Molecular basis for histone H3 “K4me3-K9me3/2” methylation pattern readout by Spindlin1

Fan Zhao, Yunan Liu, Xiaonan Su, Ji‐Eun Lee, Yutong Song, Daliang Wang, Kai Ge, Juntao Gao, Michael Q. Zhang, Haitao LiJournal of Biological Chemistry 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals Spindlin1 as a novel "reader" protein that specifically recognizes a complex histone modification pattern: trimethylation at H3K4 and dimethylation/trimethylation at H3K9 (H3 "K4me3-K9me3/2"). Structural and biochemical data show Spindlin1 binds this bivalent mark with high affinity, suggesting a role in fine-tuning gene expression by integrating signals from both active (H3K4me3) and repressive (H3K9me3/2) chromatin states.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "histone code" hypothesis posits that combinations of histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) dictate downstream cellular events, particularly gene regulation. While individual PTMs and their readers are well-studied, understanding how cells interpret combinations of marks, especially those with seemingly opposing roles (like activating H3K4me3 and repressing H3K9me3), remains a significant challenge. Bivalent domains, characterized by the co-occurrence of these opposing marks, are known to be crucial for maintaining pluripotency and regulating developmental genes. However, the molecular mechanisms by which these bivalent marks are read and translated into specific cellular responses are not fully understood. This paper addresses this gap by investigating Spindlin1's potential role in reading the H3 "K4me3-K9me3/2" bivalent methylation pattern.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Thermal Shift Assays (TSA): Used to assess the thermal stability of Spindlin1 upon binding to various histone peptides, indicating binding affinity.
  • Isothermal Titration Calorimetry (ITC): Quantitatively measured the binding affinity (Kd) of Spindlin1 to different histone peptides, providing precise binding constants.
  • X-ray Crystallography: Determined the high-resolution 3D structures of Spindlin1 bound to H3 "K4me3-K9me3" and H3 "K4me3-K9me2" peptides. This allowed visualization of how Spindlin1 recognizes and interacts with these specific methylation patterns.
  • Mutagenesis Studies: Created mutant versions of Spindlin1 to identify key amino acid residues involved in binding to the histone marks and validated their importance through ITC.
  • Chromatin Immunoprecipitation followed by Sequencing (ChIP-Seq) and Quantitative PCR (ChIP-qPCR): Investigated the genomic distribution of Spindlin1, H3K4me3, and H3K9me3 in cells. This helped to understand where Spindlin1 localizes in relation to these histone marks in the genome.
  • Gene Ontology (GO) Analysis: Analyzed the biological functions of genes found in regions where Spindlin1, H3K4me3, and H3K9me3 co-localize.

Datasets

  • Histone H3 Peptides: Synthetic peptides representing various methylation states of the histone H3 N-terminus (e.g., H3(1-20)K4me3, H3(1-20)K4me3-K9me3, H3(1-20)K4me3-K9me2, etc.) were used for binding assays.
  • Genomic Data: ChIP-Seq data were generated from HEK293 cells overexpressing FLAG-Spindlin1, along with antibodies for H3K4me3 and H3K9me3. This data was deposited in the GEO database (accession No. GSE147785).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spindlin1 as a Bivalent Mark Reader: The most significant finding is Spindlin1's ability to recognize the combination of H3K4me3 and H3K9me3/2, not just individual marks. This highlights its role in interpreting complex epigenetic landscapes.
  • Dual Aromatic Pocket Recognition: Structural analysis revealed that Spindlin1 uses two distinct aromatic pockets (pocket 2 for H3K4me3 and pocket 1 for H3K9me3/2) to simultaneously bind these two methylation marks on the same histone tail.
  • High Affinity for Bivalent Mark: Spindlin1 exhibits a remarkably high binding affinity (16 nM) for the H3 "K4me3-K9me3" peptide, significantly stronger than its affinity for individual marks or other known readers of H3K4me3. This suggests a specialized and crucial role for this interaction.
  • H3K4me3 as a "Hot Spot" for Recruitment: While Spindlin1 binds both marks, genomic data suggests that its initial recruitment to chromatin is primarily driven by H3K4me3, with the presence of H3K9me3/2 further stabilizing this interaction. This implies a model where Spindlin1 acts as a downstream effector of H3K4me3 in regions that also harbor repressive H3K9me3/2 marks.
  • Balancing Gene Expression and Silencing: The colocalization of Spindlin1 with both H3K4me3 and H3K9me3/2 in promoter regions of genes involved in transcription and its regulation suggests a role in dynamically balancing gene activation and silencing.

Key Results

  • Binding Affinity: Spindlin1 binds H3 "K4me3-K9me3" peptide with a Kd of 16 nM, which is 1-3 orders of magnitude stronger than many other histone reader-peptide interactions.
  • Structural Basis: Crystal structures revealed that Spindlin1's Tudor 2 pocket binds H3K4me3, while its Tudor 1 pocket binds H3K9me3/2, allowing for concurrent recognition.
  • Genomic Colocalization: ChIP-Seq data showed that 93.6% of Spindlin1 peaks overlap with H3K4me3 peaks. Crucially, 70.7% of the overlap between H3K4me3 and H3K9me3 peaks also contained Spindlin1 peaks, primarily in gene promoter regions.
  • Functional Enrichment: Genes found in these co-localized regions were significantly enriched for processes related to transcription and its regulation.
  • Mutagenesis Validation: Mutations in key aromatic residues of Spindlin1's binding pockets significantly reduced binding affinity, confirming their importance for recognizing H3K4me3 and H3K9me3/2.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In vivo Validation of Y98R Mutant: While the Y98R mutant (affecting H3K9me3 binding) showed a mild decrease in enrichment at specific genomic sites, further in-depth functional studies are needed to fully elucidate its in vivo role.
  • Dynamic Regulation Mechanisms: The paper proposes that Spindlin1 might act as a pioneering reader to balance gene expression and silencing in heterochromatic regions. Future work could focus on dissecting the "read-and-erase" mechanisms involving histone demethylases and how Spindlin1 integrates these signals for dynamic gene regulation.
  • Broader Functional Context: While the study identifies Spindlin1 as a reader of this bivalent mark and links it to transcription, further research is needed to fully understand its specific roles in processes like early embryogenesis, metabolic stress response, and its implications in diseases like cancer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Histone recognition by "reader" modules serves as a fundamental mechanism in epigenetic regulation. Previous studies have shown that Spindlin1 is a reader of histone H3K4me3 as well as "K4me3-R8me2a" and promotes transcription of rDNA or Wnt/TCF4 target genes. Here we show that Spindlin1 also acts as a potent reader of histone H3 "K4me3-K9me3/2" bivalent methylation pattern. Calorimetric titration revealed a binding affinity of 16 nm between Spindlin1 and H3 "K4me3-K9me3" peptide, which is one to three orders of magnitude stronger than most other histone readout events at peptide level. Structural studies revealed concurrent recognition of H3K4me3 and H3K9me3/2 by aromatic pockets 2 and 1 of Spindlin1, respectively. Epigenomic profiling studies showed that Spindlin1 colocalizes with both H3K4me3 and H3K9me3 peaks in a subset of genes enriched in biological processes of transcription and its regulation. Moreover, the distribution of Spindlin1 peaks is primarily associated with H3K4me3 but not H3K9me3, which suggests that Spindlin1 is a downstream effector of H3K4me3 generated in heterochromatic regions. Collectively, our work calls attention to an intriguing function of Spindlin1 as a potent H3 "K4me3-K9me3/2" bivalent mark reader, thereby balancing gene expression and silencing in H3K9me3/2-enriched regions.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2020molecular,
  author = {Fan Zhao and Yunan Liu and Xiaonan Su and Ji‐Eun Lee and Yutong Song and Daliang Wang and Kai Ge and Juntao Gao and Michael Q. Zhang and Haitao Li},
  title = {{Molecular basis for histone H3 “K4me3-K9me3/2” methylation pattern readout by Spindlin1}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Chemistry},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1074/jbc.ra120.013649},
}
Figure