Modified Collardversusend‐to‐side hand‐sewn anastomosis for cervical anastomosis after<scp>McKeown</scp>esophagectomy

Xiaokun Li, Yang Xu, Zhuangzhuang Cong, Jing Luo, Hai Zhou, Saiguang Ji, Yifei Diao, Wen‐Jie Wu, Yong Qiang, Jianjun Qian, Yi ShenThoracic 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares two surgical techniques for creating an anastomosis in the neck after esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: the modified Collard (MC) method and the end-to-side (ETS) hand-sewn method. While the MC technique shows promise in reducing long-term issues like strictures and dysphagia, it comes with a higher risk of early anastomotic leaks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Esophageal cancer surgery, specifically esophagectomy, is a complex procedure with a high rate of postoperative complications. A critical step is the reconstruction of the digestive tract, typically involving an anastomosis between the esophagus and the stomach (or a gastric conduit). Two major complications at this anastomosis are anastomotic leakage (where the connection breaks down, leading to leakage of digestive contents) and anastomotic stricture (narrowing of the connection, causing difficulty swallowing). These complications significantly impact patient survival and quality of life. While various techniques exist, the optimal method for creating this cervical anastomosis remains a subject of debate. This paper aims to compare the long-term outcomes of two specific hand-sewn techniques: the modified Collard (MC) anastomosis and the end-to-side (ETS) anastomosis, focusing on the incidence of strictures, dysphagia, and early complications like leakage.

Methods

This was a retrospective cohort study involving 905 patients who underwent a McKeown esophagectomy with either a modified Collard (MC) or an end-to-side (ETS) cervical anastomosis. The study reviewed clinical data from January 2014 to January 2017.

Key aspects of the methodology include:

  • Patient Selection: Inclusion criteria focused on pathologically diagnosed esophageal cancer patients who underwent McKeown esophagectomy with either MC or ETS anastomosis and extended two-field lymphadenectomies. Patients with insufficient records or a history of other malignant tumors were excluded.
  • Data Collection: A wide range of data was collected, including patient demographics, tumor characteristics, surgical details (type of surgery, time, blood loss, nutrition support), and early postoperative complications (chylothorax, pulmonary issues, anastomotic leakage, surgical site infection).
  • Outcome Measures:
    • Primary Endpoint: The rate of postoperative stricture formation over three years, assessed via stricture-free survival.
  • Secondary Endpoints: Incidence of dysphagia, time to first stricture onset, and the number of dilatations required for stricture management.
  • Follow-up: Patients were followed up every three months for the first three years, then every six months. Follow-up included outpatient visits, home visits, or telephone calls. Imaging during follow-up involved chest CT scans or videoendoscopy.
  • Statistical Analysis: Standard statistical tests (chi-square, Fisher's exact, Student's t-test, Mann-Whitney U test) were used to compare categorical and continuous variables, with a significance level of P < 0.05.

Datasets

The study utilized the clinical data of 905 patients from the Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery at Jinling Hospital. This represents a single-center retrospective dataset. No new benchmarks or datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stricture Reduction is Key: The primary goal of esophagectomy reconstruction is not just survival but also restoring normal swallowing function. Strictures severely impair this, making them a critical endpoint.
  • MC's Promise for Long-Term Function: The modified Collard anastomosis appears to offer a significant advantage in reducing the long-term incidence of anastomotic strictures and the associated dysphagia. This suggests it may lead to better quality of life for patients post-surgery.
  • The Trade-off: Leakage Risk: The benefit of reduced strictures with the MC technique comes at the cost of a higher incidence of early anastomotic leakage. This highlights a crucial trade-off that surgeons and patients must consider.
  • Potential Explanations for Differences: The paper speculates on reasons for the observed differences, such as the larger anastomotic diameter created by the MC technique (potentially reducing tension and ischemia) and the specific suturing techniques employed.

Key Results

  • Anastomotic Leakage: The incidence of anastomotic leakage tended to be higher in the MC group (13.0%) compared to the ETS group (8.7%), though this difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.064).
  • Anastomotic Stricture: The MC group had significantly lower rates of anastomotic stricture (benign stricture) compared to the ETS group (11.9% vs. 17.2%, P = 0.004). This was also true for severe strictures (11.9% vs. 17.2%, P = 0.024).
  • Dysphagia: The MC group showed a significantly lower rate of dysphagia (≥ grade 2) compared to the ETS group (20.0% vs. 28.5%, P = 0.032).
  • Onset of Stricture: The first time of onset of stricture was significantly longer in the MC group (4.80 ± 2.33 months) compared to the ETS group (4.06 ± 1.87 months, P = 0.038).
  • Dilatations: The number of dilatations required was surprisingly higher in the ETS group (2.46 ± 0.82) compared to the MC group (2.34 ± 0.51, P = 0.011), which seems counterintuitive given the lower stricture rate in MC. Correction: The paper states "A significantly higher number of dilatations in the ETS group were found compared with the MC group (P = 0.011)." This implies the MC group had fewer dilatations, aligning with fewer strictures.
  • Short-term Outcomes: No significant differences were found in 30-day or 90-day mortality between the two groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrospective Nature: The study is retrospective and single-center, which introduces potential selection bias and limits generalizability.
  • Confounding Factors: While efforts were made to control for variables, it's challenging to completely eliminate bias between the two groups, especially given the complexity of surgical outcomes.
  • Technical Nuances: The paper suggests that the specific insertion length of the stapler in the anastomosis might influence stricture rates, indicating a need for further research into optimal technical parameters.
  • Future Directions: The authors imply that more studies are needed to investigate the appropriate insertion length for staplers and to further explore the factors influencing anastomotic complications. The trade-off between leakage and stricture rates with the MC technique warrants further investigation to optimize its application.

Summary updated

Abstract

A modified Collard cervical esophagogastric anastomosis was associated with lower rates of anastomotic stricture and dysphagia, compared with ETS hand-sewn anastomosis. However, the modified Collard anastomosis is accompanied by an increased anastomotic leakage rate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020modified,
  author = {Xiaokun Li and Yang Xu and Zhuangzhuang Cong and Jing Luo and Hai Zhou and Saiguang Ji and Yifei Diao and Wen‐Jie Wu and Yong Qiang and Jianjun Qian and Yi Shen},
  title = {{Modified Collard<i>versus</i>end‐to‐side hand‐sewn anastomosis for cervical anastomosis after<scp>McKeown</scp>esophagectomy}},
  booktitle = {Thoracic},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1111/1759-7714.13630},
}
Figure