Modeling of the Arc Characteristics inside a Thermal Laminar Plasma Torch with Different Gas Components

Jing Tao, Changpeng Li, Xiuquan Cao, Shuangliang Li, Jingdong Wang, Guangzhong HuProcesses 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Numerical simulations are effective, low-cost methods to reveal the internal mechanisms of thermal spraying plasma torches. While various models exist for studying plasma torch characteristics, more attention is required to build precise models of laminar plasma torches to understand their generating mechanisms and flow characteristics. Based on the user-defined function (UDF) and user-defined scalar (UDS) of ANSYS Fluent, this study discusses the assumptions, governing equations, boundary conditions, and solving methods for a numerical model of a home-made laminar spraying plasma torch. The study results show that the axial temperature of the plasma torch can be divided into three distinct sections: a peak temperature area (10mm < x < 20mm), a stable temperature area (20mm < x < 62mm), and a decreasing temperature area (62mm < x < 95mm). Furthermore, the axial velocity of pure nitrogen is significantly higher than that of pure argon, and the simulated arc voltage trends align well with experimental data.

Introduction

Laminar plasma jets are essential tools in high-precision material processing, such as thermal spraying and surface modification. Unlike turbulent jets, laminar jets offer superior stability, longer lengths, and lower noise. However, the extreme internal environment of a plasma torch—where temperatures can exceed 10,000 K—makes direct physical measurement nearly impossible. Sensors placed within the arc chamber would be destroyed instantly, and exhaustive physical experimentation with various gas mixtures is economically unfeasible. This research addresses this gap by developing a high-fidelity 2D numerical model to "see" the internal generating mechanisms and optimize torch performance without destructive testing.

Numerical Methodology and Material Properties

The researchers constructed a 2D axisymmetric model using ANSYS Fluent 2021 R1. To handle the complex coupled physics of electric arcs, the team implemented custom User-Defined Functions (UDFs) and User-Defined Scalars (UDSs) to solve governing equations for mass, momentum, energy, and electromagnetics. The model accounts for Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (Non-LTE) in critical near-electrode regions and utilizes the SST k-ω model to manage flow transitions.

A critical component of the simulation is the inclusion of accurate thermodynamic and transport properties for the working gases. These properties, including specific heat, enthalpy, electrical conductivity, and viscosity, vary significantly with temperature and gas composition, fundamentally dictating the arc's behavior.

Thermodynamic and transport properties of various gases used in the simulation, including (a) specific heat, (b) enthalpy, (c) electrical conductivity, (d) viscosity, and thermal conductivity.

Key Insights and Results

The Three-Zone Axial Profile

The simulation identified that the axial temperature is not a uniform gradient but consists of three zones:

  1. Peak Temperature Area (10–20mm): Caused by intense electron collisions near the cathode.
  2. Stable Area (20–62mm): Where the plasma reaches thermal equilibrium.
  3. Decrease Area (62–95mm): As the plasma moves toward the torch outlet.

Gas Component Effects

The choice of gas significantly reshapes the plasma arc. Nitrogen ($N_2$), a diatomic gas, has a more profound effect than monatomic Argon ($Ar$). The dissociation of $N_2$ molecules absorbs and redistributes energy, constricting the arc and resulting in higher temperatures and velocities.

  • Temperature: Pure $N_2$ produced stable temperatures of approximately 11,000 K, while pure $Ar$ arcs hovered between 9,000 K and 10,000 K.
  • Velocity: Nitrogen plasma flows peaked at 240 m/s near the anode, compared to only 190 m/s for Argon, due to nitrogen's lower density and higher arc temperature.
  • Voltage: Pure $N_2$ required higher voltages (~195 V) than $Ar$ because nitrogen is more difficult to ionize, leading to higher plasma impedance.

Experimental Validation

The model's accuracy was verified using a 20 kW home-made laminar plasma torch. The simulated arc voltage trends matched experimental observations. Furthermore, the high-intensity rings of erosion found on experimental electrodes perfectly corresponded with the model's predicted peaks in current density, confirming the simulation's spatial accuracy.

Conclusion

This numerical model provides a powerful tool for predicting the internal characteristics of laminar plasma torches. While the current 2D model is highly effective for symmetric torches, future work will explore 3D phenomena such as "arc root jumping" to further improve jet stability and prolong the service life of torch hardware. These insights allow for the customization of torch geometries and gas mixtures for specific industrial applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

For low costs, numerical simulation is an effective method to reveal the internal mechanisms inside a thermal plasma torch. Various simulation models for studying the inside or outside characteristics of thermal plasma torches have been built and discussed. However, to reveal the inside mechanisms of thermal plasma torches under various working conditions to support the materials processing, more attention should be paid to building precise models of laminar plasma torches. Thus, based on the user-defined function (UDF) and user-defined scalar (UDS) of ANSYS Fluent software, the assumptions, governing equations, boundary conditions, and solving method were discussed in detail, and a corresponding numerical model of a homemade laminar plasma torch was first built. For verifying the effectiveness of the proposed numerical model and studying the influence of the gas components on the arc characteristics, the working conditions and experimental setups were introduced in sequence. Finally, the numerical and experimental results of the homemade laminar plasma torch were obtained and discussed in detail. The study results show that: ① The axial temperature of the plasma torch could be divided into three sections along the axis: peak temperature area (10 mm &lt; x &lt; 20 mm), stable temperature area (20 mm &lt; x &lt; 62 mm) and decrease temperature area (62 mm &lt; x &lt; 95 mm). Under the same input conditions, when pure argon gas was used, the peak temperature at the outlet was reached at approximately 7590 K, while for pure nitrogen and 50%Ar + 50%N2, the corresponding peak temperatures were 6785 K and 7402.2 K, respectively. ② The axial velocity of pure nitrogen is much higher than that of pure argon and 50%Ar + 50%N2, while that of pure argon and 50%Ar + 50%N2 has little difference. In addition, when nitrogen gas was used, the peak velocity at the outlet reached 185 m/s, whereas, for argon gas and 50%Ar + 50%N2, the corresponding peak velocities were 146 m/s and 169 m/s, respectively. ③ The simulated arc voltage trends under different working conditions are well in accordance with the experimental arc voltage trends.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tao2024modeling,
  author = {Jing Tao and Changpeng Li and Xiuquan Cao and Shuangliang Li and Jingdong Wang and Guangzhong Hu},
  title = {{Modeling of the Arc Characteristics inside a Thermal Laminar Plasma Torch with Different Gas Components}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pr12061207},
}
Figure