping to differentiate it from community-acquired pneumonia where these markers are also elevated.

Key Results

  • Nomogram Performance: The constructed nomogram demonstrated good predictive ability, with a C-index of 0.801 in the training set and 0.861 in the external validation set. The AUC for MLR in diagnosing spinal tuberculosis was 0.663 in the training set and 0.737 in the validation set.
  • MLR and Severity: MLR was significantly higher in patients with higher ODI scores (≥20) and higher VAS scores (>7), indicating a correlation with disease severity.
  • Independent Factor: MLR was identified as an independent factor for the diagnosis of spinal tuberculosis.
  • Predictor of Active STB: The study suggests MLR may also serve as a predictor of active spinal tuberculosis, with a nomogram for predicting active STB achieving an AUC of 0.69.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Single-Center Study: The research was conducted at a single center, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other populations and healthcare settings.
  • Single Time Point Blood Tests: Blood samples were collected at a single time point. Longitudinal studies with multiple time points would provide more robust data and a clearer understanding of MLR dynamics during treatment and recovery.

Future work could focus on:

  • Multi-center Validation: Conducting similar studies across multiple centers to validate the findings and the nomogram's performance.
  • Longitudinal Studies: Investigating the role of MLR over time to monitor disease progression and treatment response.
  • Integration with Other Biomarkers: Exploring the synergistic effect of MLR with other emerging biomarkers for a more comprehensive diagnostic and prognostic tool.

Summary updated

Abstract

MLR was an independent factor in the diagnosis of spinal tuberculosis and was associated with the severity of spinal tuberculosis. Additionally, MLR may be a predictor of active spinal tuberculosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2022monocytetolymphocyte,
  author = {Liyi Chen and Chong Liu and Tuo Liang and Zhen Ye and Shengsheng Huang and Jiarui Chen and Xuhua Sun and Ming Yi and Jie Jiang and Tianyou Chen and Hao Li and Wuhua Chen and Hao Guo and Yuanlin Yao and Shian Liao and Chaojie Yu and Shaofeng Wu and Binguang Fan and Zhaoping Gan and Xinli Zhan},
  title = {{Monocyte‐to‐Lymphocyte Ratio Was an Independent Factor of the Severity of Spinal Tuberculosis}},
  booktitle = {Oxidative},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1155/2022/7340330},
}
Figure