Abstract
In positive psychology, the study of happiness is more popular than that of serenity. Many studies have found connections between helping and happiness and between happiness and serenity. However, research that examines all three variables and how they relate in a model is limited. This study aims to develop models of helping, happiness, and serenity using students from Indonesia and China. A total of 103 Indonesian students and 104 Chinese students contributed to this research. The Helping Attitude Scale (HAS), Subjective Happiness Scale (SHS), Tatmainn al-Qulūb Scale (TQS), and Peace of Mind Scale (PoM) were used in this study. The results show that for Indonesian students, helping is a predictor of spiritual serenity but not of happiness. However, one aspect of helping, belief, can be a predictor of happiness. This model is confirmed using the CFI (0.97), GFI (0.97), and TLI (0.91) parameters. In contrast, for Chinese students, helping is a predictor of happiness but not of spiritual serenity. However, helping is a predictor of one component of spiritual serenity: confidence. This model is confirmed using the GFI (1) and AGFI (0.97) parameters.
Introduction
While the "helper’s high"—the boost in well-being following altruistic acts—is well-documented, the specific psychological pathways it follows across different cultures remain under-explored. Positive psychology has traditionally prioritized "happiness" (subjective well-being) over "serenity" (peace of mind). This study investigates how helping behavior influences both happiness and spiritual serenity among university students in Indonesia and China, two nations with distinct philosophical and religious foundations.
The researchers posit that serenity is defined differently across cultures: "theocentric" (God-centered) in Islamic traditions like Indonesia, and "anthropocentric" (human-centered) in Chinese traditions. This study seeks to model these relationships to determine if the link between altruism and well-being is universal or culturally contingent.
Methodology
The study employed a cross-sectional survey design with 207 university students: 103 from Indonesia (predominantly female, 100% believers) and 104 from China (mixed gender, ~51% believers). Participants completed four validated instruments:
- Helping Attitude Scale (HAS): Assessing belief, feeling, and behavioral dimensions of helping.
- Subjective Happiness Scale (SHS): Measuring global subjective happiness.
- Tatmainn al-Qulūb Scale (TQS): An Islamic-rooted measure of spiritual serenity (calmness and confidence).
- Peace of Mind Scale (PoM): A Chinese-rooted scale for internal peace and harmony.
Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used to test the theoretical models for each cohort.
Results and Analysis
The structural models revealed significant cultural divergence in how helping behavior translates into well-being.
The Indonesian Model: Serenity through Sincerity
For Indonesian students, helping behavior was a direct and strong predictor of spiritual serenity ($\beta = 0.54, p < 0.001$). Interestingly, helping did not directly predict overall happiness. Instead, happiness was predicted specifically by the Belief sub-dimension of helping ($\beta = 0.29, p = 0.001$), suggesting that the religious or moral sincerity behind the act is the necessary catalyst for happiness in this context.
The Chinese Model: Direct Happiness and Confidence
In the Chinese cohort, helping acted as a direct predictor of happiness ($\beta = 0.22, p = 0.021$). While it did not predict overall spiritual serenity, it was a significant predictor of Confidence ($\beta = 0.37, p < 0.001$), a key component of serenity in the anthropocentric model.
Model Validation
The validity of these distinct cultural models was confirmed through various fit indices. The Indonesian model showed excellent fit (CFI = 0.97, GFI = 0.97), while the Chinese model was supported by high GFI (1.00) and AGFI (0.97) scores.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings highlight a "sincerity filter" in the Indonesian context, where helping only leads to happiness when driven by deep-seated belief. In contrast, the Chinese model suggests a more direct emotional payoff from altruism. Furthermore, the failure of the TQS (Islamic serenity scale) to provide a valid structure for the Chinese sample underscores the difficulty of applying theocentric psychological tools to more secular populations.
This research demonstrates that while helping others is a cross-cultural virtue, its psychological outcomes are mediated by cultural and religious frameworks. Serenity may represent a state of "affective bliss" that, in some cultures, is more closely tied to altruistic behavior than happiness itself.
Summary updated