Molecular Cytogenetic and Agronomic Characterization of the Similarities and Differences Between Wheat–Leymus mollis Trin. and Wheat–Psathyrostachys huashanica Keng 3Ns (3D) Substitution Lines

Jiachuang Li, Jiaojiao Li, Xueni Cheng, Zhao Li, Zhenglin Yang, Jun Wu, Qunhui Yang, Xinhong Chen, Jixin ZhaoFrontiers in Plant Science 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study developed and characterized two novel wheat lines where a wheat chromosome is replaced by an alien chromosome from either Psathyrostachys huashanica (DH109) or Leymus mollis (DM131). Both lines exhibit enhanced resistance to powdery mildew, but differ in other agronomic traits, suggesting that the Ns genome from these two species, while related, carries distinct genetic contributions for wheat improvement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Common wheat ( Triticum aestivum ) is a staple crop, but it often lacks resistance to various diseases and tolerance to environmental stresses. Wild relatives of wheat, such as Psathyrostachys huashanica and Leymus mollis, possess valuable genes for traits like disease resistance and stress tolerance. These species share a common "Ns" genome, making them promising sources for improving wheat. However, understanding how the Ns chromosomes from these different species behave and influence wheat traits when introduced is crucial for effective breeding. This paper addresses the need to characterize wheat lines that have substituted a wheat chromosome with an Ns chromosome from either P. huashanica or L. mollis, to compare their genetic stability, and to evaluate their agronomic performance and disease resistance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to characterize the new wheat lines:

  • Cytological Observation: Root tip cells and pollen mother cells were examined to determine chromosome numbers and observe their behavior during meiosis, ensuring the stability of the introduced alien chromosomes.
  • Genomic In Situ Hybridization (GISH): This technique uses fluorescently labeled DNA probes from the alien donor species (P. huashanica or L. mollis) to visualize and confirm the presence and location of the alien chromosomes within the wheat background.
  • Molecular Marker Analysis:
    • SSR (Simple Sequence Repeat) and EST-STS (Expressed Sequence Tag-Sequence Tag Site) Markers: These markers were used to identify specific DNA sequences and determine the homoeology (similarity in structure and gene content) of the alien chromosomes with wheat chromosomes.
  • SCAR (Sequence Characterized Amplified Region) Markers: These were developed to specifically identify chromosomes from P. huashanica.
  • Wheat 55K SNP Array Analysis: This high-throughput genotyping platform was used to compare the overall genetic makeup of the new lines with their parents, providing a detailed fingerprint and identifying regions of similarity and difference.
  • Disease Resistance and Agronomic Trait Evaluation: The lines were tested in field and controlled conditions for resistance to stripe rust, powdery mildew, and Fusarium head blight (FHB). Agronomic traits like plant height, tiller number, spike length, kernel number, and thousand-kernel weight were also measured.

Datasets

The study utilized the following plant materials:

  • Psathyrostachys huashanica Keng (alien donor)
  • Leymus mollis Trin. (alien donor)
  • Common wheat lines: 7,182, Mingxian169 (MX169), Chinese Spring (CS), Huixianhong (HXH)
  • Durum wheat line: Trs-372
  • Wheat-P. huashanica disomic substitution line: DH109
  • Wheat-L. mollis disomic substitution line: DM131

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on characterizing the developed lines.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D Chromosome Substitution: Both P. huashanica and L. mollis Ns chromosomes, specifically those belonging to the 3Ns homoeologous group, can successfully substitute for the wheat 3D chromosome. This is a significant finding for targeted gene introgression.
  • Distinct Genetic Contributions: Despite sharing the Ns genome, the P. huashanica 3Ns chromosome and the L. mollis 3Ns chromosome carry different sets of genes that influence agronomic traits and disease resistance in wheat. This highlights the genetic divergence even within related alien species.
  • Differential Disease Resistance: While both lines gained powdery mildew resistance, DH109 showed superior resistance to Fusarium head blight compared to DM131. This suggests specific resistance genes are located on these distinct Ns chromosomes.
  • Agronomic Trade-offs: The lines exhibited different agronomic advantages. DH109 had larger kernels, while DM131 had longer spikes and more tillers. This indicates that the choice of alien donor can lead to different breeding outcomes.
  • Phylogenetic Clues: The FISH analysis suggested a closer relationship between L. mollis and wheat compared to P. huashanica, potentially reflecting evolutionary divergence.

Key Results

  • Cytological Stability: Both DH109 and DM131 were confirmed to be stable disomic substitution lines, each possessing 42 chromosomes (20 pairs of wheat chromosomes + 1 pair of alien chromosomes) with regular meiotic behavior.
  • Chromosome Identification: Molecular markers (SSR, EST-STS, SCAR) and FISH confirmed that DH109 carries a P. huashanica 3Ns chromosome substituting for wheat 3D, and DM131 carries an L. mollis 3Ns chromosome substituting for wheat 3D.
  • Disease Resistance: Both DH109 and DM131 showed strong resistance to powdery mildew. DH109 also exhibited superior resistance to Fusarium head blight (FHB) compared to DM131 and wheat parents.
  • Agronomic Traits:
    • DH109 had larger kernels and was shorter than its wheat parent.
  • DM131 had longer spikes, more tillers, and was shorter than its wheat parent.
  • SNP Array Data: The SNP array analysis corroborated the substitution, showing distinct patterns of shared alleles between the derived lines and their respective alien parents, particularly on chromosome 3D.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of Substitution: This study focused on the 3D chromosome substitution. Future work could explore substitutions involving other wheat chromosomes with Ns chromosomes from these species to uncover a broader range of beneficial traits.
  • Detailed Gene Mapping: While the study identified differences in agronomic traits and disease resistance, further research is needed to pinpoint the specific genes responsible for these variations on the 3Ns chromosomes.
  • Breeding Potential: While the lines show promise, their full potential for wheat breeding will depend on further introgression and evaluation in diverse genetic backgrounds. The study suggests that DH109 and DM131 may have different applications depending on the desired breeding outcome.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Psathyrostachys huashanica</i> Keng (2<i>n</i> = 2<i>x</i> = 14, NsNs) and <i>Leymus mollis</i> Trin. (2<i>n</i> = 4<i>x</i> = 28, NsNsXmXm) are valuable resources for wheat breeding improvement as they share the Ns genome, which contains diverse resistance genes. To explore the behaviors and traits of Ns chromosomes from the two species in wheat background, a series of wheat-<i>P. huashanica</i> and wheat-<i>L. mollis</i> substitution lines were developed. In the present study, line DH109 (F<sub>7</sub> progeny of wheat-<i>P. huashanica</i> heptaploid line H8911 × durum wheat Trs-372) and line DM131 (F<sub>8</sub> progeny of wheat-<i>L. mollis</i> octoploid line M842 × durum wheat Trs-372) were selected. Cytological observation combined with genomic <i>in situ</i> hybridization experiments showed that DH109 and DM131 each had 20 pairs of wheat chromosomes plus a pair of alien chromosomes (Ns chromosome), and the pair of alien chromosomes showed stable inheritance. Multiple molecular markers and wheat 55K SNP array demonstrated that a pair of wheat 3D chromosome in DH109 and in DM131 was substituted by a pair of <i>P. huashanica</i> 3Ns chromosome and a pair of <i>L. mollis</i> 3Ns chromosome, respectively. Fluorescence <i>in situ</i> hybridization (FISH) analysis confirmed that wheat 3D chromosomes were absent from DH109 and DM131, and chromosomal FISH karyotypes of wheat 3D, <i>P. huashanica</i> 3Ns, and <i>L. mollis</i> 3Ns were different. Moreover, the two lines had many differences in agronomic traits. Comparing with their wheat parents, DH109 expressed superior resistance to powdery mildew and fusarium head blight, whereas DM131 had powdery mildew resistance, longer spike, and more tiller number. Therefore, Ns genome from <i>P. huashanica</i> and <i>L. mollis</i> might have some different effects. The two novel wheat-alien substitution lines provide new ideas and resources for disease resistance and high-yield breeding on further utilization of 3Ns chromosomes of <i>P. huashanica</i> or <i>L. mollis</i>.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021molecular,
  author = {Jiachuang Li and Jiaojiao Li and Xueni Cheng and Zhao Li and Zhenglin Yang and Jun Wu and Qunhui Yang and Xinhong Chen and Jixin Zhao},
  title = {{Molecular Cytogenetic and Agronomic Characterization of the Similarities and Differences Between Wheat–Leymus mollis Trin. and Wheat–Psathyrostachys huashanica Keng 3Ns (3D) Substitution Lines}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2021.644896},
}
Figure