Fluid flow in porous media is a fundamental scientific challenge in the development of oil and gas reservoirs. While traditional mechanics based on the continuum hypothesis and Darcy’s Law have served the industry for decades, they are increasingly inadequate for unconventional reservoirs like shale, tight gas, and fractured-vuggy carbonates. These reservoirs exhibit extreme multi-scale characteristics—spanning six orders of magnitude—and involve complex multi-field interactions. This paper proposes a "modern system" of multiphase flow that integrates multi-scale porous media, multi-field coupling (stress, thermal, chemical, and physical), and diverse flow patterns to bridge the gap between laboratory physics and field-scale production.
The Limitations of Darcy’s Law in Unconventional Reservoirs
For over a century, the oil and gas industry relied on Darcy’s Law, which assumes a linear relationship between pressure and flow in a continuous, uniform medium. However, unconventional extraction faces three primary hurdles:
Scale Disparity: Pore sizes in shale range from nanometer-sized organic pores to kilometer-long hydraulic fractures.
Complex Physics: In nano-pores, fluids do not simply flow; they adsorb to surfaces, slip along walls, and exhibit non-Newtonian behavior.
Multi-field Coupling: High-volume hydraulic fracturing induces strong stress interactions. Flow is no longer a purely hydraulic problem; it is inextricably linked to geomechanics (stress), thermodynamics (heat), and chemistry.
The Modern System Framework
The proposed modern system defines a hierarchical approach to modeling, moving away from "one size fits all" equations. It is built upon the "Five Multis": Multi-porous media (organic vs. inorganic), Multi-scale (nm to km), Multi-phase (oil/water/gas), Multi-pattern (adsorption, slip, Darcy, free flow), and Multi-field coupling.
The proposed modern system for multiphase flow, illustrating the integration of multi-scale media with multi-field coupling (stress, thermal, chemical, and physical).
To address these complexities, the framework advocates for a tiered simulation strategy:
Nano-scale: Utilizing Molecular Dynamics (MD) and Density Functional Theory (DFT) to understand interfacial phenomena and hydrocarbon transport in nanopores.
Micro-scale: Using Digital Core technology (reconstructed via CT or FIB-SEM) combined with the Lattice Boltzmann Method (LBM) and Pore Network Models (PNM) to simulate flow through actual rock geometries.
Upscaling: Applying Homogenization Theory and Volume Averaging to translate nano-micro mechanisms into macro-scale parameters.
Macro-scale: Implementing Discrete Fracture Models (DFM) and Embedded Discrete Fracture Models (EDFM) to handle complex fracture networks, often coupled with the Extended Finite Element Method (XFEM) for geomechanics.
Key Insights and Results
Nano-scale Transport
Research identified that in pores smaller than 10nm, surface adsorption and Knudsen diffusion account for a significant portion of total flow, which Darcy-based models ignore. Molecular dynamics simulations reveal how specific factors, such as vibrational charges and frequency, drastically alter fluid flux at these scales.
Molecular dynamics (MD) results showing non-linear transport behaviors at the nano-scale, where factors like vibrational charge and frequency significantly influence fluid flux.
New multi-scale discrete fracture models have demonstrated a 2.6x speedup in simulation time compared to traditional methods while maintaining high accuracy. Furthermore, physical simulations using 3D-printed models and laser etching have successfully validated the non-linear flow regimes predicted by these new mathematical frameworks, particularly the critical Stokes-Darcy coupling required at the interface of carbonate "caves" and surrounding rock.
Future Directions
Despite significant progress, several challenges remain. Developing robust upscaling methods for highly heterogeneous, non-periodic "real-world" rock is a major hurdle. Additionally, fully coupling four or five physical fields at the reservoir scale remains computationally prohibitive. Future work must focus on improving computational efficiency and integrating "nano-confinement" effects—where fluid phase behavior changes inside 2nm pores—into reservoir-scale models to move toward true "Digital Twin" reservoir management.
Summary updated
Abstract
Fluid flow in porous media is the key scientific problem in the development of oil and gas reservoirs. The traditional mechanics of fluid flow in porous media which based on the continuum hypothesis and Darcy′s law plays an important role in developing conventional oil and gas resources. In recent years, unconventional reservoirs are drawing more and more attention all over the world, therefore the development theory and technology, especially the corresponding flow mechanisms have become the hot research issues. The unconventional reservoirs exhibit distinct multiscale characteristics, even with six orders of magnitude difference. In addition, the application of massive multi-stage hydraulic fracturing can induce strong stress interactions. Therefore, the traditional theory of fluid flow in porous media cannot accurately describe the flow characteristics in unconventional reservoirs. In essence, the development of unconventional oil and gas resources involves multiphase fluids (e.g. oil, water and gas) flow in multi-scale porous media with multi-field coupling and various flow patterns. Therefore, the concept of modern system of multiphase flow in porous media is proposed, which means multiphase fluids flowing in multi-scale porous media with multi-field coupling and various flow patterns. The research status and development tendency are reviewed from the aspects of: (1) micro- and nanoscale oil and gas flow simulation; (2) upscaling for reservoir simulation, (3) macroscale flow simulation of unconventional oil and gas reservoirs; (4) simulation of flow in large scale fractured and vuggy carbonate reservoirs and (5) physical simulation of hydrocarbon transport in porous media. More specifically, in nanoscale the density functional theory and molecular simulation method can be used to study the interfacial phenomena to understand the hydrocarbon transport behavior in nanopores and provide key parameters for mesoscale flow simulation. The current study of nanoscale simulation mainly focuses on developing more realistic molecular structure model to represent the heterogeneous shale samples. Microscale simulation methods involve pore network model, lattice Boltzmann method, direct simulation of Navies-Stokes equation, level-set method and smoothed particle hydrodynamics, etc. Digital core and pore network model are the fundamental research platforms. Various methods can be used to reconstruct digital cores with multiscale pore structures and mineral compositions. The complex physicochemical phenomena namely adsorption/desorption, wettability change and boundary effect should be considered in the microscale flow simulations and extensive works have been done in microscale gas flow simulations. The future work on microscale simulation should focus on the multiphase flow mechanisms with multi-field coupling. The multiscale characteristics of unconventional reservoirs indicate the necessity of upscaling process to introduce the microscale flow mechanisms to macroscale. Homogenization theory and volume averaging method are the main upscaling approaches. Current upscaling methods are mostly based on the periodic boundary condition and are unreliable to be used in complex oil and gas reservoirs, which needs further study. In addition, more research needs to be conducted on the upscaling from molecular scale to mesoscale. In macroscale simulations of unconventional oil and gas reservoirs, the fluid-structure interaction should be considered and high efficiency numerical algorithm needs to be established. For large scale fractured and vuggy carbonate reservoirs, the non-Darcy flow characteristics and different flow regimes in vugs and fractures should be taken into account during flow simulation. Physical simulations of hydrocarbon transport in porous media are conducted at two scales: macroscale, nano- and microscale. Macroscale physical simulations aim at monitoring the dynamic saturation and pressure fields change under the realistic reservoir conditions. Nano- and microscale physical simulations are mainly applied to study the fluid transport mechanisms in single pore or throat. In summary, the proposed theory of multiphase fluids flowing in multi-scale porous media with multi-field coupling and various flow patterns can be applied to study the fluid flow problems in unconventional oil and gas industries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yao2017modern,
author = {Jun Yao and Hai Sun and Aifen Li and Yongfei Yang and Zhaoqin Huang and Yueying Wang and Lei Zhang and Jianlong Kou and Haojun Xie and Jianlin Zhao and Xia Yan and Qingfu Zhang and Xiaoxia Ren and Wencheng Han and Piyang Liu and Guangpu Zhu and Wenhui Song and Hongguang Sui and Senyou An and Zhen Wang and Wenzheng Liu and Xu Zhang and Zheng Li},
title = {{Modern system of multiphase flow in porous media and its development trend}},
booktitle = {Chinese},
year = {2017},
doi = {10.1360/n972017-00161},
}