Modeling the evolution of aerosol particles in a ship plume using PartMC-MOSAIC

J. Tian, Nicole Riemer, Matthew West, L. Pfaffenberger, Hans Schlager, Andreas PetzoldAtmospheric 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a sophisticated particle-resolved model (PartMC-MOSAIC) to simulate how ship exhaust particles evolve over time, focusing on the crucial roles of dilution and coagulation. The study validates the model against real-world measurements and reveals that coagulation significantly impacts particle mixing and their ability to form cloud condensation nuclei (CCN), especially at higher supersaturations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ocean-going ships are a major source of atmospheric aerosols, which influence climate and air quality. Understanding how these emitted particles change after leaving the ship's stack is critical for accurate climate modeling. Freshly emitted particles are a complex mixture, and their properties (like size, composition, and ability to form clouds) evolve rapidly due to processes like dilution with ambient air, chemical reactions forming new particles (nucleation), and particles sticking together (coagulation). Previous studies often simplified these processes, leading to uncertainties in predicting the climate impact of ship emissions. This paper aims to provide a more detailed, process-level understanding of this evolution, specifically quantifying the roles of dilution, coagulation, and condensation on particle properties and their CCN activity.

Methods

The core of this research is the PartMC-MOSAIC model, a particle-resolved aerosol model. This means it tracks the composition and properties of individual particles, rather than treating them as bulk averages. This is crucial for understanding how mixing states evolve. The model simulates:

  • Emission: Initial particle and gas phase properties from ship exhaust.
  • Dilution: How the plume spreads and mixes with background air, modeled using power-law relationships for plume width and height.
  • Coagulation: The process where particles collide and merge, modeled using a stochastic Monte Carlo approach.
  • Condensation: The growth of particles by gas-to-particle conversion (e.g., sulfuric acid forming sulfate particles).
  • Gas-phase Chemistry: Chemical reactions occurring in the gas phase, coupled with aerosol processes.
  • Nucleation: The formation of new, very small particles, parameterized based on sulfuric acid concentration.

The model's ability to resolve individual particles allows for detailed analysis of particle mixing states (e.g., the proportion of black carbon or sulfate within a particle) and their subsequent impact on cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activity, which is determined by a particle's size and hygroscopicity (its tendency to absorb water).

Datasets

The study uses observational data from two main sources:

  • HERCULES campaign (2006): Provided initial input parameters for gas and particle properties from ship engine exhaust, obtained from a test-rig study.
  • QUANTIFY study (2007): Provided airborne measurements of ship plumes in the English Channel and Gulf of Biscay. This includes total number concentrations, size distributions, and meteorological data, used for model validation and comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dilution is King (Initially): Within the first hour, dilution dramatically reduces the concentration of emitted particles (by four orders of magnitude).
  • Coagulation is Crucial for Small Particles: While dilution is dominant early on, coagulation significantly reduces the number of small, volatile particles and alters the overall particle size distribution. Neglecting coagulation leads to a substantial overprediction of particle numbers.
  • Mixing State Matters: Coagulation drives the formation of internally mixed particles (e.g., sulfate and black carbon combined within a single particle), moving away from the initially externally mixed state. This internal mixing is key to changing particle properties.
  • CCN Activity is Sensitive to Processes: The ability of particles to act as CCN is not solely determined by initial emissions. Coagulation and condensation significantly alter this potential, with the impact depending on the supersaturation level at which CCN activity is evaluated.
  • Nucleation's Role is Context-Dependent: For the base case with limited secondary aerosol formation, nucleation had a minor impact on CCN. However, in a sensitivity case with higher secondary aerosol production, nucleation could significantly increase CCN concentrations at higher supersaturations.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The PartMC-MOSAIC model successfully reproduced observed total number concentrations in a ship plume, especially when coagulation was included.
  • Dilution and Coagulation Dominance: For the base case, dilution reduced particle concentration by four orders of magnitude in the first hour, and coagulation reduced it by an additional order of magnitude.
  • Coagulation's Impact on Size Distribution: Neglecting coagulation led to overpredictions of particle number concentration by more than an order of magnitude for particles < 40 nm at 100s plume age. Including coagulation improved agreement with observed size distributions.
  • CCN Impact:
    • For low supersaturations (< 0.2%), coagulation and condensation had negligible impact on CCN concentrations.
  • For intermediate supersaturations (0.2-0.7%), neglecting coagulation led to underestimations of CCN (e.g., 37% for S=0.3%).
  • For high supersaturations (> 0.7%), neglecting coagulation led to overestimations of CCN (e.g., 75% for S=1%).
  • Neglecting condensation but including coagulation led to underestimations of CCN for larger supersaturations (e.g., 18% for S=0.6%).
  • Sensitivity to Simulation Start Time: A sensitivity case starting earlier in the day (06:00 LT) with more sunlight exposure showed increased secondary aerosol formation, leading to more significant impacts of condensation on CCN.
  • Nucleation Impact: In the base case, nucleation had a limited effect on CCN. In a sensitivity case with enhanced secondary aerosol formation, nucleation increased CCN concentrations by an order of magnitude at supersaturations above 0.3%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The model assumes a well-mixed Lagrangian parcel, meaning it doesn't resolve spatial gradients within the plume.
  • Nucleation Parameterization: The study uses a specific parameterization for nucleation, and the authors acknowledge that the range of currently proposed models for nucleation and growth is vast.
  • Vanadium-Catalyzed Sulfate Production: The model did not include vanadium-catalyzed sulfate production, which might lead to an underestimation of sulfate concentrations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the impact of other secondary aerosol species and further investigating the role of nucleation under different atmospheric conditions. The sensitivity analysis on dilution parameters (α and β) was conducted but not exhaustively explored, indicating room for further refinement.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the evolution of ship-emitted aerosol particles using the stochastic particle-resolved model PartMC-MOSAIC (Particle Monte Carlo model-Model for Simulating Aerosol Interactions and Chemistry). Comparisons of our results with observations from the QUANTIFY (Quantifying the Climate Impact of Global and European Transport Systems) study in 2007 in the English Channel and the Gulf of Biscay showed that the model was able to reproduce the observed evolution of total number concentration and the vanishing of the nucleation mode consisting of sulfate particles. Further process analysis revealed that during the first hour after emission, dilution reduced the total number concentration by four orders of magnitude, while coagulation reduced it by an additional order of magnitude. Neglecting coagulation resulted in an overprediction of more than one order of magnitude in the number concentration of particles smaller than 40 nm at a plume age of 100 s. Coagulation also significantly altered the mixing state of the particles, leading to a continuum of internal mixtures of sulfate and black carbon. The impact on cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) concentrations depended on the supersaturation threshold S at which CCN activity was evaluated. For the base case conditions, characterized by a low formation rate of secondary aerosol species, neglecting coagulation, but simulating condensation, led to an underestimation of CCN concentrations of about 37% for S = 0.3% at the end of the 14-h simulation. In contrast, for supersaturations higher than 0.7%, neglecting coagulation resulted in an overestimation of CCN concentration, about 75% for S = 1%. For S lower than 0.2% the differences between simulations including coagulation and neglecting coagulation were negligible. Neglecting condensation, but simulating coagulation did not impact the CCN concentrations below 0.2% and resulted in an underestimation of CCN concentrations for larger supersaturations, e.g., 18% for S = 0.6%. We also explored the role of nucleation for the CCN concentrations in the ship plume. For the base case the impact of nucleation on CCN concentrations was limited, but for a sensitivity case with higher formation rates of secondary aerosol over several hours, the CCN concentrations increased by an order of magnitude for supersaturation thresholds above 0.3%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tian2014modeling,
  author = {J. Tian and Nicole Riemer and Matthew West and L. Pfaffenberger and Hans Schlager and Andreas Petzold},
  title = {{Modeling the evolution of aerosol particles in a ship plume using PartMC-MOSAIC}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-14-5327-2014},
}
Figure