Abstract
Trust and trustworthiness are essential to an efficient economy and play crucial roles in social life. Previous evidence from behavioral experiments has revealed that the trustworthiness of individuals is closely related with their altruistic preference. It has been demonstrated that the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) is associated with decisions involving trustworthiness. Moreover, vmPFC lesion patients showed less trustworthiness and altruism than control subjects, indicating the indispensable role of this specific brain area in human social interactions. However, the causal relationship between this neural area and trustworthiness, as well as altruism, has not been fully revealed. In the present study, we aimed to provide evidence of a direct link between the neural and behavioral results through the application of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) over the vmPFC of our participants. We found that activating the vmPFC could promote both the trustworthiness and altruism of our participants. We also show that enhancing the excitability of the vmPFC using tDCS increased the trustworthiness of the participants, and this promoting effect might be attributable to the enhancement of individuals' altruistic preference. In addition, we revealed that the enhancing effect in trustworthiness and altruism might be specific to the activation of the vmPFC by applying tDCS over another brain region within the prefrontal cortex as a control site. Crucially, our findings provide direct evidence supporting the critical role of the vmPFC in cooperative behaviors in economic interactions, especially the trustees' repayment in the trust game and the dictators' altruistic transfer in the dictator game.
Introduction
Trust is often described as the "invisible glue" that holds the global economy and social structures together. While neuroimaging studies (fMRI) and clinical observations of patients with brain lesions have consistently implicated the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) in social decision-making, establishing a definitive causal link between this region and trustworthiness has remained a challenge. Previous research has established a correlation—people who are more altruistic tend to be more trustworthy—but it was unclear if the vmPFC specifically drives the repayment behavior of a trustee or if it acts as a general social-processing hub. This study utilizes non-invasive brain stimulation to investigate whether modulating vmPFC excitability can directly influence a person's trustworthiness and altruism.
Methodology
The researchers employed transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS), a technique that applies a weak electrical current (2mA) to the scalp to either increase (anodal) or decrease (cathodal) the excitability of neurons in the underlying brain tissue. The study involved 100 healthy, right-handed participants across two distinct experiments.
In Experiment 1, 60 subjects were randomly assigned to anodal, cathodal, or sham (placebo) stimulation over the vmPFC. Following 20 minutes of stimulation, participants engaged in two classic economic games implemented via z-Tree software:
- The Trust Game: Participants acted as "trustees" who received money from a "trustor" (which was tripled) and had to decide how much to return.
- The Dictator Game: Participants were given money and decided how much to unilaterally give to a stranger, serving as a pure measure of altruistic preference.
Experiment 2 served as a control, with 40 subjects receiving stimulation over the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC), another area involved in decision-making, to determine if the observed effects were specific to the vmPFC.
Results
The results demonstrated a significant increase in pro-social behavior following anodal stimulation of the vmPFC. In the Trust Game, the anodal group returned a mean repayment ratio of 53.6%, significantly higher than the 36.8% observed in the sham group. Similarly, in the Dictator Game, the anodal group gave away nearly double the amount of the sham group (mean of 3.75 tokens vs. 2.00 tokens).
Crucially, stimulation of the dlPFC in Experiment 2 produced no significant changes in repayment or giving, confirming the neural specificity of the vmPFC in these cooperative interactions. Interestingly, while anodal (excitatory) stimulation enhanced these behaviors, cathodal (inhibitory) stimulation did not significantly decrease them relative to the sham group, suggesting a potential baseline maintenance mechanism for social behavior in the human brain.
Discussion and Conclusion
This study provides direct evidence that the vmPFC is causally involved in modulating trustworthiness and altruism. The findings suggest that altruistic preference acts as the underlying engine for trustworthy behavior; by exciting the vmPFC, researchers were able to enhance both generosity and reciprocal repayment. While tDCS provides a powerful tool for intervention, it does not visualize dynamic neural flow; future research combining tDCS with fMRI could further elucidate the network-wide reactions to vmPFC stimulation. Ultimately, these results highlight the vmPFC as a critical seat of the human "moral compass" in economic and social exchanges, proving that modulating brain activity can directly dial a person's cooperative impulses up or down.
Summary updated