Modelling and Performance Analysis of an Autonomous Marine Vehicle Powered by a Fuel Cell Hybrid Powertrain

Giuseppe De Lorenzo, Francesco Piraino, Francesco Longo, Giovanni Tinè, V. Boscaino, Nicola Panzavecchia, Massimo Caccia, Petronilla FragiacomoEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a detailed dynamic model of a fuel cell-hybrid powertrain for an autonomous marine vehicle (AMV), aiming to improve range and reduce environmental impact. The model was used to simulate four different operational journeys, demonstrating the feasibility of hydrogen power for AMVs and highlighting critical performance aspects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autonomous Surface Vehicles (ASVs) are increasingly used for various marine tasks, but their operational range is often limited by battery energy density. This paper addresses the challenge of extending the endurance of these vehicles by investigating a hybrid powertrain that combines a proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cell system with a lithium-ion battery. The goal is to leverage the higher energy density of hydrogen storage to achieve longer mission durations while minimizing environmental impact.

Methods

The authors developed a comprehensive dynamic electrical model of the entire hybrid powertrain in a MATLAB-Simulink environment. This model integrates several key components:

  • Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) Fuel Cell System: This includes the fuel cell stack, its ancillaries, and a DC-DC converter.
  • Hydrogen Metal Hydride Storage System: This stores the hydrogen fuel.
  • Lithium-Ion Battery Subsystem: This acts as a buffer and provides peak power.
  • Brushless DC (BLDC) Electric Motors: Two motors are used for propulsion and directional control.
  • Control Subsystems: These manage the power sharing between the fuel cell and battery and control the motor operation.

The model was validated against experimental data for the PEM fuel cell stack and the Li-ion battery. Subsequently, the integrated powertrain model was used to simulate four distinct operational journeys, each with varying power and energy demands, to analyze performance, energy consumption, and the state of charge (SOC) of the hydrogen and battery systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors used manufacturer-provided technical data for the PEM fuel cell stack (H300 type C) and the Li-ion battery pack (IS36V13), as well as experimental data for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrogen as a viable energy source for AMVs: The simulations demonstrate that a fuel cell hybrid system can significantly extend the operational range of autonomous marine vehicles, offering a more environmentally friendly alternative to purely battery-powered systems.
  • Importance of a hybrid approach: The study highlights that a hybrid system, combining the fuel cell's energy density with the battery's ability to handle power peaks and provide buffer capacity, is crucial for efficient operation across diverse mission profiles.
  • Control strategy is critical: The performance and success of the AMV are highly dependent on the power-sharing control strategy. Journey 4, in particular, showed that without adjustments, the system could fail to complete its mission due to the limitations of the control strategy in handling rapid power fluctuations.
  • Trade-offs in mission design: Different journeys revealed varying energy consumption patterns and fuel cell/battery utilization. For instance, longer journeys might not necessarily consume the most energy if power demands are lower, while shorter, more dynamic journeys can be more demanding on the battery.

Key Results

  • The developed dynamic model was validated against experimental data, showing good agreement for both the PEM fuel cell and Li-ion battery components.
  • Journey 1: A 5-hour journey with moderate power fluctuations consumed 1100 Wh, with the fuel cell providing 965 Wh and the battery 157 Wh. Hydrogen consumption was 64 g, leaving the battery at 70% SOC.
  • Journey 2: The shortest journey (85 min) had the lowest energy demand (425 Wh). Hydrogen consumption was low (16 g), with the battery contributing 195 Wh and ending at 61% SOC.
  • Journey 3: The longest and most critical journey (6 h) consumed the most energy (1615 Wh). The system stopped prematurely at 340 min because the hydrogen SOC reached its limit (11%). The fuel cell supplied 1087 Wh (consuming 71 g of hydrogen), and the battery provided 375 Wh, ending at 25% SOC.
  • Journey 4: This journey (180 min) required 980 Wh with significant power variations. Without control system correction, the battery SOC reached its lower limit (20%), terminating the mission. With an adjusted control strategy, the journey was completed, with the fuel cell providing 632 Wh (consuming 43 g of hydrogen) and the battery 368 Wh, ending at 25% SOC.
  • Overall energy consumption for the fuel cell across the four journeys ranged from 235 Wh to 1087 Wh, and battery energy contribution ranged from 157 Wh to 375 Wh.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Control System Optimization: The paper highlights that the control strategy is a critical factor, especially for journeys with significant and contiguous power variations. Future work could focus on developing more advanced control systems to better manage power fluctuations and optimize the use of both energy sources, potentially increasing the vehicle's range.
  • Real-world Testing: While the model is validated against experimental data, the simulations represent a theoretical analysis. Future work could involve implementing and testing this hybrid powertrain on a physical AMV to validate the model's predictions in real-world conditions.
  • Component Sizing: The study used a fixed energy storage configuration. Further research could explore optimal sizing of the fuel cell, battery, and hydrogen storage for different mission profiles and vehicle types.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper describes the implementation of a hydrogen-based system for an autonomous surface vehicle in an effort to reduce environmental impact and increase driving range. In a suitable computational environment, the dynamic electrical model of the entire hybrid powertrain, consisting of a proton exchange membrane fuel cell, a hydrogen metal hydride storage system, a lithium battery, two brushless DC motors, and two control subsystems, is implemented. The developed calculation tool is used to perform the dynamic analysis of the hybrid propulsion system during four different operating journeys, investigating the performance achieved to examine the obtained performance, determine the feasibility of the work runs and highlight the critical points. During the trips, the engine shows fluctuating performance trends while the energy consumption reaches 1087 Wh for the fuel cell (corresponding to 71 g of hydrogen) and 370 Wh for the battery, consuming almost all the energy stored on board.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lorenzo2022modelling,
  author = {Giuseppe De Lorenzo and Francesco Piraino and Francesco Longo and Giovanni Tinè and V. Boscaino and Nicola Panzavecchia and Massimo Caccia and Petronilla Fragiacomo},
  title = {{Modelling and Performance Analysis of an Autonomous Marine Vehicle Powered by a Fuel Cell Hybrid Powertrain}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15196926},
}
Figure