Modelling and Design of MEMS Piezoresistive Out-of-Plane Shear and Normal Stress Sensors

Yi Zhang, Lin LiSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel MEMS sensor design for measuring out-of-plane shear and normal stresses, crucial for applications like robotics and biomedical devices. By strategically incorporating "surface trenches" near the sensing elements, the researchers significantly boosted sensor sensitivity, achieving up to a 6.72x improvement compared to a flat sensor design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Measuring stresses and strains is vital across many fields, from structural health monitoring to biomechanics. While traditional sensors excel at in-plane stress measurements, there's a significant need for sensors capable of detecting out-of-plane shear and normal stresses. These are particularly important for applications like humanoid robots (for balance and interaction), advanced prosthetics (for socket pressure monitoring), and microfluidic pumps. Existing MEMS sensors for these stresses often suffer from limited sensitivity, especially when dealing with high stress loads (up to 1 GPa), hindering their use in demanding applications. This paper aims to address this sensitivity limitation.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the strategic use of stress concentration regions (SCRs), implemented as surface trenches, etched into the silicon chip near the piezoresistive sensing elements.

  1. Finite Element Modeling (FEM): A coupled piezoresistive-mechanical FEM was developed using ANSYS Multiphysics. This model simulated a five-layer structure (PCB, ACA, silicon chip, bonding layer, stress transmission layer) to analyze stress distribution and sensor response.
  2. Analytical Model: A five-layer analytical model was also developed and used to verify the FEM results, particularly for out-of-plane shear stress distribution.
  3. Geometric Optimization: The FEM was extensively used to optimize the location, length, width, and depth of the surface trenches. This involved systematically varying these parameters and measuring the resulting percentage signal change compared to a flat sensor.
  4. Microfabrication and Packaging: A detailed microfabrication process flow was outlined, and a flip-chip packaging scheme using anisotropic conductive adhesive (ACA) was employed to assemble the sensor.
  5. Experimental Validation: The prototyped sensor was tested and its signal output was compared against the FEM simulations and a load cell from a universal testing machine.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations and experimental measurements from the fabricated sensor.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface Trenches as Sensitivity Boosters: The introduction of surface trenches dramatically enhances sensor sensitivity by concentrating stress in their vicinity, directly impacting the piezoresistors. This is the paper's central finding.
  • Optimizing Trench Geometry is Crucial: The effectiveness of the trenches is highly dependent on their dimensions and placement. The study systematically identified optimal parameters for distance, length, and depth to maximize signal output.
  • FEM as a Design Tool: The FEM proved to be a powerful tool for guiding the complex geometric optimization of the trenches, saving significant experimental effort.
  • Analytical Model Validation: The agreement between the analytical and FEM models for stress distribution provides confidence in the simulation's accuracy.
  • Out-of-Plane Stress is Challenging: The paper highlights the inherent difficulty in measuring out-of-plane stresses and the limitations of existing technologies, underscoring the importance of this research.

Key Results

  • Significant Sensitivity Improvement: The sensor with surface trenches showed a substantial increase in signal output compared to a flat sensor. Specifically, the sum of signal output was 4.52, 5.06, and 5.72 times higher for the center sensing area, edge sensing area 1, and edge sensing area 2, respectively. (Note: The abstract mentions 4.52, 5.06, and 5.72, while the conclusion mentions 5.52, 6.06, and 6.72. The latter values are likely the final, optimized results, but the former are also stated).
  • Optimal Trench Placement: For edge sensing areas, the trenches should be placed as close as possible to the sensing elements (minimum distance of 85 µm due to fabrication limits).
  • Optimal Trench Dimensions: For edge sensing areas, the optimal length was found to be 350 µm and depth 100 µm. For the center sensing area, optimal lengths were 380 µm and 400 µm, and depths were 175 µm and 125 µm for the two trenches.
  • Good Agreement: Experimental results showed excellent agreement with FEM simulations for voltage output and with a load cell for measured stresses, validating the sensor's performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Microfabrication Resolution: The minimum achievable distance between trenches and sensing elements was limited by microfabrication resolution (15 µm), which influenced the optimization.
  • Temperature Effects: While the piezoresistive theory section mentions temperature effects, the experimental validation and optimization focus primarily on stress response. Further investigation into temperature compensation might be needed for some applications.
  • Future Work: The authors state that detailed testing and calibration of the proposed sensor will be presented in a future paper, suggesting ongoing development and refinement. They also mention the potential for this sensor in high load applications, implying future work could explore its performance under even greater stresses.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the design of MEMS piezoresistive out-of-plane shear and normal stress sensor is described. To improve the sensor sensitivity, a methodology by the incorporation of stress concentration regions, namely surface trenches in the proximity of sensing elements was explored in detail. The finite element (FE) model, verified by a five-layer analytical model was developed as a tool to model the performance of the sensor and guide the geometric optimization of the surface trenches. Optimum location and dimensions of the surface trenches have been obtained through a comprehensive FE analysis. The microfabrication and packing scheme was introduced to prototype the sensor with optimum geometric characteristics of surface trenches. Signal output from the prototyped sensor was tested and compared with those from FE simulation. Good agreement has been achieved between the simulation and experimental results. Moreover, the results suggest the incorporation of surface trenches can help improve the sensor sensitivity. More specifically, the sum of signal output from the sensor chip with surface trenches are 4.52, 5.06 and 5.72 times higher compared to flat sensor chip for center sensing area, edge sensing areas 1 and 2, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018modelling,
  author = {Yi Zhang and Lin Li},
  title = {{Modelling and Design of MEMS Piezoresistive Out-of-Plane Shear and Normal Stress Sensors}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18113737},
}
Figure