Monitoring and influencing factors of grassland livestock overload in Xinjiang from 1982 to 2020

Lisha Ma, Jianghua Zheng, J.e. Perez Peñ, Xianghua Xiao, Yujia Liu, Liang Liu, Wanqiang Han, Gangyong Li, Jianli ZhangFrontiers in Plant Science 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive 39-year (1982–2020) analysis of Xinjiang’s grassland carrying capacity, revealing that while the land's ability to support livestock has generally increased, it is being outpaced by rising livestock numbers. Using remote sensing and geographic detectors, the researchers identified precipitation and altitude as the primary drivers of this delicate balance, warning that the region's carrying capacity is likely to decline in the future.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Xinjiang is a critical hub for China’s livestock industry, but its arid and semi-arid ecosystems are notoriously fragile. To prevent land degradation and desertification, managers need to maintain a "grass-livestock balance"—ensuring the number of grazing animals doesn't exceed what the vegetation can naturally regenerate.

The challenge is that this balance isn't a static number; it fluctuates wildly based on climate change, seasonal cycles, and human activity. Previous studies often lacked the long-term, multi-scale data needed to see the "big picture." This paper fills that gap by quantifying the theoretical carrying capacity (CC)—the maximum sustainable population of livestock—and comparing it to actual livestock data across nearly four decades.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage modeling approach:

  • Net Primary Productivity (NPP) Estimation: They used the CASA (Carnegie-Ames-Stanford Approach) model, which integrates NDVI (vegetation greenness), solar radiation, temperature, and precipitation.
  • Data Fusion: To create a seamless 39-year timeline, they used linear regression to bridge two different satellite datasets: GIMMS NDVI (1982–2015) and MODIS NDVI (2000–2020).
  • Carrying Capacity Calculation: NPP was converted into aboveground biomass and then into "Sheep Units" (SU), a standard metric where one sheep unit represents the daily forage intake of a 50kg female sheep.
  • Trend & Driver Analysis: They used Sen’s slope and Mann-Kendall tests to identify temporal trends, the Hurst index to predict future shifts, and the Geographic Detector method to quantify how much factors like GDP, precipitation, and soil quality actually influence the results.

Datasets

  • Remote Sensing: GIMMS NDVI 3g and NASA MOD13A3 (MODIS).
  • Climate & Topography: Monthly temperature/precipitation data (1km resolution) and ASTER GDEM (30m resolution).
  • Socio-economic: Population density and spatialized GDP datasets.
  • Ground Truth: 617 field biomass samples collected between 2018 and 2020 were used to validate the NPP model’s accuracy ($R^2 = 0.746$).
  • Livestock Statistics: Actual livestock counts from the "Statistical Yearbook of Xinjiang" (1988–2020).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The July Peak: Carrying capacity is highly seasonal. It peaks in July (averaging 25.59 SU/hm²) and is virtually non-existent in winter. This highlights the extreme pressure on ranchers to provide supplemental feed during the cold months.
  • The Productivity Gradient: There is a clear "North > South" and "East > West" gradient in productivity. The Tianshan and Altai mountains act as the region's primary forage engines, while the areas surrounding the Taklamakan Desert offer minimal support.
  • Interaction Effects: One of the most interesting findings from the Geographic Detector is that factors don't act alone. The interaction between annual precipitation and altitude has a much higher explanatory power than either factor in isolation.
  • Future Reversal: While the historical trend (1982–2020) shows an increase in carrying capacity due to improved climate conditions, the Hurst index suggests this trend will likely reverse, meaning the land may become less productive in the coming years.

Key Results

  • Overall Trend: The theoretical carrying capacity showed an upward trend over the study period, with an average value of 7.48 SU/hm².
  • Overload Status: From 1988 to 2020, the average grass-livestock balance index was 2.61%, indicating a state of mild overloading.
  • County-Level Strain: The number of "overloaded" counties (where livestock exceeds the land's capacity) rose from 46 in 1988 to 58 in 2020.
  • Primary Drivers: Annual precipitation ($q=0.49$) and elevation ($q=0.34$) were the dominant natural drivers. Socio-economic factors like GDP and population density had a much smaller direct impact ($q < 0.10$).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for improvement:

  • Resolution Constraints: The 1km resolution of the vegetation data may not capture fine-grained variations in specific pasture types.
  • Biological Variables: The current model does not account for forage loss due to rodents, insects, or plant diseases, which can significantly reduce the actual available biomass.
  • Management Factors: Future research should incorporate the distance to water sources and specific grazing durations (rotational grazing) to provide more precise "safe ecological limits" for local policymakers.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is crucial to estimate the theoretical carrying capacity of grasslands in Xinjiang to attain a harmonious balance between grassland and livestock, thereby fostering sustainable development in the livestock industry. However, there has been a lack of quantitative assessments that consider long-term, multi-scale grass-livestock balance and its impacts in the region. This study utilized remote sensing and empirical models to assess the theoretical livestock carrying capacity of grasslands. The multi-scale spatiotemporal variations of the theoretical carrying capacity in Xinjiang from 1982 to 2020 were analyzed using the Sen and Mann-Kendall tests, as well as the Hurst index. The study also examined the county-level grass-livestock balance and inter-annual trends. Additionally, the study employed the geographic detector method to explore the influencing factors. The results showed that: (1) The overall theoretical livestock carrying capacity showed an upward trend from 1982 to 2020; The spatial distribution gradually decreased from north to south and from east to west. In seasonal scale from large to small is: growing season &amp;gt; summer &amp;gt; spring &amp;gt; autumn &amp;gt; winter; at the monthly scale, the strongest livestock carrying capacity is in July. The different grassland types from largest to smallest are: meadow &amp;gt; alpine subalpine meadow &amp;gt; plain steppe &amp;gt; desert steppe &amp;gt; alpine subalpine steppe. In the future, the theoretical livestock carrying capacity of grassland will decrease. (2) From 1988 to 2020, the average grass-livestock balance index in Xinjiang was 2.61%, showing an overall increase. At the county level, the number of overloaded counties showed an overall increasing trend, rising from 46 in 1988 to 58 in 2020. (3) Both single and interaction factors of geographic detectors showed that annual precipitation, altitude and soil organic matter were the main drivers of spatiotemporal dynamics of grassland load in Xinjiang. The results of this study can provide scientific guidance and decision-making basis for achieving coordinated and sustainable development of grassland resources and animal husbandry in the region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2024monitoring,
  author = {Lisha Ma and Jianghua Zheng and J.E. Perez Peñ and Xianghua Xiao and Yujia Liu and Liang Liu and Wanqiang Han and Gangyong Li and Jianli Zhang},
  title = {{Monitoring and influencing factors of grassland livestock overload in Xinjiang from 1982 to 2020}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2024.1340566},
}
Figure