Molecular Aharonov–Bohm-type interferometers based on porphyrin nanorings

Chi Cheng, Gil Harari, Igor Rončević, Juan E. Peralta, Harry L. Anderson, Andrew M. Teale, Oded HodChemical Science 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates, through computational modeling, that porphyrin nanorings can function as molecular Aharonov-Bohm (AB) interferometers. By carefully tuning the ring size and its coupling to external leads, these molecular devices can exhibit significant changes in conductance in response to experimentally achievable magnetic fields (5-10 T), paving the way for novel molecular electronic components.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, where electrons in a ring are influenced by a magnetic flux even without direct magnetic field exposure, has long been a fascinating phenomenon. Applying this to molecular electronics, the goal is to create devices whose electrical conductance can be precisely controlled by external magnetic fields. However, a major hurdle has been the requirement for impractically large magnetic fields to induce a significant AB effect in molecular-scale rings. This is because the magnetic flux quantum, which dictates the full cycle of conductance oscillations, is very small. The challenge, therefore, is to design molecular systems that are highly sensitive to magnetic fields, allowing for AB interferometry at realistic field strengths.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated computational approach combining the Nonequilibrium Green's Function (NEGF) formalism with a semi-empirical tight-binding method (GFN1-xTB-M1). This combined method, termed NEGF+GFN1-xTB-M1, is capable of calculating electronic transport through molecular junctions under finite bias and, crucially, external magnetic fields. The GFN1-xTB-M1 method is particularly noteworthy for its ability to incorporate the effects of magnetic fields on electronic structure. To validate their approach, they compared their results with more computationally expensive DFT calculations for smaller systems, finding good agreement. The transport calculations themselves are based on the Landauer formalism, relating current to the transmittance probability of electrons through the molecular junction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on computational modeling of molecular structures rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Molecular AB Interferometry is Feasible: The study provides strong computational evidence that molecular AB interferometers can be realized using porphyrin nanorings at experimentally accessible magnetic field strengths.
  • Weak Ring-Lead Coupling is Key: A critical finding is that weakening the coupling between the molecular ring and the external leads significantly enhances the sensitivity of the device to magnetic fields, allowing for observable conductance changes even with magnetic fluxes much smaller than a full flux quantum.
  • Size and Effective Mass Matter: The research highlights that larger ring radii are beneficial for encompassing a greater fraction of the AB flux quantum, while a smaller effective mass (higher electron mobility) in the conducting electrons amplifies the response to magnetic fields.
  • Fano Resonances as Control Mechanisms: The computational model predicts sharp Fano resonances in the transmittance probability, which are identified as the mechanism by which magnetic fields modulate the current. These resonances arise from the magnetic field-induced delocalization of molecular orbitals.
  • Porphyrin Nanorings as Promising Candidates: Specifically, butadiyne-linked porphyrin nanorings (c-PN) are identified as excellent candidates due to their tunable sizes, ability to form planar structures, and existing synthetic routes.

Key Results

  • Porphyrin nanorings with radii of 2-9 nm were modeled as AB interferometers.
  • Significant conductance changes (magnetoresistance) of up to 32-45% were predicted at a magnetic field of 10 T.
  • The study identified effective masses for electrons in c-PN nanorings around 0.1m_e and in f-PN nanobelts around 0.01m_e, with lower values indicating greater magnetic field sensitivity.
  • The calculations predicted that even at 10 T, the energy levels of the molecular orbitals split by up to ~20 meV, leading to observable changes in transmittance.
  • The proposed molecular AB interferometer design is based on a c-P10 porphyrin nanoring weakly coupled to polyacene leads.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Model: The study is based on computational modeling. While validated against DFT, experimental verification is the crucial next step.
  • Low Temperatures: The sharp Fano resonances and significant magnetoresistance are predicted at low temperatures. The paper notes that at higher electronic temperatures, the broadened Fermi transport window would reduce magneto-sensitivity.
  • Idealized Leads: The model uses idealized polyacene leads. The behavior with more complex or realistic electrode materials might differ.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring other molecular ring designs, varying linker chemistries and positions, and investigating different types of metallic leads to further optimize magnetic response. They also point to the potential of toroidal carbon nanotubes and charged polycyclic systems as other promising candidates for molecular AB interferometry. The development of strategies for reducing ring-lead coupling, such as using weakly coupled non-covalent stacking interactions to graphene leads, is also highlighted as a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

A goal of molecular electronics and spintronics is to create molecular devices that change their conductance in response to external stimuli. The Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect implies that an electronic device formed from a quantum ring and metallic leads will exhibit such behavior under external magnetic fields. At first sight, it appears that unrealistically large fields would be required to significantly alter the conductance of a molecular ring. However, the sensitivity of a molecular AB interferometer to magnetic fields can be increased by weakening the coupling between the molecular ring and the metallic leads. An ideal molecular ring for an AB interferometer has a large radius (to encompass a larger fraction of the AB flux quantum), and a small effective mass (high electron mobility) to enhance its response to magnetic fields. Here, we use computational modelling to demonstrate that recently synthesized zinc porphyrin nanorings, with radii of 2-9 nm, could behave as molecular AB interferometers at achievable magnetic field strengths (5-10 T), if weak ring-lead coupling is used. Building on our recently developed semi-empirical approach, which incorporates the effects of finite magnetic fields on the electronic structure, we develop a transport computational platform that allows us to identify sharp Fano resonances in the transmittance probability of porphyrin nanorings that could be exploited to control the current with an applied magnetic field. These resonances are rationalized in terms of a magnetic field-induced delocalization of the molecular orbitals. Our findings indicate that molecular AB interferometry should be feasible with current experimental capabilities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2025molecular,
  author = {Chi Cheng and Gil Harari and Igor Rončević and Juan E. Peralta and Harry L. Anderson and Andrew M. Teale and Oded Hod},
  title = {{Molecular Aharonov–Bohm-type interferometers based on porphyrin nanorings}},
  booktitle = {Chemical Science},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1039/d4sc07992b},
}
Figure