Molecular insights into chirality transfer from double axially chiral phosphoric acid in a synergistic enantioselective intramolecular amination

Soumi Tribedi, Raghavan B. SunojChemical 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses computational chemistry to unravel the mechanism behind a highly enantioselective intramolecular amination reaction catalyzed by a synergistic system of palladium and a double axially chiral phosphoric acid (DAPCy). The study reveals that the chiral phosphoric acid acts as a crucial counterion, guiding the reaction through a series of specific noncovalent interactions to achieve excellent stereocontrol.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving high enantioselectivity (producing predominantly one mirror-image form of a molecule) is a cornerstone of modern organic synthesis, particularly for pharmaceuticals and fine chemicals. While chiral catalysts are essential for this, understanding how they induce chirality, especially in complex multi-catalytic systems, remains a significant challenge. This paper addresses the need for detailed mechanistic insights into a specific dual-catalytic system: the intramolecular allylic amination of an achiral substrate using a palladium catalyst and a double axially chiral phosphoric acid (DAPCy). Previous experimental work showed this system achieved impressive 95% enantiomeric excess (ee), but the precise role of the DAPCy catalyst and the origin of its stereodirecting ability were unclear.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive computational approach using density functional theory (DFT). Specifically, they utilized the SMD (toluene) solvation model with the B3LYP-D3 functional and a 6-31G** basis set for most atoms, with relativistic corrections (SDD ECP) for palladium. This level of theory is well-suited for investigating reaction mechanisms, transition states, and noncovalent interactions. Key techniques included:

  • Geometry Optimization: Finding the lowest energy structures for reactants, intermediates, and transition states.
  • Transition State Characterization: Verifying that identified transition states correspond to the desired reaction pathway using Hessian indices and intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC) calculations.
  • Noncovalent Interaction Analysis: Employing the Atoms-in-Molecule (AIM) formalism and NCI plots to visualize and quantify the strength of various weak interactions (hydrogen bonding, π-π stacking, etc.) that are crucial for stereocontrol.
  • Activation Strain Analysis: Decomposing the energy barrier into contributions from reactant distortion and the interaction between the reacting fragments.
  • Energetic Span Model: Identifying the turnover-determining intermediate (TDI) and transition state (TDTS) to understand the rate-limiting steps of the catalytic cycle.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on a theoretical investigation of a specific reaction mechanism, not on training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cooperative Catalysis: The reaction proceeds via a synergistic mechanism where both the palladium catalyst and the chiral phosphoric acid play distinct but complementary roles. Palladium activates the allyl alcohol, while the phosphoric acid guides the subsequent cyclization.
  • Chiral Phosphate Counterion: The double axially chiral phosphoric acid (DAPCy) primarily functions as a chiral counterion to the Pd-π-allyl intermediate, rather than a direct ligand to palladium. This is a key insight into its stereodirecting role.
  • Dynamic Equilibrium of DAPCy Diastereomers: The (S,R,S)-DAPCy catalyst exists in dynamic equilibrium with its (S,S,S) diastereomer. The study strongly suggests that the (S,R,S) form is the catalytically active species responsible for high enantioselectivity.
  • Crucial Role of Noncovalent Interactions: A complex network of noncovalent interactions (N-H⋯O, C-H⋯O, C-H⋯π, lone pair⋯π, etc.) between the DAPCy catalyst and the Pd-π-allyl intermediate dictates the preferred orientation of the substrate and thus the stereochemical outcome.
  • Enantiocontrolling Step Identified: The intramolecular nucleophilic addition of the sulfonamide nitrogen to the Pd-π-allyl moiety is identified as the enantiocontrolling step, rather than the initial dehydroxylation.
  • "Exo-si" Pathway Dominance: The favored pathway for high enantioselectivity involves the si prochiral face of the Pd-π-allyl intermediate being accessible for nucleophilic attack, driven by specific interactions within the exo-si configuration of the catalyst-substrate complex.

Key Results

  • High Enantioselectivity Explained: The computational model successfully rationalizes the experimentally observed high enantioselectivity (95% ee). The (S,R,S)-DAPCy catalyst predicts an ee of >99% for the S enantiomer, aligning well with experimental findings.
  • Energetic Barriers: The study identified the key transition states and their relative energies, showing that the exo-si pathway for the (S,R,S)-DAPCy catalyst has a significantly lower energetic span (10.6 kcal mol⁻¹) compared to the endo-re pathway (14.1 kcal mol⁻¹), indicating superior catalytic efficiency.
  • Detailed NCI Analysis: Extensive analysis of noncovalent interactions revealed specific hydrogen bonding and π-interactions that stabilize the transition state leading to the desired S enantiomer. For instance, the N-H⋯O interaction between the sulfonamide and the DAPCy phosphate is identified as a critical anchoring contact.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: While the computational model accurately predicts the observed enantioselectivity, it is a theoretical study. The exact dynamic behavior of the catalyst and substrate in solution, including potential solvent effects beyond the implicit SMD model, can introduce nuances not fully captured. The paper acknowledges that the "adventitious water" present in the system plays a role in stabilizing transition states, and its precise concentration and behavior could influence outcomes.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that these molecular insights provide a rational framework for designing new asymmetric catalytic strategies utilizing dynamic double axially chiral phosphoric acids. Further experimental validation of the proposed mechanistic details and exploration of other substrates or related chiral catalysts would be valuable. The study also highlights the potential of chiral counterion-directed catalysis (ACDC) as a powerful tool in asymmetric synthesis.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the most general practice of asymmetric catalysis, a chiral catalyst, typically bearing a center or an axis of chirality, is employed as the chiral source for imparting enantiocontrol over the developing product. Given the current interest toward optically pure compounds, various forms of chiral induction enabled by diverse chiral sources as well as the use of multiple catalysts under one-pot conditions have been in focus. In one such promising development, an achiral <i>N</i>-sulfonamide protected 1,6-amino allyl alcohol (NaphSO<sub>2</sub>NHCH<sub>2</sub>C(Ph)<sub>2</sub>CH<sub>2</sub>CH[double bond, length as m-dash]CHCH<sub>2</sub>OH) was subjected to Tsuji-Trost activation and an intramolecular amination to form important chiral pyrrolidine frameworks. A dual catalytic system comprising Pd(PPh<sub>3</sub>)<sub>4</sub> and DAPCy (β-cyclohexyl substituted double axially chiral phosphoric acid derived from two homocoupled BINOL backbones with a dynamic central chiral axis) under mild conditions was reported to offer quantitative conversion with an <i>ee</i> of 95%. Here, we provide molecular insights into the origin of chiral induction by DAPCy, as obtained through a comprehensive density functional theory (SMD<sub>(toluene)</sub>/B3LYP-D3/6-31G**,Pd(SDD)) investigation. Two key steps in the mechanism are identified to involve a cooperative mode of activation of the Pd-bound allyl alcohol in the form of a Pd-π-allyl moiety at one end of the substrate, followed by an intramolecular nucleophilic addition of <i>N</i>-sulfonamide from the other end to yield a pyrrolidine derivative bearing an α-vinyl stereogenic center. (<i>S</i>,<i>R</i>,<i>S</i>)-DAPCy is found to steer the dehydroxylation to yield a Pd-π-allyl intermediate with a suitably poised <i>si</i> prochiral face for the nucleophilic addition. In the enantiocontrolled (as well as the turn-over determining step) nucleophilic addition, the chiral catalyst is identified to serve as a chiral phosphate counterion. The chiral induction is facilitated by a series of N-H⋯O, C-H⋯O, C-H⋯π, lone pair (lp)⋯π, O-H⋯O, O-H⋯π, and π⋯π noncovalent interactions, which is noted as more effective in the lower energy C-N bond formation transition state through the <i>si</i> prochiral face of the Pd-π-allyl moiety. These insights into the novel dynamic axially double chiral catalyst could be valuable toward exploiting such modes of stereoinduction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tribedi2021molecular,
  author = {Soumi Tribedi and Raghavan B. Sunoj},
  title = {{Molecular insights into chirality transfer from double axially chiral phosphoric acid in a synergistic enantioselective intramolecular amination}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1039/d1sc05749a},
}
Figure