Modelling the ecological impacts of tidal energy barrages

Amy Baker, Robert Craighead, Emma Jarvis, Harriett C. Stenton, Athanasios Angeloudis, Lucas Mackie, Alexandros Avdis, Matthew D. Piggott, Jon Hill2020 · DOI

Abstract

Tidal energy has the potential to form a key component of the energy mix of a number of countries, including the UK. Nonetheless, the deployment of tidal energy systems is associated with potential environmental impacts as prime resource sites often coincide with unique ecosystems inhabited by sensitive organisms. Preceding studies have generally focused on the hydrodynamic impact of tidal energy schemes, i.e. how schemes alter the flow dynamics and sedimentary transport processes. Whilst these efforts are key in understanding environmental impacts, there is no straightforward step for translating sediment to faunal changes. Species distribution models offer methods to quantitatively predict certain possible impacts of tidal energy extraction. The River Severn is a distinguished candidate region for tidal energy in the UK featuring sites under stringent ecological protection regulations. We examine the impact of a proposed Severn tidal barrage on 14 species via the linking of hydrodynamic modelling to species distribution models. Through a selection of species that are linked via a simple food web system we extrapolate changes in prey species to the respective predator species. We show that species at lower trophic levels are adversely affected by the barrage, but higher trophic level organisms increase in possible habitable area. Once food web relationships are acknowledged this increase in habitat area decreases, but is still net positive. Overall, all 14 species were affected, with most gaining in distribution area, and only four losing distribution area within the Severn Estuary. We conclude that a large-scale tidal barrage may have detrimental and complex impacts on species distribution, altering food web dynamics and threatening food availability in the Severn Estuary. The methodology outlined herein can be transferred to the assessment and optimisation of prospective projects globally to aide in the sustainable introduction of the technology.

Introduction

As nations strive for net-zero carbon emissions, tidal energy has emerged as a critical renewable resource. The Severn Estuary in the UK is a primary candidate for large-scale tidal energy extraction due to its immense tidal range. However, such developments pose significant risks to local ecosystems. While the hydrodynamic consequences—alterations in flow, salinity, and sediment transport—are well-studied, the subsequent biological impacts remain poorly quantified. Traditional environmental impact assessments often evaluate species in isolation, failing to account for the complex interdependencies within a food web. This study introduces a novel framework that bridges this gap by coupling hydrodynamic modeling with machine learning-based species distribution models (SDMs) to predict ecological shifts.

Methodology

The research utilized a two-stage modeling pipeline to assess the impact of a proposed 8.6 GW tidal barrage in the Severn Estuary.

  1. Hydrodynamic Simulation: The Thetis unstructured-mesh coastal ocean model was employed to simulate the estuary's physical environment before and after the barrage installation. This provided high-resolution spatial data on variables such as maximum flow velocity and tidal range, forced by the TPXO tidal harmonic database and river inflow data from the UK National River Flow Archive.
  2. Species Distribution Modeling: The MaxEnt (Maximum Entropy) algorithm was used to predict habitat suitability for 14 key species, including benthic organisms like the mud shrimp (C. volutator) and predators like the Dover sole (S. solea). Species occurrence data was sourced from the National Biodiversity Network (NBN) Atlas.
  3. Trophic Integration: In a departure from standard practice, this approach incorporated predicted prey distributions as environmental layers for predator models. This "bottom-up" approach allows for the assessment of how habitat loss at lower trophic levels ripples through the food web.
The modeled food web of 14 species used to inform the SDMs.

Results and Discussion

The simulation revealed profound physical changes landward of the barrage. The structure significantly reduces both the maximum flow velocity and the tidal range, creating a "calmer" environment that fundamentally alters the benthic habitat.

Hydrodynamic impacts of the barrage on maximum velocity and tidal range.

Ecological Winners and Losers

The study found that all 14 species were affected, though the impacts were non-uniform. Initially, without considering food web interactions, the model predicted a 38% net gain in habitable area across the estuary. However, this figure masks significant declines in critical benthic species. For instance, the mud shrimp (C. volutator) saw a 40.8% loss in distribution area, and the pink clam (M. balthica) lost 10.2%. Specific regions like Swansea Bay saw a marked decrease in suitability for almost all benthic organisms.

The Importance of Trophic Linking

The inclusion of trophic relationships significantly altered the predictions for higher-level predators. For the Dover sole (S. solea), a model based solely on physical parameters predicted a 14.9% gain in habitat. When prey availability was factored in, this prediction was corrected to a 5.9% loss. This discrepancy highlights the danger of "siloed" species modeling, which can lead to overly optimistic environmental assessments.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that large-scale tidal barrages can have complex and potentially detrimental impacts on estuarine ecology. While some species may appear to benefit from altered physical conditions, the loss of key prey species can lead to a net reduction in habitat suitability for predators.

Future work should expand this framework to include 3D hydrodynamic modeling for pelagic species and account for direct mortality factors such as turbine strikes or barotrauma. Additionally, linking these findings to intertidal habitat loss is essential for understanding the impact on protected wading bird populations. The methodology presented here provides a scalable tool for the sustainable planning of tidal energy projects worldwide.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tidal energy has the potential to form a key component of the energy mix of a number of countries, including the UK. Nonetheless, the deployment of tidal energy systems is associated with potential environmental impacts as prime resource sites often coincide with unique ecosystems inhabited by sensitive organisms. Preceding studies have generally focused on the hydrodynamic impact of tidal energy schemes, i.e. how schemes alter the flow dynamics and sedimentary transport processes. Whilst these efforts are key in understanding environmental impacts, there is no straightforward step for translating sediment to faunal changes. Species distribution models offer methods to quantitatively predict certain possible impacts of tidal energy extraction. The River Severn is a distinguished candidate region for tidal energy in the UK featuring sites under stringent ecological protection regulations. We examine the impact of a proposed Severn tidal barrage on 14 species via the linking of hydrodynamic modelling to species distribution models. Through a selection of species that are linked via a simple food web system we extrapolate changes in prey species to the respective predator species. We show that species at lower trophic levels are adversely affected by the barrage, but higher trophic level organisms increase in possible habitable area. Once food web relationships are acknowledged this increase in habitat area decreases, but is still net positive. Overall, all 14 species were affected, with most gaining in distribution area, and only four losing distribution area within the Severn Estuary. We conclude that a large-scale tidal barrage may have detrimental and complex impacts on species distribution, altering food web dynamics and threatening food availability in the Severn Estuary. The methodology outlined herein can be transferred to the assessment and optimisation of prospective projects globally to aide in the sustainable introduction of the technology.
BibTeX
@misc{baker2020modelling,
  author = {Amy Baker and Robert Craighead and Emma Jarvis and Harriett C. Stenton and Athanasios Angeloudis and Lucas Mackie and Alexandros Avdis and Matthew D. Piggott and Jon Hill},
  title = {{Modelling the ecological impacts of tidal energy barrages}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.31223/osf.io/vapmu},
}
Figure