Monocyte-derived transcriptome signature indicates antibody-dependent cellular phagocytosis as the primary mechanism of vaccine-induced protection against HIV-1

Shida Shangguan, Philip K. Ehrenberg, Aviva Geretz, Lauren K. Yum, Gautam Kundu, Kelly May, Slim Fourati, Krystelle Nganou‐Makamdop, LaTonya D. Williams, Sheetal Sawant, Éric Lewitus, Punnee Pitisuttithum, Sorachai Nitayaphan, Suwat Chariyalertsak, Supachai Rerks‐Ngarm, Morgane Rolland, Daniel C. Douek, Peter B. Gilbert, Georgia D. Tomaras, Nelson L. Michael, Sandhya Vasan, Rasmi ThomasbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper identifies a specific gene expression signature in immune cells that consistently correlates with vaccine-induced protection against HIV-1 across multiple studies. This signature points to antibody-dependent cellular phagocytosis (ADCP) as a key mechanism of protection and suggests monocytes are the primary cell type involved, offering a potential tool for evaluating and developing new HIV vaccines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing an effective HIV vaccine has been a major challenge for decades. While some candidate vaccines have shown partial protection in animal models and limited efficacy in humans (like the RV144 trial), understanding why they work and identifying reliable "correlates of protection" has been difficult. This makes it hard to screen new vaccine candidates and optimize existing ones. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating a previously identified gene signature that showed promise in non-human primate (NHP) studies and determining if it holds true as a correlate of protection in human trials, and if so, what biological mechanism it represents.

Methods

The researchers employed several advanced techniques:

  • RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq): Used to analyze gene expression profiles from blood samples of participants in various HIV vaccine trials.
  • Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA): A computational method to determine if a predefined set of genes shows statistically significant, concordant differences between two biological states (e.g., infected vs. uninfected, high vs. low ADCP).
  • Composite Gene Expression Score (GES): A novel analytical approach developed to quantify the overall expression of the identified gene signature, making it comparable across different studies and platforms.
  • CITE-seq (Cellular Indexing of Transcriptomes and Epitopes by Sequencing): A cutting-edge single-cell technology that simultaneously measures mRNA expression and cell surface protein markers, allowing researchers to pinpoint the specific cell types responsible for the observed gene signature.
  • Antibody-Dependent Cellular Phagocytosis (ADCP) Assay: A functional assay to measure the ability of antibodies to promote the engulfment of pathogens by immune cells.

Datasets

The study utilized data from several human and non-human primate (NHP) HIV vaccine trials:

  • NHP Studies: Data from various adenovirus-based (Ad26) and ALVAC-based SIV/SHIV challenge models.
  • RV144 Human Trial: Data from the partially protective ALVAC/gp120 vaccine trial conducted in Thailand.
  • HVTN 505 Human Trial: Data from a DNA/rAd5 HIV-1 vaccine trial that did not show overall efficacy.
  • RV306 Immunogenicity Trial: Data from a trial using a similar vaccine regimen to RV144, used to investigate ADCP responses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Universal Signature of Protection: The identified gene signature is not specific to one vaccine type or species; it consistently appears in studies where vaccines conferred protection, regardless of the vaccine platform or animal model.
  • ADCP as a Key Mechanism: The gene signature strongly correlates with Antibody-Dependent Cellular Phagocytosis (ADCP), suggesting that this immune mechanism is a crucial component of vaccine-induced protection against HIV.
  • Monocytes are the "Workhorses": Single-cell analysis revealed that the genes within this signature are primarily expressed in monocytes, a type of white blood cell known for its phagocytic capabilities, directly linking them to ADCP.
  • A Predictive Tool: The composite gene expression score (GES) derived from this signature can predict HIV-1 infection risk and vaccine efficacy, offering a potential biomarker for evaluating vaccine performance.
  • Failed Trials Lack the Signature: Crucially, the gene signature was absent in a human trial (HVTN 505) that failed to demonstrate efficacy, further validating its role as a correlate of protection.

Key Results

  • The gene signature was significantly enriched in uninfected individuals/animals across multiple NHP and human vaccine studies that showed partial protection.
  • The signature was absent in the HVTN 505 trial, which did not show efficacy.
  • In the RV144 trial, higher GES was associated with lower odds of HIV acquisition and increased vaccine efficacy.
  • The GES was a stronger correlate of reduced risk than previously identified correlates like V1V2-specific IgG antibodies.
  • The gene signature strongly correlated with ADCP responses in human trials.
  • Single-cell analysis identified monocytes as the primary cell type expressing the signature genes, which are key effector cells for ADCP.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cellular Origin Nuances: While monocytes were identified as the primary source, the study acknowledges that other non-lymphoid cell populations might also contribute to vaccine responses, and the analysis of PBMCs might miss granulocyte contributions.
  • Further Validation: The authors propose that this gene signature can serve as a tool to screen novel vaccine candidates and accelerate development, implying the need for further validation in ongoing and future trials.
  • Mechanism Exploration: While ADCP is implicated, further investigation into the specific roles of the enriched genes and their pathways (e.g., myeloid leukocyte activation, lysosome function) could provide deeper mechanistic insights.
  • Broader Applicability: The study suggests that similar analytical tools and approaches could be applied to other ongoing HIV vaccine clinical trials for more systematic meta-analyses and candidate selection.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract A gene signature previously correlated with mosaic adenovirus 26 vaccine protection in simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) and SHIV challenge models in non-human primates (NHP). In this report we investigated presence of this signature as a correlate of reduced risk in human clinical trials and potential mechanism for protection. The absence of this gene signature in the DNA/rAd5 human vaccine trial which did not show efficacy, strengthens our hypothesis that this signature is only enriched in studies that demonstrated protection. This gene signature was enriched in the partially effective RV144 human trial that administered the ALVAC/protein vaccine, and we find that the signature associates with both decreased risk of HIV-1 acquisition and increased vaccine efficacy. Total RNA-seq in a clinical trial that used the same vaccine regimen as the RV144 HIV vaccine implicated antibody-dependent cellular phagocytosis (ADCP) as a potential mechanism of vaccine protection. CITE-seq profiling of 53 surface markers and transcriptomes of 53,777 single cells from the same trial, showed that genes in this signature were primarily expressed in cells belonging to the myeloid lineage including monocytes, which are major effector cells for ADCP. The consistent association of this transcriptome signature with vaccine efficacy represents a tool both to identify potential mechanisms, as with ADCP here, and to screen novel approaches to accelerate development of new vaccine candidates.
BibTeX
@misc{shangguan2021monocyte,
  author = {Shida Shangguan and Philip K. Ehrenberg and Aviva Geretz and Lauren K. Yum and Gautam Kundu and Kelly May and Slim Fourati and Krystelle Nganou‐Makamdop and LaTonya D. Williams and Sheetal Sawant and Éric Lewitus and Punnee Pitisuttithum and Sorachai Nitayaphan and Suwat Chariyalertsak and Supachai Rerks‐Ngarm and Morgane Rolland and Daniel C. Douek and Peter B. Gilbert and Georgia D. Tomaras and Nelson L. Michael and Sandhya Vasan and Rasmi Thomas},
  title = {{Monocyte-derived transcriptome signature indicates antibody-dependent cellular phagocytosis as the primary mechanism of vaccine-induced protection against HIV-1}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.05.12.443737},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure