Modeling Pore Size Distribution in Cellulose Rolled Stationary Phases

Craig Keim, Chenghong Li, Christine M. Ladisch, Michael R. LadischBiotechnology 2002 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a simple logistic model to characterize the pore size distribution of cellulose-based rolled stationary phases used in chromatography. This model effectively quantifies how enzyme treatment alters the pore structure, offering a valuable tool for understanding and optimizing these novel separation materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional chromatography often relies on packed beds of small particles, which can lead to high pressure drops and flow limitations. The authors are exploring an alternative: continuous rolled stationary phases made from fabrics. While these fabric-based columns offer advantages like low pressure drop, their separation performance is less understood, particularly how their internal pore structure influences the separation of molecules. The key challenge is to accurately measure and model the pore size distribution within these non-particulate, interlaced fabric structures, which are not typical for standard size exclusion chromatography. This understanding is crucial for predicting and controlling how different sized molecules will be separated.

Methods

The researchers employed a size exclusion chromatography (SEC) approach using various molecular probes to characterize the pore sizes within the cellulose fabric columns. These probes included small molecules like D₂O, NaCl, and glucose, as well as larger ones like polyethylene glycol (PEG) and dextran of varying molecular weights.

The core of their methodology lies in developing a mathematical model to describe the pore size distribution. They evaluated several models and found a simple logistic function to be the most effective. This model relates the elution volume of a probe to its size and the pore diameter of the stationary phase. Specifically, they used a four-parameter logistic model initially, but settled on a simplified three-parameter logistic model (Equation 4 in the paper) for its better fit and fewer parameters that require complex initial guesses.

To assess the impact of fabric modification, they treated the cotton fabric with cellulase enzymes. They then repeated the SEC measurements and modeling to quantify the changes in pore size distribution due to this enzymatic treatment.

Datasets

The study utilized a range of molecular probes for characterization:

  • Small molecules: D₂O, NaCl, glucose.
  • Polyethylene Glycols (PEGs): Molecular weights ranging from 400 to 20,000 Da.
  • Dextrans: Molecular weights of 66,300, 506,000, and 2,000,000 Da.

The data generated from injecting these probes into the rolled stationary phase columns (both untreated and enzyme-treated cotton print cloth) served as the primary dataset for model fitting and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fabric as Chromatography Media: The paper demonstrates that interlaced fabric structures, often overlooked for SEC, can effectively function as stationary phases for size-based separations.
  • Logistic Model Efficacy: A simple logistic function is surprisingly effective at modeling the pore size distribution of these non-particulate, continuous fabric columns, outperforming more complex models. This simplifies analysis and comparison.
  • Enzyme Treatment Uniformly Shrinks Pores: Cellulase enzyme treatment leads to a uniform decrease in water-accessible pore volume across the fabric. This suggests a consistent modification of the fabric's internal structure rather than selective pore enlargement or reduction.
  • NaCl Exclusion Mechanism: The study notes that NaCl elution from these columns might involve ion exclusion or attraction, not solely size exclusion, which is an important consideration for derivatized columns.

Key Results

  • The simple logistic model (Equation 4) fits the experimental data for pore size distribution in cotton print cloth columns with an error of less than 3%.
  • Enzyme treatment with cellulase (at 4.1 GCU/g) reduced the water-accessible pore volume by approximately 20% compared to untreated cotton print cloth.
  • The model successfully captured the decrease in pore volume and the shift in retention volumes to smaller values observed after enzyme treatment, indicating a reduction in larger pores.
  • The parameters of the logistic model (α and β) could be reasonably predicted, with α (related to external void volume) being particularly accurate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • NaCl Data Exclusion: The authors excluded NaCl data from their primary curve fitting due to potential ion exclusion/attraction mechanisms, which might limit the model's applicability to columns where ionic interactions are significant.
  • Extrapolation of PEG Data: The PEG molecular weight-to-radius relationship (Equation 1) was extrapolated beyond the original data range (up to 20,000 Da), which could introduce some uncertainty.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that understanding how enzyme treatment affects charged groups on the cellulose surface is important. This could influence resolution differently for columns that are further derivatized with cation or anion exchange groups. Future work could explore these derivatized columns and the impact of enzyme treatment on their separation performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rolled stationary phases are fabrics (i.e., nonparticulate phases) that rapidly separate proteins from salts on the basis of size exclusion. Pore size and pore size distributions in the stationary phase determine how different size molecules distribute between the stationary and mobile phases in liquid chromatography columns. The potential for size exclusion chromatography by fabrics is not initially obvious because their interlaced structures are atypical for size exclusion supports. A simple logistic model fits the pore size distribution of a rolled stationary phase when pore sizes were measured using PEG, Dextran, D2O, glucose, and NaCl probes. When the fabric is treated with cellulase enzymes, the water-accessible pores uniformly decrease and peak retention is lower. The logistic function model captures this result and enables comparison of pore size distribution curves between enzyme-treated and untreated fabrics in rolled stationary phase columns.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{keim2002modeling,
  author = {Craig Keim and Chenghong Li and Christine M. Ladisch and Michael R. Ladisch},
  title = {{Modeling Pore Size Distribution in Cellulose Rolled Stationary Phases}},
  booktitle = {Biotechnology},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1021/bp010197e},
}
Figure