Moleculo Long-Read Sequencing Facilitates Assembly and Genomic Binning from Complex Soil Metagenomes

Richard White, Eric Bottos, Taniya Roy Chowdhury, Jeremy Zucker, Colin Brislawn, Carrie Nicora, Sarah Fansler, Kurt R. Glaesemann, Kevin Glass, Janet JanssonmSystems 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the use of Moleculo synthetic long-read sequencing to overcome the significant challenge of assembling complex soil metagenomes. By generating longer, more accurate DNA fragments, Moleculo technology dramatically improves the ability to reconstruct microbial genomes from diverse soil communities, enabling deeper insights into their functional roles and interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil metagenomics, the study of microbial communities directly from environmental samples, is crucial for understanding fundamental ecological processes. However, soil ecosystems are incredibly complex, harboring billions of microbial cells with vast genetic diversity. This complexity makes it extremely difficult to assemble complete or even partial microbial genomes from short DNA sequencing reads. Current short-read sequencing technologies often result in fragmented assemblies, with a large proportion of the data remaining unassembled and uncharacterized. This "grand challenge" of soil metagenomics limits our understanding of microbial functions, ecological roles, and responses to environmental changes.

Methods

The researchers employed Moleculo synthetic long-read sequencing technology as their primary innovation. This technology generates DNA fragments significantly longer than standard short-read sequencing (over 1.5 kbp, with many exceeding 10 kbp), which are then subassembled. They compared this approach to traditional short-read (SR, ~100 bp) and rapid-mode reads (RMR, ~250 bp) sequencing.

Key methodological steps included:

  • Hybrid Assembly: Combining data from SR, RMR, and Moleculo reads using various assembly algorithms (MEGAHIT, TruSeq long-read assembler, CAP3, minimus2) to create a comprehensive assembly.
  • Metagenomic Binning: Using the assembled contigs to group DNA sequences belonging to individual microbial genomes. They utilized the MaxBin system for this purpose, which relies on coverage and composition to identify potential genome bins.
  • Metatranscriptomic Analysis: Mapping RNA sequencing (metatranscriptome) reads back to the assembled contigs and genome bins to identify which genes and microbes were actively expressed.
  • Functional Annotation: Assigning functions to genes using databases like MetaCyc, KEGG, and COG to understand the metabolic capabilities of the reconstructed genomes.
  • Taxonomic Classification: Determining the identity of the microbes using RefSeq and JspeciesWS.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples from the Kansas native prairie. They analyzed existing metagenomic sequence data from the Joint Genome Institute (JGI) and generated new data using SR, RMR, and Moleculo sequencing. Additionally, they used three replicate metatranscriptomes from the same parent soil to assess gene expression.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Longer Reads are Game-Changers for Soil Metagenomes: The core insight is that the increased contiguity provided by Moleculo's long reads is essential for resolving the complexity of soil microbial communities, which short reads struggle with.
  • Moleculo Enables Unprecedented Genomic Resolution: The technology allows for the reconstruction of a significantly higher number of long contigs and, crucially, enables the binning of a large number of microbial genomes from a single, complex sample.
  • Functional Insights from Active Microbes: By combining metagenomic assembly with metatranscriptomic data, the researchers could distinguish between metabolically active and potentially dormant or relic microbial populations within the soil.
  • Discovery of Novel Genomes: The improved assembly and binning capabilities led to the recovery of novel microbial genomes, including the first complete genome of a "Candidatus Pseudomonas sp. strain JKJ-1" from a native soil metagenome.

Key Results

  • Assembly Improvement: Moleculo sequencing alone yielded over 5,600 reads >10 kbp, with >95% of unassembled reads mapping to contigs >1.5 kbp. A hybrid assembly of all data produced over 10,000 contigs >10 kbp.
  • Genome Binning Success: Moleculo subassembly enabled the binning of 129 microbial genome bins, with higher average completeness compared to SR and RMR assemblies.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: 95% of predicted genes (based on EC numbers) in the Moleculo assembly were found to be expressed in at least one soil sample.
  • Active vs. Dormant Microbes: While high-abundance Verrucomicrobia showed low transcriptional activity, low-abundance Acidobacteria were highly transcriptionally active, suggesting different ecological roles or states.
  • First Complete Soil Genome: The study successfully obtained the first complete genome from a native soil metagenome, "Candidatus Pseudomonas sp. strain JKJ-1."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cost: The paper acknowledges that Moleculo library preparation is currently more expensive (~10x) than standard shotgun libraries.
  • Hybrid Approach Recommendation: For large studies, they recommend a hybrid approach: using standard metagenomic sequencing for most samples and adding a smaller number of Moleculo libraries for complex ecosystems to optimize costs. However, if cost is not a constraint, incorporating Moleculo data is beneficial for any environmental sample metagenome.
  • Assembler Choice: The quality of Moleculo assemblies can be influenced by the choice of assembler used for subassembly.
  • Future Work: The authors anticipate and encourage the application of Moleculo technology for resolving highly complex microbial ecosystems across various sample types and for multi-omics data integration (metaproteomics, metatranscriptomics). They suggest that even more complete genomes could be obtained from lower-complexity samples or by adding more Moleculo data for high-complexity samples.

Summary updated

Abstract

Soil metagenomics has been touted as the "grand challenge" for metagenomics, as the high microbial diversity and spatial heterogeneity of soils make them unamenable to current assembly platforms. Here, we aimed to improve soil metagenomic sequence assembly by applying the Moleculo synthetic long-read sequencing technology. In total, we obtained 267 Gbp of raw sequence data from a native prairie soil; these data included 109.7 Gbp of short-read data (~100 bp) from the Joint Genome Institute (JGI), an additional 87.7 Gbp of rapid-mode read data (~250 bp), plus 69.6 Gbp (>1.5 kbp) from Moleculo sequencing. The Moleculo data alone yielded over 5,600 reads of >10 kbp in length, and over 95% of the unassembled reads mapped to contigs of >1.5 kbp. Hybrid assembly of all data resulted in more than 10,000 contigs over 10 kbp in length. We mapped three replicate metatranscriptomes derived from the same parent soil to the Moleculo subassembly and found that 95% of the predicted genes, based on their assignments to Enzyme Commission (EC) numbers, were expressed. The Moleculo subassembly also enabled binning of >100 microbial genome bins. We obtained via direct binning the first complete genome, that of "<i>Candidatus</i> Pseudomonas sp. strain JKJ-1" from a native soil metagenome. By mapping metatranscriptome sequence reads back to the bins, we found that several bins corresponding to low-relative-abundance <i>Acidobacteria</i> were highly transcriptionally active, whereas bins corresponding to high-relative-abundance <i>Verrucomicrobia</i> were not. These results demonstrate that Moleculo sequencing provides a significant advance for resolving complex soil microbial communities. <b>IMPORTANCE</b> Soil microorganisms carry out key processes for life on our planet, including cycling of carbon and other nutrients and supporting growth of plants. However, there is poor molecular-level understanding of their functional roles in ecosystem stability and responses to environmental perturbations. This knowledge gap is largely due to the difficulty in culturing the majority of soil microbes. Thus, use of culture-independent approaches, such as metagenomics, promises the direct assessment of the functional potential of soil microbiomes. Soil is, however, a challenge for metagenomic assembly due to its high microbial diversity and variable evenness, resulting in low coverage and uneven sampling of microbial genomes. Despite increasingly large soil metagenome data volumes (>200 Gbp), the majority of the data do not assemble. Here, we used the cutting-edge approach of synthetic long-read sequencing technology (Moleculo) to assemble soil metagenome sequence data into long contigs and used the assemblies for binning of genomes. <b>Author Video</b>: An author video summary of this article is available.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{white2016moleculo,
  author = {Richard White and Eric Bottos and Taniya Roy Chowdhury and Jeremy Zucker and Colin Brislawn and Carrie Nicora and Sarah Fansler and Kurt R. Glaesemann and Kevin Glass and Janet Jansson},
  title = {{Moleculo Long-Read Sequencing Facilitates Assembly and Genomic Binning from Complex Soil Metagenomes}},
  booktitle = {mSystems},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1128/msystems.00045-16},
}
Figure