Monitoring Variability in Melt Pool Spatiotemporal Dynamics (VIMPS): Towards Proactive Humping Detection in Additive Manufacturing

Mohamed Abubakr Hassan, Mahmoud Hassan, Chi-Guhn Lee, A. SadekJournal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces VIMPS, a novel proactive monitoring system for additive manufacturing that detects "humping" defects by analyzing the variability in melt pool solidification dynamics. VIMPS can predict humping up to 10 seconds before visible defects appear, significantly outperforming existing reactive methods that detect defects only after they've occurred.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Additive manufacturing (AM), particularly Direct Energy Deposition (DED), offers high productivity for complex parts. However, DED processes are prone to defects like "humping," where the melt pool elongates and solidifies unevenly, leading to wavy structures and reduced geometric accuracy. Current methods for detecting humping are largely reactive, meaning they only identify the defect after it has already impacted the part's geometry. This late detection limits the ability to correct the issue in real-time, often resulting in scrap parts or requiring costly post-processing. The challenge is to develop a proactive system that can anticipate humping before it causes significant geometric errors, enabling timely intervention and improving overall process control and quality.

Methods

The core innovation is the Variability of Instantaneous Melt Pool Spatiotemporal Dynamics (VIMPS) indicator. VIMPS is designed to capture early-stage humping by focusing on spatiotemporal abnormalities rather than just spatial ones. The methodology involves:

  1. Infrared (IR) Imaging: Capturing high-speed IR video of the melt pool during the DED process.
  2. Region of Interest (ROI) Analysis: Focusing on the melt pool area within the IR frames.
  3. Average Pixel Intensity (API): Calculating the average pixel intensity within the ROI. API is inversely correlated with the melt pool's liquid phase dominance and directly with the solidification front speed.
  4. Rolling Variance of API (APIRV): Quantifying the fluctuations in API over a rolling window. This captures the cyclic elongation and solidification characteristic of humping.
  5. Rolling Mean of API (APIRM): Used to smooth the APIRV, making it less sensitive to noise and unrelated variances.
  6. APIRVxM: A combined metric to further enhance robustness, especially in early build layers.
  7. VIMPS Calculation: A final rolling mean of APIRVxM, providing a stable and interpretable indicator of humping.

Essentially, VIMPS tracks how the melt pool's solidification front speed varies over time, which is a direct consequence of the cyclic elongation and swelling that precedes visible humping defects.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from a 3kW TRUMPF TruDiode laser system. Austenitic nickel-chromium stainless steel powder was used. The experiments involved printing nine circular builds (25 mm height and diameter) under varied laser powers (650W, 850W) and traverse speeds (600 mm/min, 360 mm/min). The focus was on thin-walled, single-bead multi-layer prints, which are more susceptible to humping. The IR data was captured using a FLIR SC8300 MWIR camera at 233 Hz. As-printed parts were also imaged using a ZEISS Smartzoom 5 microscope for geometrical assessment. No specific pre-existing datasets were used for training; rather, the VIMPS indicator was developed and validated on this experimental dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proactive vs. Reactive Detection: The most significant insight is that monitoring spatiotemporal dynamics (how things change over time and space) allows for much earlier detection of humping than solely looking at spatial abnormalities (what the melt pool looks like at a single moment).
  • Solidification Front Variability as a Precursor: The variability in the melt pool's solidification front speed (VIMPS) is a direct indicator of the cyclic elongation and swelling that leads to humping. This variability is present before the melt pool detaches or forms significant geometric irregularities.
  • API as a Proxy for Solidification Dynamics: Average Pixel Intensity (API) in IR images, when analyzed over time, effectively reflects the changes in the melt pool's liquid-to-solid phase transition, making it a suitable proxy for solidification front dynamics.
  • The Power of Variance: Quantifying the variance of API (APIRV) is key to capturing the oscillatory nature of humping, while smoothing it (VIMPS) makes it robust and interpretable.
  • Humping Complexity: The study highlights that simple correlations between process parameters (like laser power or speed) and humping activation are difficult to establish due to the complex, non-linear interplay of physical factors. This underscores the need for real-time monitoring.

Key Results

  • Early Detection: VIMPS successfully predicted humping up to 10 seconds before any significant geometric defects were observed.
  • Superiority over SOTA: Existing state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods, which rely on detecting spatial abnormalities like melt pool detachment, only detected humping 20 seconds after significant geometric defects had occurred. This represents a 30-second improvement in detection latency.
  • Reduced Latency: The reduced detection latency is crucial for enabling proactive interventions, improving productivity, and minimizing scrap.
  • Consistency: VIMPS demonstrated higher consistency in detecting humping events compared to detachment-based SOTA methods, which can be delayed or missed in subsequent occurrences.
  • Computational Efficiency: VIMPS is computationally efficient and can be implemented using existing hardware, making it practical for industrial integration.
  • Qualitative Validation: IR images and surface topography analysis confirmed the correlation between VIMPS signals and humping-induced defects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • ROI Definition: The study notes that future work could explore excluding the melt pool head from the ROI to see how it affects API signal quality, as the head can sometimes show contradictory SF dynamics.
  • Elongation Cycle Time: While Test #2 showed good geometrical accuracy, it still exhibited some elongation cycles, albeit with a significantly longer cycle time. This suggests that while VIMPS can detect humping, understanding the degree of humping and its impact might require further refinement.
  • Segmentation Complexity for SOTA: The paper highlights the significant complexity of current SOTA methods that rely on image segmentation (e.g., using SAM), which often requires human intervention and is prone to errors, further emphasizing VIMPS's advantage in simplicity and robustness.
  • Generalizability: While the study focused on stainless steel, future work could investigate the applicability of VIMPS to other materials and DED process variations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Humping is a common defect in direct energy deposition processes that reduces the geometric integrity of printed products. The available literature on humping detection is deemed reactive, as they focus on detecting late-stage melt pool spatial abnormalities. Therefore, this work introduces a novel, proactive indicator designed to detect early-stage spatiotemporal abnormalities. Specifically, the proposed indicator monitors the variability of instantaneous melt pool solidification-front speed (VIMPS). The solidification front dynamics quantify the intensity of cyclic melt pool elongation induced by early-stage humping. VIMPS tracks the solidification front dynamics based on the variance in the melt pool infrared radiations. Qualitative and quantitive analysis of the collected infrared data confirms VIMPS’s utility in reflecting the intricate humping-induced dynamics and defects. Experimental results proved VIMPS’ proactivity. By capturing early spatiotemporal abnormalities, VIMPS predicted humping by up to 10 s before any significant geometric defects. In contrast, current spatial abnormality-based methods failed to detect humping until 20 s after significant geometric defects had occurred. VIMPS’ proactive detection capabilities enable effective direct energy deposition control, boosting the process’s productivity and quality.
BibTeX
@article{hassan2024monitoring,
  author = {Mohamed Abubakr Hassan and Mahmoud Hassan and Chi-Guhn Lee and A. Sadek and Chi-Guhn Lee and Ahmad Sadek},
  title = {{Monitoring Variability in Melt Pool Spatiotemporal Dynamics (VIMPS): Towards Proactive Humping Detection in Additive Manufacturing}},
  journal = {Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jmmp8030114},
}
Figure