Modelling methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus decolonization: interactions between body sites and the impact of site-specific clearance

Onur Poyraz, Mohamad Sater, Loren G. Miller, James A. McKinnell, Susan S. Huang, Yonatan H. Grad, Pekka MarttinenJournal of The Royal Society Interface 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Bayesian coupled hidden Markov model (CHMM) to understand how MRSA colonization spreads between different body sites and how decolonization therapies affect this process. By analyzing data from a clinical trial, they not only confirm the importance of nasal treatments but also reveal that skin clearance offers the biggest potential for improving decolonization strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is a persistent public health threat, and its colonization, particularly in multiple body sites, is a major risk factor for developing infections. While decolonization protocols aim to clear MRSA, the optimal combination of therapies and their specific impact on different body sites remain unclear. Existing methods struggle to disentangle the complex interactions between body sites and the effectiveness of individual treatment components within a multi-site decolonization strategy. This paper tackles the challenge of understanding these interactions to design more effective and personalized MRSA decolonization protocols.

Methods

The core of this work is a novel Bayesian coupled hidden Markov model (CHMM). Unlike standard Hidden Markov Models (HMMs) where a site's future state only depends on its own past, this CHMM accounts for how colonization at one body site influences colonization at other body sites. This is achieved by making the transition probabilities of each site's colonization state dependent on the states of all other sites.

The authors developed a specific formulation they call the Additive-CHMM. This model allows for the estimation of interaction parameters (denoted by $\beta$) that quantify the influence of colonization at one site on another. The model also incorporates emission probabilities to account for the imperfect sensitivity and specificity of the diagnostic swabs used. They employed a Metropolis-within-Gibbs Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm for efficient Bayesian inference, providing credible intervals for all model parameters.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from the CLEAR (Changing Lives by Eradicating Antibiotic Resistance) Trial. This randomized controlled trial involved MRSA carriers and compared a decolonization protocol (nasal mupirocin and chlorhexidine body/mouth wash) against an education-only group. Swabs were collected from multiple body sites (nares, skin, throat, and wounds) at various time points after discharge. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather applies their novel modeling approach to this comprehensive existing dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nares as a Central Hub: The model confirms that the anterior nares are a critical "hub" for MRSA colonization, influencing other sites. This reinforces the importance of nasal treatments.
  • Synergistic Therapy Effects: The study demonstrates that while nasal mupirocin is the most impactful single therapy, all components of the decolonization protocol contribute significantly to overall clearance. This highlights the benefit of combination therapies.
  • Skin Clearance Potential: Perhaps the most striking insight is that enhancing MRSA clearance from the skin (axilla/groin) was predicted to yield the largest gains in overall decolonization success. This suggests a potential area for optimizing future protocols.
  • Reduced Self-Inoculation: The decolonization protocol was shown to reduce the transmission of MRSA between body sites, implying a reduction in self-inoculation.
  • Model-Driven Optimization: The CHMM allows for in silico testing of hypothetical therapy improvements, providing a powerful tool for evidence-based protocol design beyond traditional clinical trial limitations.

Key Results

  • The CHMM accurately predicted the observed decrease in MRSA carriage over the study period.
  • The decolonization protocol significantly decreased the persistence of MRSA colonization in the nares and throat, independent of other sites.
  • The protocol also reduced MRSA transmission between body sites.
  • In silico analysis indicated that improving MRSA clearance from the skin would lead to the most substantial gains in overall decolonization success.
  • Nasal mupirocin was identified as the most efficient single therapy, but all components contributed to the protocol's efficacy.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several simplifying assumptions:

  • Focus on Individual Clearance: The analysis primarily focused on individual clearance, not considering broader community transmission effects of the protocol.
  • Missing Data Assumption: The assumption that missing observations (due to trial exits, skipped visits, etc.) are independent of colonization status might not always hold true. For instance, a healed wound might lead to missing samples without ongoing colonization.
  • Optimal Therapy Assumptions: The optimal therapy analysis assumed all patients followed the same protocol and that swab sensitivity/specificity remained constant, which might not be entirely realistic.

Future work could explore:

  • Incorporating the cost and adherence aspects of different decolonization protocols.
  • Investigating potential side effects or impacts on the body's microbiota.
  • Extending the model to account for more complex interaction dynamics or a larger number of body sites.
  • Further validating the model's predictions with new clinical trials or real-world data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Methicillin-resistant <i>Staphylococcus aureus</i> (MRSA) can colonize multiple body sites, and carriage is a risk factor for infection. Successful decolonization protocols reduce disease incidence; however, multiple protocols exist, comprising diverse therapies targeting multiple body sites, and the optimal protocol is unclear. Standard methods cannot infer the impact of site-specific components on successful decolonization. Here, we formulate a Bayesian coupled hidden Markov model, which estimates interactions between body sites, quantifies the contribution of each therapy to successful decolonization, and enables predictions of the efficacy of therapy combinations. We applied the model to longitudinal data from a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of an MRSA decolonization protocol consisting of chlorhexidine body and mouthwash and nasal mupirocin. Our findings (i) confirmed nares as a central hub for MRSA colonization and nasal mupirocin as the most crucial therapy and (ii) demonstrated all components contributed significantly to the efficacy of the protocol and the protocol reduced self-inoculation. Finally, we assessed the impact of hypothetical therapy improvements <i>in silico</i> and found that enhancing MRSA clearance at the skin would yield the largest gains. This study demonstrates the use of advanced modelling to go beyond what is typically achieved by RCTs, enabling evidence-based decision-making to streamline clinical protocols.
BibTeX
@article{poyraz2022modelling,
  author = {Onur Poyraz and Mohamad Sater and Loren G. Miller and James A. McKinnell and Susan S. Huang and Yonatan H. Grad and Pekka Marttinen},
  title = {{Modelling methicillin-resistant <i>Staphylococcus aureus</i> decolonization: interactions between body sites and the impact of site-specific clearance}},
  journal = {Journal of The Royal Society Interface},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1098/rsif.2021.0916},
}
Figure