Modelling road mortality risks to persistence to a Western Toad ({\it Anaxyrus boreas}) population in British Columbia

Marguerite H. Mahr, Noah D. Marshall, Jessa Marley, Sarah K. Wyse, Wayne P. McCrory, Rebecca C. TysonarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Road mortality may be a significant factor in the global decline of amphibian populations, yet rigorous assessments of its effect on long-term population persistence are lacking. Here, we investigate population persistence through a field study and mathematical model of a western toad (Anaxyrus boreas) population within a highway corridor in the Selkirk Mountains of British Columbia. The analysis shows traffic levels strongly correlate with toad mortality, with each additional vehicle causing a 3.1% ± 1.3% ($p=0.020$) increase in toad deaths. Although the current risk of the population becoming threatened or endangered is low, it rises to 50% if baseline road mortality increases from 10% to 30%. Gravid female mortality is higher than the baseline mortality and can increase the probability of endangerment by nearly two-fold at higher baseline mortality levels. We make the case that a small increase in vehicle traffic resulting from future development and recreational pressures could destabilize this apparently healthy toad population. The high sensitivity to traffic levels and rapid transition from healthy to endangered raises concerns for similar populations worldwide. Compensatory structures such as amphibian underpasses (toad tunnels) should be given high priority.

Introduction

Amphibians are often considered the "canaries in the coal mine" for environmental health, yet they are uniquely vulnerable to anthropogenic infrastructure. Their complex life cycles require seasonal migrations between terrestrial foraging grounds and aquatic breeding sites, a journey that frequently forces them to cross high-traffic road corridors. While "roadkill" is a visible and tragic phenomenon, its long-term effect on population persistence—the ability of a population to survive over time—is notoriously difficult to quantify. This study bridges that gap by combining a six-year field study with a mechanistic mathematical framework to predict how specific traffic increases translate into long-term extinction risks for the Western Toad, a species of "Special Concern" in Canada.

Study Area and Field Methods

The field study (2016–2021) focused on a critical migration corridor along Highway 31A near Fish and Bear Lakes in the Selkirk Mountains of British Columbia. Researchers patrolled the highway to record toad counts, sex, "gravid" (egg-bearing) status, and vehicle frequency. This period included the COVID-19 pandemic, which provided a natural experiment with drastically reduced traffic levels, allowing for a clearer assessment of the relationship between vehicle volume and mortality.

Map of the study area showing Highway 31A and the toad migration area of interest near Fish and Bear Lakes in British Columbia.

The Impulsive ODE Model

To translate field observations into long-term predictions, we developed a stage-structured Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) model. Unlike standard continuous models, this framework utilizes impulsive events to represent migrations. This approach mathematically collapses multi-week migration periods into discrete "jumps" in the population state, capturing the seasonal nature of toad movement while keeping the model computationally tractable.

Diagram of the impulsive ODE model illustrating toad development stages and migration impulses across the road barrier at specific time intervals.

To account for ecological uncertainties, such as carrying capacity ($K$) or natural death rates, we conducted $10^5$ Monte Carlo simulations. These simulations sampled across a wide range of plausible values to determine the probability of the population falling below "Threatened" (1,000 individuals) or "Endangered" (250 individuals) thresholds over time.

Key Insights and Results

Traffic as a Direct Predictor

The analysis revealed a high correlation between vehicle counts and toad deaths. We estimate that each additional vehicle per minute on the road during migration causes a 3.1% ± 1.3% increase in mortality ($p = 0.020$).

The "Healthy Population" Illusion and Tipping Points

While the study area currently appears to host a healthy population, the model reveals that this stability is precarious. The population's health does not decline linearly with traffic; instead, there is a sharp "tipping point." A population that appears stable at 10% road mortality faces a 50% chance of endangerment if that mortality triples to 30%—a likely scenario given regional development pressures.

Female Vulnerability

Field observations suggest gravid females are disproportionately vulnerable, possibly because they linger on warm asphalt to aid the digestion of energy stores required for egg development. The model shows that at higher baseline mortality levels, this increased risk to egg-bearing females nearly doubles the probability of population endangerment.

Conclusion and Mitigation

The high sensitivity of Western Toad populations to traffic levels suggests that current "healthy" statuses may be deceptive. Small increases in recreational or industrial traffic could rapidly destabilize these systems. Consequently, mitigation strategies such as amphibian underpasses ("toad tunnels") and diversion fencing should be prioritized as essential requirements for long-term persistence in developing areas, rather than optional conservation measures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Road mortality may be a significant factor in the global decline of amphibian populations, yet rigorous assessments of its effect on long-term population persistence are lacking. Here, we investigate population persistence through a field study and mathematical model of a western toad ({\textit{Anaxyrus Boreas}} {\RR(Baird and Girard, 1852)}) population within a highway corridor in the Selkirk Mountains of British Columbia. The analysis shows traffic levels strongly correlate with toad mortality, with each additional vehicle causing a 3.1\% $\pm$ 1.3\% ($p=0.020$) increase in toad deaths. Although the current risk of the population becoming threatened or endangered is low, it rises to 50\% if baseline road mortality increases from 10\% to 30\%. Gravid female mortality is higher than the baseline mortality and can increase the probability of endangerment by nearly two-fold at higher baseline mortality levels. We make the case that a small increase in vehicle traffic resulting from future development and recreational pressures could destabilize this apparently healthy toad population. The high sensitivity to traffic levels and rapid transition from healthy to endangered raises concerns for similar populations worldwide. Compensatory structures such as amphibian underpasses (toad tunnels) should be given high priority.
BibTeX
@misc{mahr2025modelling,
  author = {Marguerite H. Mahr and Noah D. Marshall and Jessa Marley and Sarah K. Wyse and Wayne P. McCrory and Rebecca C. Tyson},
  title = {{Modelling road mortality risks to persistence to a Western Toad (\{\textbackslash\{\}it Anaxyrus boreas\}) population in British Columbia}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2510.00340},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.00340},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure