Modeling of Resilience Properties in Oscillatory Biological Systems Using Parametric Time Petri Nets

Alexander Andreychenko, Morgan Magnin, Katsumi InoueCMSB 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach using parametric time Petri nets (P-TPNs) to precisely analyze the resilience of biological oscillatory systems, like the circadian clock. By formalizing resilience properties and leveraging parametric model checking, the authors demonstrate how to quantitatively assess the impact of environmental changes and perturbations on these biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the complex dynamics of biological systems, particularly their ability to maintain function despite environmental disturbances (resilience), is a significant challenge. While models exist, precisely analyzing how these systems adapt to changes like jet-lag or component failures, especially considering the timing of biological processes, remains difficult. The authors aim to bridge this gap by providing a formal framework using parametric time Petri nets (P-TPNs) to rigorously model and verify these resilience properties. This allows for a deeper understanding of how biological oscillators respond to various perturbations and how their behavior can be guaranteed under different conditions.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in the application of Parametric Time Petri Nets (P-TPNs). These are an extension of traditional Petri nets that incorporate time delays for transitions and allow for parameters within these delays. The authors extend P-TPNs with read and logical inhibitor arcs, enhancing their expressivity for modeling biological systems.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Parametric TCTL (P-TCTL): A temporal logic specifically designed for P-TPNs. This logic allows for the specification of properties that depend on the parametric time intervals of transitions.
  • Observer Construction: A crucial technique where auxiliary components (observers) are added to the P-TPN model. These observers are used to simulate specific environmental conditions or perturbations (e.g., light changes, gene knock-out) and to check how the system behaves under these altered scenarios.
  • Parametric Model Checking: The authors leverage this technique to analyze the P-TPN models. Instead of just verifying properties for fixed parameter values, parametric model checking allows for the synthesis of parameter ranges that satisfy a given property. This is essential for understanding the limits of resilience.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and its application to a simplified model of the circadian clock, rather than empirical data from specific biological experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Formalizing Resilience: The paper provides a concrete way to formally define and verify resilience properties in biological systems. This moves beyond qualitative descriptions to quantitative analysis.
  • Impact of Parametric Delays: The study highlights how precise timing (parametric delays) in biological processes is critical for resilience. Small changes in these delays can significantly impact the system's ability to cope with perturbations.
  • Observer-Based Analysis: The use of observers is a powerful technique for simulating external influences and testing the system's robustness without altering the core model.
  • Model Elicitation: The framework can be used to refine biological models. By checking properties and observing parameter synthesis results, researchers can gain insights into the underlying biological mechanisms and identify missing or incorrect model components.
  • Limitations of Local Clocks: The authors acknowledge that P-TPN formalism, while powerful, has limitations in modeling recovery processes that rely on global synchronization or complex feedback loops beyond local clock mechanisms.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the applicability of their P-TPN framework through several queries on a simplified circadian clock model:

  • Query I: Investigates the system's behavior under constant darkness, showing that specific parameter values are required for sustained oscillation.
  • Query II: Explores the duration of light exposure that allows for a specific property to hold, identifying a range of acceptable parameters for a particular perturbation.
  • Query III: Examines the impact of switching on light during "night," revealing that while the model can handle some deviations, it doesn't fully capture complex recovery processes.
  • Firing Delay Analysis: The analysis of transition firing delays (e.g., for tg and ta) shows that biologically irrelevant delays (like zero firing delay) can be identified, and that the model can accommodate a range of behaviors, suggesting redundancy in biological systems.
  • Gene Knock-out and Jet-Lag: The framework is used to model the effects of gene knock-out (leading to system malfunction) and artificial jet-lag (prolonging the time for certain processes to occur).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local Clocks: The authors explicitly state that P-TPN formalism does not allow for modeling recovery processes that are ruled by local clocks only. This means that complex adaptive responses that require global coordination might not be fully captured.
  • Model Elicitation Limitations: While the framework aids in model elicitation, it cannot perform pure inference. Prior biological knowledge is still necessary to formalize properties and guide the analysis.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that applying this workflow to more complex gene regulatory networks and formalizing more biologically inspired properties could lead to more precise parameter estimations and a deeper understanding of biological systems. They also hint at the need for more advanced formalisms to capture recovery processes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{andreychenko2015modeling,
  author = {Alexander Andreychenko and Morgan Magnin and Katsumi Inoue},
  title = {{Modeling of Resilience Properties in Oscillatory Biological Systems Using Parametric Time Petri Nets}},
  booktitle = {CMSB},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-23401-4\_20},
}
Figure