Molecular Evolution of psb D Gene in Ferns:Selection Pressure and Co-evolutionary Analysis

Ke Xu, Bo Wang, Yingjuan Su, Lei Gao, Ting WangPlant 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the molecular evolution of the psbD gene, which encodes the D2 protein of Photosystem II, in ferns. By analyzing selection pressures and co-evolutionary patterns, the researchers found that while most sites are under strong negative selection, tree ferns exhibit a slower evolutionary rate and distinct co-evolutionary networks, suggesting unique adaptive strategies in low-light environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the question of how ferns, particularly core leptosporangiate ferns, have adapted to diverse environments, especially low-light conditions, following the rise of angiosperms. While it's generally understood that many plant groups declined with angiosperm diversification, some ferns have thrived. The researchers hypothesize that key functional genes, like psbD involved in photosynthesis, may have undergone adaptive evolution to facilitate this diversification. Understanding the selective pressures and co-evolutionary relationships within this gene can shed light on the molecular mechanisms behind fern adaptation and diversification.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze the psbD gene and its encoded D2 protein:

  • Gene Sequencing: The psbD gene was cloned and sequenced from 12 fern species. These sequences were combined with 8 publicly available sequences to create a comprehensive dataset representing various fern lineages.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: A Bayesian inference method was used to construct a phylogenetic tree of the fern species based on the psbD gene sequences.
  • Selection Pressure Analysis:
    • PAML Software: Various models within PAML (e.g., branch models, site models, branch-site models) were used to estimate the ratio of nonsynonymous to synonymous substitutions (ω). This ratio indicates the type of selection pressure: ω < 1 suggests negative (purifying) selection, ω = 1 suggests neutral selection, and ω > 1 suggests positive (adaptive) selection. Likelihood ratio tests (LRTs) were performed to compare different models and identify significant differences in selection pressures across branches and sites.
  • Selecton and Datamonkey Servers: The MEC (Mechanistic-Empirical Combination) model, along with SLAC (Single-Likelihood Ancestor Counting) and FEL (Fixed Effects Likelihood) models, were used to detect positively and negatively selected sites at the amino acid level.
  • Co-evolution Analysis: Several methods were employed to identify co-evolving amino acid sites within the D2 protein:
  • CAPS (Co-evolution Analysis Using Protein Sequences)
    • Spidermonkey
    • InterMap3D (using RCW-MI, MI/E, and Dependency models)

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Newly Sequenced Data: psbD gene sequences from 12 fern species collected from the Wuhan Botanical Garden (WBGCAS), South China Botanical Garden (SCBG-CAS), and Fairy Lake Botanical Garden (FBG-SCAS).
  • Publicly Available Data: psbD gene sequences for 8 additional fern species and 1 outgroup species obtained from the GenBank database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Widespread Purifying Selection: The psbD gene and its encoded D2 protein are under strong purifying selection across most sites and evolutionary branches in ferns. This indicates that the gene's function is highly conserved, and most mutations are detrimental.
  • Tree Ferns' Unique Evolutionary Trajectory: Tree ferns (Cyatheales) exhibit a distinct evolutionary pattern. They show a slower molecular evolutionary rate and a higher ω value compared to other fern lineages. This suggests that while the gene is still largely conserved, there might be specific adaptive pressures or relaxed constraints in certain branches of tree ferns.
  • Co-evolutionary Network in Tree Ferns: Co-evolution analysis revealed a specific co-evolutionary network involving amino acid sites D2-R168, D2-H245, and D2-M272 in tree ferns. This suggests that these sites interact and co-evolve to maintain protein structure and function, potentially playing a role in their adaptation.
  • Potential Role of D2-H245 in Metal Binding: The substitution of tyrosine (Y) with histidine (H) at position 245 in tree ferns, compared to other ferns and cyanobacteria, is hypothesized to enhance binding with Fe+2. This could be significant for the D2 protein's role in the Photosystem II reaction center.
  • Limited Evidence for Positive Selection: Despite extensive analysis using various models, clear evidence for positive selection at the molecular level was not found. This could be due to the low variability in the psbD gene, the dominance of purifying selection, or the possibility that adaptive evolution occurred much earlier and has since been fixed or masked by neutral drift.

Key Results

  • Phylogenetic Tree: A consensus phylogenetic tree of 20 fern species was constructed, largely consistent with previous classifications.
  • Selection Pressure:
    • Most sites and branches showed strong negative selection (ω < 1).
  • Tree fern branches (B) had a significantly higher ω value (0.08188) compared to other branches (e.g., 0.014503), driven by a significantly lower synonymous substitution rate (ds).
  • MEC analysis indicated that 98.9% of sites were under negative selection (ω ≤ 0.21), with no sites showing strong evidence of positive selection (ω > 1).
  • SLAC and FEL analyses identified a large number of negatively selected sites but no positively selected sites.
  • Co-evolution: 13 pairs of co-evolving amino acid sites were identified in the D2 protein. Notably, sites 45 and 115 showed co-evolution in aquatic ferns, potentially related to their aquatic lifestyle. In tree ferns, sites 168, 245, and 272 formed a co-evolutionary network.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Positive Selection Signal: The study did not detect strong signals of positive selection, which might be due to the low variability of the psbD gene, the overwhelming effect of purifying selection, or the possibility that adaptive evolution occurred in the deep past and is no longer detectable.
  • Need for New Methods: The authors suggest that new methods may be required to detect adaptive evolution in functionally important sites, especially if such evolution occurred early and has been fixed.
  • Co-evolutionary Insights: The identified co-evolving sites, particularly in tree ferns, provide valuable information for understanding the complex molecular mechanisms of protein evolution and adaptation. Future work could focus on experimentally validating the functional significance of these co-evolving residues and their role in the D2 protein's interaction with other components of Photosystem II.
  • Broader Gene Analysis: Investigating other genes involved in photosynthesis or other key metabolic pathways could provide a more comprehensive understanding of fern adaptation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2013molecular,
  author = {Ke Xu and Bo Wang and Yingjuan Su and Lei Gao and Ting Wang},
  title = {{Molecular Evolution of <i>psb</i> D Gene in Ferns:Selection Pressure and Co-evolutionary Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3724/sp.j.1142.2013.50429},
}
Figure