Modélisation mathématique de l'hématopoïèse et des hémopathies : développement, dynamique et traitement

Gurvan Hermange, Paul-Henry Cournède, Isabelle PloHématologie 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This review explores the crucial role of mathematical modeling in understanding hematopoiesis, both normal and pathological. By bridging the gap between complex biological data and mathematical formalisms, these models offer powerful tools for predicting disease progression, identifying therapeutic targets, and optimizing patient treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hematopoiesis, the process of blood cell formation, is incredibly complex. Understanding its normal function and how it goes awry in diseases like blood cancers (hemopathies) is a significant challenge. Traditional biological approaches often struggle to capture the intricate dynamics of cell populations, cancer development, and treatment responses. This paper addresses the need for a multidisciplinary approach, specifically highlighting how mathematical modeling can provide a quantitative framework to unravel these complexities, leading to better clinical decision-making and personalized medicine.

Methods

The paper provides a comprehensive overview of mathematical modeling techniques applied to hematopoiesis. It discusses:

  • Deterministic and Stochastic Models: Explaining the use of differential equations (ordinary and partial) and delay differential equations to describe cell population dynamics. Stochastic models, like Markov processes and branching processes, are introduced to capture the inherent randomness at the cellular level.
  • Agent-Based Models: Highlighting their utility for simulating complex interactions and behaviors of individual cells.
  • Mathematical Inference: Detailing the crucial steps of model calibration (estimating parameters from experimental data) and validation. This includes discussing techniques for ensuring model robustness and quantifying uncertainties.
  • Bayesian and Frequentist Approaches: Contrasting these statistical frameworks for parameter estimation and model selection.
  • Model Selection and Validation: Describing criteria like AIC and BIC for choosing the best model and methods for predicting future observations.

Datasets

Not explicitly detailed as specific datasets for training or evaluation in this review. The paper discusses the types of data used, such as:

  • Experimental observations (general)
  • Single-cell RNA-seq data
  • Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS) data
  • Variant Allele Frequency (VAF) data from patient cohorts
  • Longitudinal patient data (e.g., for treatment response)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Disciplines is Essential: The success of modeling hematopoiesis hinges on close collaboration between mathematicians and biologists, requiring mutual understanding of biological phenomena and mathematical formalisms.
  • Models as "In Silico" Labs: Mathematical models act as powerful virtual laboratories, allowing researchers to test hypotheses, explore scenarios that are difficult or impossible to study experimentally, and identify key biological mechanisms.
  • From Prediction to Optimization: Beyond simply describing dynamics, models are increasingly used to predict treatment outcomes and optimize therapeutic strategies, paving the way for personalized medicine.
  • The Importance of Data Quality and Preprocessing: Raw experimental data often requires significant preprocessing (e.g., handling noise, accounting for uncertainties, structuring data) before it can be effectively used for model calibration.
  • Model Identifiability and Sensitivity are Crucial: Ensuring that model parameters can be uniquely estimated from data (identifiability) and understanding which parameters most influence model outputs (sensitivity analysis) are critical for drawing reliable conclusions.

Key Results

This review doesn't present new experimental results but rather synthesizes the findings from numerous modeling studies. Key applications highlighted include:

  • Inferring Latent Processes: Models can reveal the dynamics of stem cells (CSH) and the early stages of malignant hematopoiesis, which are often not directly observable.
  • Testing Biological Hypotheses: Mathematical models have been used to test various hypotheses about the origins and progression of blood cancers, leading to the identification of potential therapeutic targets.
  • Predicting Treatment Efficacy: Models have been developed to predict the response of patients to treatments like imatinib and interferon-alpha, aiding in treatment selection and optimization. For example, some models suggest imatinib might not eradicate leukemia stem cells, while others indicate potential long-term remission with certain treatment combinations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Assumptions: The authors acknowledge that all models are based on assumptions, and the validity of their results is contingent on these assumptions. Different assumptions can lead to differing interpretations, as seen in studies on chronic myeloid leukemia treatment.
  • Data Limitations: While data availability is increasing, challenges remain in obtaining comprehensive, high-quality longitudinal data, especially for human patients before treatment.
  • Complexity of Biological Systems: Hematopoiesis and its diseases are inherently complex, and current models, while powerful, are simplifications of reality.
  • Future Directions: The paper points towards the increasing promise of statistical learning methods (machine learning, artificial intelligence) for handling large, high-dimensional datasets like single-cell RNA-seq, further advancing our understanding of hematopoiesis. The ongoing development of more sophisticated models and the integration of diverse data types will continue to drive progress in personalized medicine for blood disorders.

Summary updated

Abstract

L’étude de l’hématopoïèse normale et pathologique, de par la complexité de ce sujet, requiert une approche multidisciplinaire. L’utilisation de modèles mathématiques, lorsqu’il s’agit de comprendre la dynamique de populations de cellules, le développement de cancers ou l’effet d’un traitement, est particulièrement appropriée. Les modèles mathématiques, calibrés à partir d’observations expérimentales, peuvent être des outils d’aide à la décision en clinique, permettant par exemple de prédire l’effet d’un traitement ou d’en optimiser le dosage. Cette revue présente tout d’abord différents modèles et formalismes mathématiques qui ont été développés au cours des décennies pour modéliser l’hématopoïèse, et dont certains sont à la base des travaux les plus récents. Nous aborderons ensuite les enjeux méthodologiques liés à l’inférence mathématique, permettant de s’assurer de la validité et de la robustesse des résultats. Enfin, nous montrons l’utilisation de modèles mathématiques dans trois champs d’application : l’initiation et le développement des hémopathies malignes, la dérégulation de leur hématopoïèse et leurs traitements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hermange2022modelisation,
  author = {Gurvan Hermange and Paul-Henry Cournède and Isabelle Plo},
  title = {{Modélisation mathématique de l'hématopoïèse et des hémopathies : développement, dynamique et traitement}},
  booktitle = {Hématologie},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1684/hma.2022.1762},
}
Figure