Modification of the Sweetness and Stability of Sweet-Tasting Protein Monellin by Gene Mutation and Protein Engineering

Qiulei Liu, Lei Li, Liu Yang, Tianming Liu, Chenggu Cai, Bo LiuBioMed 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study successfully engineered the sweet-tasting protein monellin to significantly improve its heat stability without compromising its sweetness. By employing site-directed mutagenesis guided by structural analysis, researchers identified key amino acid residues (E23 and C41) whose modification dramatically enhances monellin's resilience to heat, paving the way for its broader application in the food industry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Monellin, a natural protein sweetener extracted from the West African plant Dioscoreophyllum cumminsii, offers a high sweetness-to-calorie ratio, making it an attractive alternative to sugar. However, its widespread use in food products is severely limited by its poor stability at elevated temperatures and extreme pH conditions. This inherent instability leads to denaturation and loss of sweetness, hindering its commercial viability. The paper aims to overcome this limitation by modifying monellin's structure through genetic engineering to enhance its thermostability while preserving or even improving its desirable sweet taste.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining bioinformatics analysis, gene mutation, and protein engineering.

  • Bioinformatics and Structural Analysis: They analyzed the known sequence and crystal structure of monellin to identify potential target residues for modification.
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis: Based on the structural insights, they systematically introduced mutations, primarily alanine substitutions, at specific amino acid positions. Particular focus was placed on residues within the α-helix region and an ionizable residue (C41).
  • Gene Cloning and Expression: The modified monellin genes were synthesized, cloned into expression vectors (pET15b), and then expressed in Escherichia coli (BL21-CodonPlus(DE3)-RIL) for large-scale production.
  • Protein Purification: The recombinant proteins were purified using nickel affinity chromatography (Ni Sepharose High Performance).
  • Thermostability Assay: Proteins were incubated at various temperatures (40°C to 90°C) for extended periods, and their stability was assessed by SDS-PAGE after centrifugation to remove denatured protein. Maximum heat resistance temperature was determined.
  • Sweetness Threshold Assay: A double-blind taste assay was conducted by a panel of ten healthy volunteers to determine the lowest concentration at which sweetness was perceived. This was compared to sucrose and wild-type monellin.
  • His-tag Removal: To assess the impact of the purification tag, the N-terminal His-tag was removed using thrombin cleavage, and the properties of the untagged proteins were re-evaluated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing structural data (PDB: 1MOL, 2O9U) and the synthesized gene sequence of monellin.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • α-Helix Ends are Hotspots for Stability: Mutagenesis studies revealed that residues located at the two ends of the α-helix region are crucial for enhancing monellin's thermostability. This suggests a symmetrical distribution of stabilizing residues within this structural element.
  • Buried Ionizable Residues Play a Key Role: Molecular biophysics analysis points to the state of buried ionizable residues as a significant factor in modulating protein properties. The E23 residue, an ionizable residue located at the C-terminal end of the α-helix and largely buried, was found to be particularly important for thermal stability.
  • Structure-Guided Engineering is Effective: The study strongly supports the efficacy of using bioinformatics and structural information to guide gene manipulation for optimizing protein properties. This "structure-guided molecular design" approach is highlighted as a powerful tool.
  • His-tag is Inert for These Properties: The removal of the N-terminal His-tag did not affect the sweetness threshold or thermostability of the tested monellin variants, indicating that the tag does not interfere with these functional characteristics.

Key Results

  • E23A Mutant: This mutant showed a remarkable improvement in thermal stability, remaining stable after 30 minutes of incubation at 85°C. Its sweetness was not affected compared to the wild type.
  • C41A Mutant: This mutant exhibited increased sweetness (lower threshold) and a slight improvement in thermostability.
  • Other Stabilizing Mutants: Several other mutants (P10A, F11A, N14A, N24A, and I26A), located at the ends of the α-helix, showed a modest increase in thermostability (around 5°C).
  • K17A Mutant: This mutant showed a significant reduction in sweetness and a decrease in thermostability.
  • A19E Mutant: This mutant was not successfully expressed, suggesting the residue at position 19 is critical for proper protein folding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • A19E Insolubility: The complete insolubility of the A19E mutant indicates that this residue is essential for proper folding, a limitation that needs to be considered in future engineering efforts.
  • Synergistic Effects: The paper suggests further investigation into the synergistic or additive effects of multiple mutations on sweetness and stability.
  • Broader Application: While the study demonstrates improved thermostability, further research is needed to assess the impact of these modifications on other stability factors like pH resistance and to evaluate their performance in actual food matrices.
  • Mechanism of Sweetness: The exact mechanism by which sweet proteins interact with taste receptors remains complex, and while this study modifies properties, deeper understanding of the interaction interface could lead to more targeted engineering.

Summary updated

Abstract

Natural sweet protein monellin has a high sweetness and low calorie, suggesting its potential in food applications. However, due to its low heat and acid resistance, the application of monellin is limited. In this study, we show that the thermostability of monellin can be improved with no sweetness decrease by means of sequence, structure analysis, and site-directed mutagenesis. We analyzed residues located in the α-helix as well as an ionizable residue C41. Of the mutants investigated, the effects of E23A and C41A mutants were most remarkable. The former displayed significantly improved thermal stability, while its sweetness was not changed. The mutated protein was stable after 30 min incubation at 85°C. The latter showed increased sweetness and slight improvement of thermostability. Furthermore, we found that most mutants enhancing the thermostability of the protein were distributed at the two ends of α-helix. Molecular biophysics analysis revealed that the state of buried ionizable residues may account for the modulated properties of mutated proteins. Our results prove that the properties of sweet protein monellin can be modified by means of bioinformatics analysis, gene manipulation, and protein modification, highlighting the possibility of designing novel effective sweet proteins based on structure-function relationships.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2016modification,
  author = {Qiulei Liu and Lei Li and Liu Yang and Tianming Liu and Chenggu Cai and Bo Liu},
  title = {{Modification of the Sweetness and Stability of Sweet-Tasting Protein Monellin by Gene Mutation and Protein Engineering}},
  booktitle = {BioMed},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1155/2016/3647173},
}
Figure