MODEM: multi-omics data envelopment and mining in maize

Haijun Liu, Fan Wang, Yingjie Xiao, Zonglin Tian, Weiwei Wen, Xuehai Zhang, Xi Chen, Nannan Liu, Wenqiang Li, Lei Liu, Jie Liu, Jianbing Yan, Jianxiao LiuDatabase 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces MODEM, a comprehensive database integrating multi-omics data (genomic, transcriptomic, metabolic, and phenotypic) for maize. It aims to facilitate a deeper understanding of maize genetic architecture and genotype-phenotype relationships by providing a user-friendly platform for data exploration and genetic mapping.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maize is a crucial crop globally and a model organism for plant genetics. While significant progress has been made in generating high-throughput omics data for maize, existing database resources have lagged behind, particularly in providing integrated, multi-dimensional datasets for advanced functional genomics studies like Quantitative Trait Loci (QTL) mapping. There's a clear need for a centralized, comprehensive resource that combines genomic variations, gene expression, metabolic profiles, and phenotypic data from a consistent, diverse set of maize lines to enable robust association mapping and functional annotation of the complex maize genome.

Methods

The MODEM database was built by integrating several types of data generated from a diverse panel of 527 maize inbred lines.

  • Genomic Variation: Approximately 1.06 million high-quality Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) were identified. This was achieved by combining data from a 50K Maize SNP array (for 513 lines) and RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) of whole kernels from 368 lines. Sophisticated SNP calling and imputation methods were employed to ensure data quality and completeness.
  • Transcriptomic Data: RNA-seq was performed on 368 maize inbred lines to quantify gene expression levels in kernels at 15 days after pollination (DAP). Reads were mapped to the B73 reference genome, and gene expression was quantified using RPKM normalization.
  • Metabolomic Data: A widely targeted metabolomics approach using LC-ESI-MS/MS was used to profile 983 metabolic features, including amino acids, flavonoids, and fatty acids, from kernel samples of the association mapping panel.
  • Phenotypic Data: Nearly 50 agronomic traits were collected across multiple locations and years for the association mapping panel, encompassing yield, drought response, and disease resistance.
  • Genetic Mapping: The integrated datasets were used to perform various genetic mapping analyses, including phenotypic QTL (pQTL), expression QTL (eQTL), and metabolic QTL (mQTL) mapping using linear mixed models that account for population structure and kinship.
  • Database Development: The platform was developed using a Struts 2 framework with a Java backend and a web interface built with JSP, JavaScript, HTML5 Canvas, and AJAX. A JBrowse genome browser was integrated for visualization.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in MODEM is derived from a collection of 527 elite maize inbred lines, forming an association mapping panel (AMP). This panel includes lines from major breeding programs in China, CIMMYT, and the Germplasm Enhancement of Maize (GEM) project.

  • Genomic Data: ~1.06 million high-quality SNPs from a 50K Maize SNP array and RNA-seq.
  • Transcriptomic Data: RNA-seq data from 368 lines.
  • Metabolomic Data: Profiling of 983 metabolic features from the AMP.
  • Phenotypic Data: ~50 agronomic traits for the AMP.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather integrates existing data types from a well-defined panel to create a novel, comprehensive resource.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integration is Key: The core idea is that integrating diverse omics data from the same diverse panel of maize lines is crucial for uncovering complex genotype-phenotype relationships and understanding genetic architecture.
  • Bridging the Gap: MODEM addresses the gap between raw omics data generation and its application in functional genomics by providing a curated, searchable, and visualized platform.
  • Enabling Multi-Scale Analysis: The database allows researchers to explore relationships from the cellular (metabolites, gene expression) to the whole plant level (phenotypes), facilitating a holistic understanding of maize biology.
  • Facilitating Novel Method Development: By providing a rich, multi-dimensional dataset and associated mapping results, MODEM serves as a valuable resource for developing and testing new analytical methods in plant genetics.

Key Results

  • Comprehensive Data Integration: MODEM houses approximately 1.06 million high-quality SNPs, gene expression data for 28,769 expressed genes, and profiles of 983 metabolic features, all linked to ~50 agronomic traits.
  • Robust Mapping Results: The database includes pre-computed QTL mapping results (pQTL, eQTL, mQTL) derived from sophisticated statistical models, providing immediate value to researchers.
  • User-Friendly Interface: The platform offers intuitive visualization tools, including a genome browser, and flexible search and download capabilities, making complex data accessible.
  • Data Availability: All original data and mapping results are freely available for query and download, promoting open science and collaborative research.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The initial release focuses on whole kernel RNA-seq at a single time point (15 DAP). This might not capture dynamic gene expression changes throughout kernel development.
  • While comprehensive, the database is still a "first release" and will be continually updated.
  • The paper mentions that the quantile transformation for expression values doesn't fully solve the problem of non-normal distribution within each genotype class, though it's a practical approach.
  • Future Work:
    • Expansion of Data: The authors plan to integrate more data, including higher-density variant maps (e.g., from 600K and GBS strategies), diverse variation types (structural variation, TE presence/absence), and additional phenotypes (e.g., disease and drought-related traits).
  • Enhanced Tools: Development of tools for primer design, rapid haplotype construction, and gene regulatory network inference is planned. Integration with R for advanced analyses is also a goal.
  • Integration with Public Data: The platform will incorporate other public datasets, such as expression patterns across different tissues, GWAS results from other groups, and epigenetic modification data (DMRs, open chromatin regions).
  • Application to Other Species: The MODEM platform's architecture is designed to be adaptable for other crop species.

Summary updated

Abstract

MODEM is a comprehensive database of maize multidimensional omics data, including genomic, transcriptomic, metabolic and phenotypic information from the cellular to individual plant level. This initial release contains approximately 1.06 M high quality SNPs for 508 diverse inbred lines obtained by combining variations from RNA sequencing on whole kernels (15 days after pollination) of 368 lines and a 50 K array for all 508 individuals. As all of these data were derived from the same diverse panel of lines, the database also allows various types of genetic mapping (including characterization of phenotypic QTLs, pQTLs; expression QTLs, eQTLs and metabolic QTLs, mQTLs). MODEM is thus designed to promote a better understanding of maize genetic architecture and deep functional annotation of the complex maize genome (and potentially those of other crop plants) and to explore the genotype-phenotype relationships and regulation of maize kernel development at multiple scales, which is also comprehensive for developing novel methods. MODEM is additionally designed to link with other databases to make full use of current resources, and it provides visualization tools for easy browsing. All of the original data and the related mapping results are freely available for easy query and download. This platform also provides helpful tools for general analyses and will be continually updated with additional materials, features and public data related to maize genetics or regulation as they become available.Database URL: (http://modem.hzau.edu.cn).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2016modem,
  author = {Haijun Liu and Fan Wang and Yingjie Xiao and Zonglin Tian and Weiwei Wen and Xuehai Zhang and Xi Chen and Nannan Liu and Wenqiang Li and Lei Liu and Jie Liu and Jianbing Yan and Jianxiao Liu},
  title = {{MODEM: multi-omics data envelopment and mining in maize}},
  booktitle = {Database},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1093/database/baw117},
}
Figure