Modeling the Effect of Green Roofs for Building Energy Savings and Air Pollution Reduction in Shanghai

Yuanfan Zheng, Liang ChenSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study models the impact of green roofs on building energy savings and subsequent reductions in greenhouse gas (GHG) and air pollutant emissions in Shanghai, China, under current and projected future climate conditions. It finds that green roofs significantly reduce energy consumption, particularly for HVAC systems, and offers a novel GIS-based approach to identify suitable buildings for green roof installation, aiding urban sustainability efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Building energy consumption is a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution. While green roofs are known to directly absorb CO2 and remove air pollutants, their indirect benefits through building energy savings, especially in the context of climate change and for various building types, are not fully understood. Furthermore, there's a need for spatially explicit tools to guide the implementation of green roofs in dense urban environments like Shanghai, which faces challenges from both high temperatures and humidity. This research aims to bridge this gap by quantifying the energy savings and associated emission reductions from green roofs across different building types and climate scenarios, and by developing a practical GIS-based tool for urban planning.

Methods

The core of this research involves building energy simulation using EnergyPlus software (version 9.5.0). The authors created five building prototypes (office, hotel, shopping mall, hospital, and apartment) representative of Shanghai's climate zone. They then simulated hourly energy consumption for these prototypes under two climate conditions: current (2020) and projected future (2050), comparing scenarios with and without green roofs.

A key methodological innovation is the integration of a GIS-based approach to assess the potential for green roof installation on existing buildings in Shanghai's Huangpu District. This approach combines building footprint data, land use information, population density grids, and proximity to industrial areas to identify buildings with high potential for energy savings and air pollution reduction. Emission factors from the IPCC were used to quantify GHG and air pollutant reductions based on simulated energy savings.

Datasets

  • Chinese Standard Weather Data (CSWD) for Shanghai: Used to simulate hourly energy consumption, representing typical meteorological year (TMY3) data.
  • Building Prototypes: Five types (office, hotel, shopping mall, hospital, apartment) were modeled based on Chinese design standards for public and residential buildings.
  • Building Footprint GIS Data (Huangpu District): Obtained from Gaode Map, providing location, outline, height, and floor number.
  • Essential Urban Land Use Categories (EULUC) China data: Used to identify building types.
  • Population Data for Shanghai (2021): Raster data at 1 km resolution.
  • Emission Factors: Data from existing literature (e.g., Liang et al., Yang and Hong, Wu et al.) for CO2, PM2.5, SO2, and NOx from electricity consumption.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing datasets were integrated for a comprehensive analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Indirect Emission Reduction is Crucial: The study highlights that the most significant impact of green roofs on GHG and air pollution comes not just from direct absorption but from the indirect reduction in emissions due to lower energy demand, particularly for HVAC.
  • HVAC Dominance: The majority of energy savings from green roofs are attributed to reductions in Heating, Ventilation, and Cooling (HVAC) systems, underscoring their role in mitigating thermal loads.
  • Future Climate Amplifies Benefits: For most building types, green roofs offer greater energy savings under the projected warmer climate of 2050 compared to 2020, emphasizing their importance for climate change adaptation.
  • Building Type Matters: The effectiveness of green roofs varies significantly by building type, with commercial spaces like shopping malls showing the most substantial energy savings due to longer operating hours and higher internal loads.
  • GIS for Targeted Implementation: The development of a GIS-based suitability assessment tool is a major innovation, enabling policymakers to prioritize green roof installations in areas with the greatest potential for environmental and energy benefits.

Key Results

  • Annual Energy Savings: All building types showed positive annual energy savings with green roofs. The shopping mall demonstrated the largest savings, with a relative change (RC) of 21.6% in 2020 and 22.2% in 2050. Apartments also showed significant savings (8.5% in 2020, 8.6% in 2050).
  • Monthly Variations: Energy savings exhibited strong seasonality, with shopping malls and apartments benefiting more in summer (cooling energy savings) and offices/hotels/hospitals showing higher savings in winter (heating energy savings).
  • Diurnal Impact: On extremely hot summer days, green roofs significantly reduced peak cooling energy demand. For a shopping mall, daily cooling energy demand was reduced by approximately 40.1%, and for an apartment building, by 10.3%.
  • GHG and Air Pollutant Reduction: In Huangpu District, installing green roofs on all four public building types (office, hotel, shopping mall, hospital) could lead to annual reductions of approximately 47.68–64.34 Kt of CO2, 26.61 t of PM2.5, 82.06 t of SO2, and 130.97 t of NOx. Shopping malls contributed the most to these reductions.
  • Suitability Classification: The GIS approach classified buildings into high, moderate, and low suitability for green roof installation based on population density, proximity to industrial areas, and potential emission reduction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Green Roof Module Limitations: The study acknowledges limitations in the EnergyPlus green roof module, which does not allow for detailed parameter settings like plant species, coverage rate, or specific irrigation strategies.
  • Heating Energy Source: The analysis focused on electricity for cooling and heating. While electricity is a major source for heating in Shanghai, other energy sources for heating were not explicitly modeled.
  • Building Model Granularity: The model did not provide detailed output on energy consumption for individual zones within buildings, making it difficult to assess the impact of floor number on energy savings.
  • Data Availability: Future work could benefit from more detailed datasets, such as high-resolution orthophotos and LiDAR data for assessing roof space and solar potential, and finer-scale energy supply data to evaluate GHG and air pollution reduction more accurately.
  • Direct vs. Indirect Benefits: While this study focused on indirect benefits (energy savings), future research could further integrate direct benefits (pollutant absorption) with the GIS framework.
  • Integration with Solar: The authors suggest exploring the combined benefits of green roofs and solar panels, which could be synergistic.

Summary updated

Abstract

Building energy consumption is an essential source of greenhouse gas (GHG) and air pollution. Green roofs can directly absorb ambient CO2 and remove air pollutants through their vegetation layers, but a limited number of studies have examined their effects on GHG and air pollutant reduction associated with building energy savings, especially in the context of climate change. This research examined the performance of green roofs on CO2 and air pollutant reduction, including SO2, PM2.5, and NOx, through building energy demand savings in Shanghai, China. Climate change mitigation effects were assessed based on the energy consumption of five types of buildings before and after the installation of green roofs under 2020 and 2050 climate conditions, respectively. EnergyPlus software 9.5.0 was applied to simulate hourly energy consumption for different building prototypes with and without green roofs. Green roofs on all building types exhibited positive energy savings on annual, monthly, and diurnal scales, and they can save more energy for most of the building types under the projected 2050 climate condition. Moreover, most of the building energy saved by green roofs came from the Heating, Ventilation, and Cooling (HVAC) systems. In addition, this study discovered that the energy-saving benefits of green roofs vary based on the type of building they were installed on. Green roofs were found to have the largest energy saving on the shopping mall, especially on extremely hot summer days. Finally, a Geographic Information System (GIS)-based approach was developed with the ability to quantify the amount of GHG and air pollutant reduction associated with building energy savings for existing buildings in the Huangpu District of Shanghai. This approach was also utilized to present the spatial distribution of buildings with different levels of suitability to install green roofs by considering their location attributes and air pollutant reduction potential together, which is the major innovation of this research. The purpose of this study is to provide valuable guidance to policy makers regarding the performance of green roofs in building energy-saving and air quality improvement in the urban environment when facing the challenge of climate change, which is essential for urban sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2023modeling,
  author = {Yuanfan Zheng and Liang Chen},
  title = {{Modeling the Effect of Green Roofs for Building Energy Savings and Air Pollution Reduction in Shanghai}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su16010286},
}
Figure