Molecular epidemiology and phylogenetic analysis of influenza viruses A (H3N2) and B/Victoria during the COVID-19 pandemic in Guangdong, China

Zhiqi Zeng, Yong Liu, Wenxiang Jin, Jingyi Liang, Jinbin Chen, Ruihan Chen, Qianying Li, Wenda Guan, Lixi Liang, Qiubao Wu, Yuanfang Lai, Xiaoyan Deng, Zhengshi Lin, Chitin Hon, Zifeng YangInfectious 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

While COVID-19 lockdowns successfully suppressed influenza cases, they didn't stop the virus from evolving in the shadows. This study reveals that "insidious transmission" during the pandemic led to an evolutionary sprint, with influenza A(H3N2) and B/Victoria evolving 1.7 to 2.1 times faster than pre-pandemic rates once restrictions were lifted in Guangdong, China.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs)—like mask-wearing, travel restrictions, and social distancing—caused seasonal influenza activity to plummet globally. However, as these measures were relaxed, unexpected and severe outbreaks of influenza B/Victoria (late 2021) and A(H3N2) (mid-2022) hit southern China.

The researchers sought to understand how these viruses persisted and changed during periods of near-zero detection. Did the lack of host-to-host opportunities slow down viral evolution, or did the virus adapt in ways that prepared it for a massive comeback? This paper explores the molecular epidemiology and phylogenetic shifts that occurred behind the scenes of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Methods

The authors conducted a massive surveillance effort in Guangdong Province, collecting 173,401 throat swabs from patients with acute respiratory infections between 2018 and 2022.

Key technical approaches included:

  • Genotyping and Sequencing: Using RT-PCR for detection and Sanger sequencing to map the Hemagglutinin (HA) and Neuraminidase (NA) genes—the primary targets for our immune system and vaccines.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: Constructing maximum-likelihood trees using IQ-TREE to visualize how local strains related to global lineages.
  • Molecular Clock Modeling: Utilizing the "treedater" R package to estimate evolutionary rates by measuring "root-to-tip" genetic distances over time.
  • Selection Pressure Analysis: Calculating dN/dS ratios (the ratio of non-synonymous to synonymous mutations) via DataMonkey to determine if the virus was undergoing "purifying selection" (conserving traits) or "positive selection" (actively adapting).

Datasets

  • Primary Dataset: 173,401 clinical samples from 262 hospitals across 21 cities in Guangdong.
  • Global Reference Dataset: HA and NA sequences for H3N2 and B/Victoria collected globally (Africa, Antarctica, Asia, Europe, North/South America, and Oceania) between 2019 and 2022, sourced from the GISAID database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Insidious Transmission" Hypothesis: Even when clinical cases were nearly undetectable, the virus continued to circulate at low levels. This "occult" transmission allowed the virus to accumulate mutations without the usual competitive pressures of a high-infection season.
  • Evolutionary Acceleration: Contrary to what one might expect from a suppressed virus, the evolutionary rate spiked. B/Victoria's HA gene evolved 1.7 times faster post-outbreak than before the pandemic, while H3N2's HA gene evolved 2.1 times faster.
  • Reduced Geographic Diversity: Before the pandemic, Guangdong's flu strains were closely linked to diverse global lineages. During the pandemic, this diversity collapsed; the outbreaks were driven by specific domestic lineages that had "bottlenecked" and then rapidly diversified within China.
  • Antigenic Drift: Several mutations occurred in major antigenic sites (e.g., R147G and N164K in B/Victoria). This suggests the virus was actively drifting to evade population immunity, which had likely waned due to a lack of natural exposure during lockdowns.

Key Results

  • Infection Peaks: After a long period of dormancy (0.13% positivity), B/Victoria peaked at 4.94% in December 2021. This was followed by an even larger H3N2 peak in June 2022, reaching 11.34%.
  • Quantitative Evolution:
    • H3N2 HA rate: Increased from $3.81 \times 10^{-3}$ to $7.96 \times 10^{-3}$ substitutions per site per year.
  • B/Victoria HA rate: Increased from $1.80 \times 10^{-3}$ to $3.11 \times 10^{-3}$ substitutions per site per year.
  • Vaccine Matching: Despite the rapid evolution, the circulating strains remained genetically similar to the WHO-recommended vaccine strains (A/Cambodia/e0826360/2020 and B/Washington/02/2019), suggesting that vaccination remains a viable defense.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Surveillance Bias: The data relies on patients who actively sought medical care, which might not capture the full spectrum of mild or asymptomatic "insidious" cases.
  • Functional Uncertainty: While the study identifies where mutations occurred, the exact impact of these mutations on viral infectivity and transmissibility requires further laboratory validation (e.g., in vitro assays).
  • Geographic Scope: The study is focused on Guangdong; while a major travel hub, the patterns of "insidious transmission" might differ in other climates or regions with different NPI strategies.

Future Work: The researchers emphasize the need for continuous, real-time molecular monitoring of influenza to provide early warnings for future "rebound" epidemics as global travel and social behaviors return to pre-pandemic norms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite the extraordinarily low detection rate of influenza infection, concealed influenza transmission may occur between individuals during strict COVID-19 control. This ultimately leads to the accumulation of viral mutations and accelerated evolution of H3N2 and B/Victoria viruses. Monitoring the evolution of influenza may provide insights and alerts regarding potential epidemics in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zeng2024molecular,
  author = {Zhiqi Zeng and Yong Liu and Wenxiang Jin and Jingyi Liang and Jinbin Chen and Ruihan Chen and Qianying Li and Wenda Guan and Lixi Liang and Qiubao Wu and Yuanfang Lai and Xiaoyan Deng and Zhengshi Lin and Chitin Hon and Zifeng Yang},
  title = {{Molecular epidemiology and phylogenetic analysis of influenza viruses A (H3N2) and B/Victoria during the COVID-19 pandemic in Guangdong, China}},
  booktitle = {Infectious},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s40249-024-01218-z},
}
Figure