Modulating the Activity of vmPFC Regulates Informational Social Conformity: A tDCS Study

Yuzhen Li, Jinjin Wang, Hang Ye, Jun LuoFrontiers in Psychology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Social conformity has been evaluated in many different contexts, ranging from an emotional contagion in psychology, to speculative episodes in economics, to mass protests concerning politics. Previous neuroscience studies suggest that the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) participates in social conformity, especially when it comes to the value integration process, but the specific mechanism of vmPFC is still unclear. In this study, we aimed to identify a direct link between the vmPFC and conformity tendencies by means of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Conformity tendencies are measured by the probability that participants change their decisions when they observe the majority responses. In our experiment, subjects could make two decisions in each trial, once without social information and once with social information, which allowed us to directly observe the conformity tendency of subjects in different conditions. We found that cathodal stimulation of the vmPFC significantly increased conformity tendency and decreased response time when the initial decision of participants differs from the majority opinion. Based on the experimental results, our study suggests that the vmPFC mainly inhibits and regulates the informational conformity behavior. These findings complement investigations of the neural mechanism of conformity and the role of the vmPFC in the neural circuit behind conformity behavior.

Introduction

Why do we follow the crowd? In "informational social conformity," individuals adopt the behavior of others based on the belief that the group possesses superior information about reality. While neuroimaging studies using fMRI have previously shown that the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC)—a region associated with value integration and subjective confidence—is active during these social shifts, it remained unclear whether the vmPFC was actually driving the behavior or merely reflecting it.

This study sought to establish a causal link: by modulating vmPFC activity using non-invasive electrical stimulation, can we change an individual's tendency to conform? Furthermore, the researchers investigated whether the vmPFC influences conformity by modulating subjective confidence in one's own initial perceptions.

Methods

The researchers recruited 61 participants, dividing them into three groups receiving different types of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) over the vmPFC:

  1. Anodal: Increases cortical excitability.
  2. Cathodal: Decreases cortical excitability.
  3. Sham: A control group where stimulation is brief.
Figure 1: Overview of the experimental design, showing the timeline from instructions to the visual task and final questionnaire.

The Task

Participants performed a perceptual decision-making task requiring them to judge whether a grainy image was dominated by orange or blue blocks. The task followed a specific four-step sequence to isolate the influence of social information.

Figure 2: The four-step visual task sequence used to measure conformity after social information is presented.
  • Step 1: The participant makes an independent choice based on a 1.5-second display.
  • Step 2: They record their initial decision.
  • Step 3: They are shown the "majority response" of three other participants (manipulated by researchers) while the image is displayed again.
  • Step 4: They make a second, final decision.

The experimental design utilized a 2x2x2 matrix (Congruency, Net Public Information, and Correctness of Majority) to ensure a robust range of social conflict scenarios. Researchers used a Bayesian Nash Equilibrium (BNE) model to compare "rational" information integration against actual behavior, quantifying the weight participants gave to private versus social information.

Key Results

The study revealed several critical insights into the role of the vmPFC in social decision-making:

  • Increased Conformity via Inhibition: The most striking finding was that cathodal stimulation (inhibition) of the vmPFC significantly increased conformity. In conflict trials (where the majority was wrong and the participant was initially right), the cathodal group conformed 48.05% of the time, compared to 35.64% in the sham group and 35.28% in the anodal group.
  • Faster Decision-Making under Conflict: Inhibiting the vmPFC also decreased response time (2.99s vs. 3.23s in sham) when participants faced a dissenting majority. This suggests that a "quieter" vmPFC leads the brain to default more quickly to social norms rather than weighing internal conflict.
  • The Confidence Mediator: The authors propose that the vmPFC encodes subjective confidence. When activity is suppressed, confidence in initial perceptions drops, making the majority opinion appear relatively more valuable.
  • Bayesian Weighting: Computational modeling showed that while participants generally underweight social information, cathodal stimulation shifted them closer to a "rational" Bayesian ideal by increasing the weight assigned to social cues.

Discussion and Limitations

These findings suggest the vmPFC acts as a critical "brake" or regulator on our tendency to follow the crowd, helping maintain independent judgment. However, the study has limitations. The spatial resolution of tDCS is relatively low, meaning stimulation likely affected adjacent areas like the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC) or the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). Additionally, anodal stimulation did not significantly decrease conformity, suggesting a potential "ceiling effect" on the vmPFC's inhibitory capacity in this task. Future research using fMRI-tDCS hybrids could further elucidate the functional connectivity changes driving these behavioral shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social conformity has been evaluated in many different contexts, ranging from an emotional contagion in psychology, to speculative episodes in economics, to mass protests concerning politics. Previous neuroscience studies suggest that the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) participates in social conformity, especially when it comes to the value integration process, but the specific mechanism of vmPFC is still unclear. In this study, we aimed to identify a direct link between the vmPFC and conformity tendencies by means of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Conformity tendencies are measured by the probability that participants change their decisions when they observe the majority responses. In our experiment, subjects could make two decisions in each trial, once without social information and once with social information, which allowed us to directly observe the conformity tendency of subjects in different conditions. We found that cathodal stimulation of the vmPFC significantly increased conformity tendency and decreased response time when the initial decision of participants differs from the majority opinion. Based on the experimental results, our study suggests that the vmPFC mainly inhibits and regulates the informational conformity behavior. These findings complement investigations of the neural mechanism of conformity and the role of the vmPFC in the neural circuit behind conformity behavior.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020modulating,
  author = {Yuzhen Li and Jinjin Wang and Hang Ye and Jun Luo},
  title = {{Modulating the Activity of vmPFC Regulates Informational Social Conformity: A tDCS Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2020.566977},
}
Figure