Molecular insights into the substrate recognition and quasi-unidirectional catalysis of OpaE, an atypical fungal enzyme from the Asp/Glu racemase family

Xuehua Zheng, Zhiyong Guo, Leyao Chen, Haowen Wang, Johannes Freitag, Aitao Li, Gert Bange, Shu‐Ming Li, Liujuan ZhengJournal of Biological Chemistry 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study unveils the crystal structure and catalytic mechanism of OpaE, a fungal enzyme from the Asp/Glu racemase family. Despite a symmetrical structure typical of bidirectional enzymes, OpaE exhibits "quasi-unidirectional" D-to-L conversion, achieving ~90% product yield. This bias arises from subtle structural adaptations that favor D-isomer binding and catalysis, offering insights into enzyme evolution and potential biotechnological applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Asp/Glu racemase family of enzymes is well-known for its role in interconverting L- and D-amino acids, crucial for processes like bacterial cell wall synthesis. These enzymes typically exhibit bidirectional activity, meaning they catalyze both L-to-D and D-to-L conversions with similar efficiency. This is often attributed to their pseudosymmetrical structures, which present minimal differences to both substrate isomers. However, the recent discovery of OpaE, a fungal enzyme from this family, presented a puzzle: it catalyzes the D-to-L conversion of specific nonribosomal peptide derivatives with a strong preference, a phenomenon termed "quasi-unidirectional" catalysis. The underlying structural and mechanistic basis for this unusual unidirectional bias in an otherwise symmetrically structured enzyme family remained poorly understood. This paper aims to elucidate these molecular details, shedding light on how OpaE achieves its specific catalytic outcome and its evolutionary implications.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to investigate OpaE:

  • X-ray Crystallography: The crystal structure of OpaE was determined at 2.65 Å resolution to understand its overall architecture.
  • Biochemical Assays: Catalytic activity was measured using both D- and L-forms of the substrate (15-epi-oxepinamide E and oxepinamide E, respectively) under varying enzyme and substrate concentrations to quantify the D-to-L preference.
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis: Key cysteine residues (Cys90 and Cys199) were mutated to alanine to confirm their essential role in catalysis.
  • Molecular Docking: Computational docking was used to predict how the substrate binds to the enzyme's active site.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: MD simulations were performed to explore the dynamic behavior of the enzyme-substrate complex and to assess the stability of different binding poses and catalytic distances.
  • Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics (QM/MM) Metadynamics Simulations: These advanced simulations were used to map the free energy landscape of the D-to-L and L-to-D conversion pathways, providing detailed insights into the reaction mechanism, transition states, and energy barriers.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: A phylogenetic tree was constructed to understand OpaE's evolutionary relationship to other Asp/Glu racemases and to identify conserved residues and potential adaptations.

Datasets

The study utilized the following:

  • Protein Data Bank (PDB): The crystal structure of OpaE was deposited under PDB ID: 9QBX. Structures of homologous enzymes like Klebsiella pneumoniae allantoin racemase (KpAlIR, PDB ID: 3QVJ) and Pseudomonas fluorescens allantoin racemase (PDB ID: 5LG5) were used for structural comparisons.
  • UniProt Database: Used for bioinformatics analysis to identify and classify Asp/Glu racemase family enzymes and their distribution across different organisms.
  • No newly introduced benchmarks or datasets were reported.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structural Symmetry vs. Catalytic Asymmetry: The most striking finding is that OpaE, despite possessing a pseudosymmetrical structure characteristic of bidirectional racemases, exhibits a strong preference for D-to-L conversion. This challenges the assumption that structural symmetry directly dictates bidirectional catalysis.
  • Subtle Adaptations Drive Specificity: The "quasi-unidirectional" activity isn't due to a completely different active site architecture but rather subtle structural divergences. These include expanded hydrophobic pockets and loop shifts that optimize the binding and orientation of the D-isomer.
  • Catalytic Dyad Identified: Cysteine residues Cys90 and Cys199 were confirmed as the essential catalytic dyad, crucial for the epimerization reaction.
  • Evolutionary Divergence: OpaE represents a distinct evolutionary path within the Asp/Glu racemase family, likely driven by the need to process complex fungal nonribosomal peptide substrates. This suggests that fungal enzymes in this family may have evolved unique adaptations.
  • Mechanism of Unidirectionality: QM/MM simulations revealed that the D-to-L conversion pathway has a lower energy barrier, greater thermodynamic favorability, and a more stable intermediate compared to the L-to-D pathway. This kinetic and thermodynamic bias is the key to the "quasi-unidirectional" catalysis.

Key Results

  • OpaE catalyzes the D-to-L conversion of 15-epi-oxepinamide E to oxepinamide E with approximately 91% conversion to the L-form, while the L-to-D conversion yields less than 10% of the D-form.
  • Mutations of Cys90 and Cys199 to serine (C90S, C199S) or double mutation (C90S/C199S) drastically reduced or abolished epimerization activity, confirming their catalytic role.
  • Structural analysis revealed expanded hydrophobic pockets (HP1 and HP2) and displaced loop regions in OpaE compared to bacterial homologs, facilitating the accommodation of bulkier fungal peptide substrates.
  • QM/MM simulations showed that the D-to-L conversion has a lower free energy barrier (8.2 kcal/mol for the first step, 9.7 kcal/mol for the second) compared to the L-to-D conversion (8.5 kcal/mol for the first step, 11.4 kcal/mol for the second). The D-to-L reaction is also thermodynamically favored, with an exothermic release of 1.3 kcal/mol.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cocrystallization Challenges: The study was unable to obtain crystals of the enzyme-substrate complex, necessitating the use of docking and MD simulations for predicting binding modes. While these methods provide valuable insights, direct structural evidence of substrate binding would be ideal.
  • Fungal Context: While OpaE is identified as a fungal enzyme, its specific role in the broader context of fungal secondary metabolism and its interaction with other enzymes in the oxepinamide pathway could be further explored.
  • Biotechnological Potential: The authors highlight OpaE's potential for biotechnological applications in chiral substrate transformations. Future work could focus on engineering OpaE for specific industrial applications, such as in peptide synthesis or the modification of natural products. Further investigation into the evolutionary trajectory and functional diversification of fungal Asp/Glu racemases is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Enzymes of the Asp/Glu racemase family, mostly found in bacteria, typically catalyze bidirectional reactions with similar rate because of their pseudosymmetrical structure and minimal differences between substrate isomers. We recently identified OpaE, an atypical fungal enzyme that catalyzes the d-to-l conversion of nonribosomal peptide derivatives in oxepinamide E/F biosynthesis from Aspergillus ustus. However, the structure and catalytic mechanism remained poorly understood. In this study, we present the crystal structure of OpaE, which reveals a pseudosymmetrical architecture characteristic of bidirectional racemases, yet it catalyzes the "quasi-unidirectional" d-to-l conversion, yielding approximately 90% of the l-form. This "quasi-unidirectional" activity arises from structural divergence between substrate isomers, which leads to differences in binding modes, energy barriers, and intermediate stabilities, as well as distinct thermodynamic properties, as revealed by crystal structure, docking, molecular dynamics, and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics-based metadynamics simulations. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that OpaE has evolved specific structural adaptations, including hydrophobic pockets and loop shifts, to optimize substrate binding and catalysis, which ultimately favor "quasi-unidirectional" activity and reflect a distinct evolutionary path. In summary, our study deepens our understanding of the structural and mechanistic diversity within the Asp/Glu family and highlights OpaE's potential for biotechnological applications, particularly in chiral substrate transformations.
BibTeX
@article{zheng2025molecular,
  author = {Xuehua Zheng and Zhiyong Guo and Leyao Chen and Haowen Wang and Johannes Freitag and Aitao Li and Gert Bange and Shu‐Ming Li and Liujuan Zheng},
  title = {{Molecular insights into the substrate recognition and quasi-unidirectional catalysis of OpaE, an atypical fungal enzyme from the Asp/Glu racemase family}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Chemistry},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jbc.2025.110828},
}
Figure