Modeling uniquely human gene regulatory function in humanized mice

Emily V. Dutrow, Deena Emera, Kristina Yim, Severin Uebbing, Acadia A. Kocher, Martina Krenzer, Timothy Nottoli, Daniel B. Burkhardt, Smita Krishnaswamy, Angeliki Louvi, James P. NoonanbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses humanized mice to investigate the function of a Human Accelerated Region (HAR), HACNS1, a key candidate for driving human-specific developmental changes. They found that HACNS1 retains its human-specific enhancer activity in mice and significantly alters the expression of the gene Gbx2 in developing limb cells, providing mechanistic insight into how HARs contribute to human evolution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The evolution of unique human traits, such as our complex cognitive abilities and physical characteristics, is thought to be driven by changes in gene regulation during development. Human Accelerated Regions (HARs) are genomic regions that show rapid evolution in the human lineage and are enriched for human-specific sequence changes, making them prime candidates for novel regulatory functions. However, understanding how these HARs actually function in vivo and impact gene expression, particularly during development, has been challenging. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the role of a specific HAR, HACNS1, in a humanized mouse model to understand its regulatory function and its impact on gene expression during limb development.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Humanized Mouse Model Generation: They created mouse lines where the endogenous mouse sequence of a specific genomic region was replaced with either the human HACNS1 sequence or the chimpanzee orthologous sequence using homologous recombination. This allowed them to study the human-specific regulatory elements in the context of a living organism.
  • Epigenetic Profiling (ChIP-seq): They used chromatin immunoprecipitation followed by sequencing (ChIP-seq) to examine epigenetic marks (H3K27ac and H3K4me2), which are associated with active enhancers, at the HACNS1 locus in developing mouse limbs and pharyngeal arches. This helped determine if the humanized HACNS1 retained its enhancer activity in the mouse genome.
  • Gene Expression Analysis (In Situ Hybridization and qRT-PCR): They used whole-mount in situ hybridization (ISH) and quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) to visualize and quantify the expression of the nearby gene Gbx2 in embryos from the different mouse lines. This helped assess the impact of HACNS1 on gene regulation.
  • Single-Cell RNA-Sequencing (scRNA-seq): To identify the specific cell types affected by HACNS1 and Gbx2 expression changes, they performed scRNA-seq on hindlimb cells. This allowed for a detailed analysis of gene expression at the single-cell level, revealing cell-type-specific responses.
  • Computational Analyses: They utilized various computational tools for data processing, normalization, integration, and analysis, including Seurat for scRNA-seq data, HOMER for peak calling and differential analysis, and kNN-DREMI for gene association analysis.

Datasets

The study utilized datasets generated from the humanized mouse models created for this research. Specifically, they generated:

  • ChIP-seq data for H3K27ac and H3K4me2.
  • qRT-PCR data for Gbx2 expression.
  • scRNA-seq data from hindlimb buds of E11.5 embryos.

No external datasets were explicitly mentioned for training or evaluation, as the study focused on generating and analyzing novel data from their experimental models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HARs are functionally conserved in a heterologous context: The finding that the human HACNS1 sequence retains its human-specific enhancer activity when placed in the mouse genome is crucial. It suggests that the regulatory mechanisms governing HAR function are robust and can be recapitulated in a different species, allowing for experimental interrogation.
  • A single HAR can significantly impact gene expression: The demonstration that HACNS1 drives robust changes in Gbx2 expression, particularly in chondrogenic mesenchymal cells of the developing limb, highlights the potent regulatory capacity of individual HARs. This challenges the notion that evolutionary changes in gene regulation are solely driven by widespread, subtle alterations.
  • Humanized models are powerful for studying evolutionary regulatory changes: The success of this study underscores the utility of humanized mouse models for dissecting the functional consequences of human-specific genetic changes. These models provide a living system to observe the complex interplay of regulatory elements and gene expression during development.
  • Gbx2 is a key downstream target of HACNS1 in limb development: The identification of Gbx2 as a regulated gene by HACNS1, especially in the context of chondrogenesis, points to a specific developmental pathway that may have been modified during human evolution. This opens avenues for understanding how changes in this pathway contribute to human limb morphology.

Key Results

  • HACNS1 exhibits human-specific enhancer activity in humanized mice: ChIP-seq data showed significantly higher H3K27ac enrichment at the human HACNS1 locus compared to its chimpanzee ortholog and the endogenous mouse locus in developing limb buds.
  • HACNS1 upregulates Gbx2 expression in limb development: Both ISH and qRT-PCR revealed substantially increased Gbx2 expression in the forelimbs and hindlimbs of HACNS1 humanized embryos compared to chimpanzee ortholog and wild-type embryos. This upregulation was observed across multiple developmental time points.
  • Gbx2 upregulation occurs in chondrogenic mesenchymal cells: Single-cell RNA-sequencing identified that Gbx2 is primarily expressed in mesenchymal cell clusters within the developing limb bud, and this expression is significantly higher in the humanized HACNS1 line. These cells are destined for chondrogenesis, suggesting HACNS1 influences skeletal patterning.
  • No gross morphological differences were detected: Despite the observed changes in gene expression, morphometric analysis of E18.5 skeletons did not reveal significant differences in limb length or proportions between the genotypes. This suggests that the observed molecular changes may contribute to more subtle or complex phenotypic outcomes not captured by gross skeletal morphology.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study did not detect overt morphological differences in the limb skeletons of the humanized mice, suggesting that the observed gene expression changes might contribute to more subtle phenotypes or require analysis of adult mice or soft tissues.
  • The analysis of pharyngeal arch tissue was limited due to a lack of comparative epigenetic profiling data and the absence of a significant gain in H3K27ac marking in that region.
  • The modest differences observed in the chimpanzee ortholog line compared to wild type might be due to primate-rodent specific sequence changes that predate human-specific changes.
  • Future Work:
    • Deciphering the regulatory network of Gbx2 in both humanized and wild-type limbs, including identifying downstream targets of Gbx2 and upstream regulators of HACNS1.
  • Investigating the role of transcription factors whose predicted binding sites are unique to HACNS1.
  • Conducting in vivo genetic studies of HACNS1 orthologs from multiple primate and rodent species, and ancestral orthologs, to distinguish between primate-specific and rodent-specific changes.
  • Studying additional HARs contributing to human-specific phenotypes, potentially through intercrossing mouse lines or iterative editing.
  • Exploring subtle changes in adult mice or soft tissues, and further characterizing other tissues with known Gbx2 developmental functions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The evolution of uniquely human traits likely entailed changes in developmental gene regulation. Human Accelerated Regions (HARs), which include transcriptional enhancers harboring a significant excess of human-specific sequence changes, are leading candidates for driving gene regulatory modifications in human development. However, insight into whether HARs alter the level, distribution and timing of endogenous gene expression remains limited. We examined the role of the HAR HACNS1 (HAR2) in human evolution by interrogating its molecular functions in a humanized mouse model. We find that HACNS1 maintains its human-specific enhancer activity in humanized mice and that it modifies expression of Gbx2 , which encodes a homeobox transcription factor, during limb development. Using single-cell RNA-sequencing, we demonstrate that Gbx2 is upregulated in the chondrogenic mesenchyme of humanized limbs, supporting that HACNS1 alters gene expression in cell types involved in skeletal patterning. Our findings illustrate that humanized mouse models provide mechanistic insight into how HARs modified gene expression in human evolution.
BibTeX
@misc{dutrow2019modeling,
  author = {Emily V. Dutrow and Deena Emera and Kristina Yim and Severin Uebbing and Acadia A. Kocher and Martina Krenzer and Timothy Nottoli and Daniel B. Burkhardt and Smita Krishnaswamy and Angeliki Louvi and James P. Noonan},
  title = {{Modeling uniquely human gene regulatory function in humanized mice}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/2019.12.11.873075},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure