Modeling Genetic Circuit Behavior in Transiently Transfected Mammalian Cells

Junmin Wang, Samuel A. Isaacson, Călin BeltaACS 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of accurately modeling gene expression in transiently transfected mammalian cells, where traditional models fail to capture observed protein production saturation. They introduce a novel "bin-dependent" model that accounts for this saturation by treating cells with low and high plasmid copy numbers differently, achieving up to twice the accuracy of existing methods with only one additional parameter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transient transfection is a widely used technique to introduce genetic material into mammalian cells for protein production or gene circuit studies. A common practice in analyzing data from these experiments is to group cells based on their plasmid copy number (binning). Many existing computational models assume that protein production rates are directly proportional to plasmid copy number. However, the authors observe that these models often fail to accurately reproduce experimental data, particularly at higher plasmid copy numbers where protein production appears to plateau or saturate. This discrepancy suggests that the simple proportionality assumption breaks down, and a more nuanced approach is needed to model gene expression in these systems.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Stochastic Modeling: They first developed a detailed stochastic model to explore the underlying mechanisms of protein saturation. This allowed them to investigate how factors like transcription or translation saturation, and correlations between co-transfected plasmids, contribute to the observed phenomena.
  • Bin-Dependent Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) Model: Building on the insights from the stochastic model, they proposed a novel, simplified ODE model. This "bin-dependent" model divides the cell population into two groups based on plasmid copy number: one group exhibiting linear protein production and another exhibiting saturation. This coarse-grained approach avoids specifying the exact physical mechanism of saturation but captures its effect.
  • Model Fitting and Validation: They fitted both a traditional Hill-function-based model and their new bin-dependent model to experimental flow cytometry data. Model performance was evaluated using mean-squared errors and cross-validation.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental flow cytometry data from previous work (specifically, data from Ref. 26) for three repressors: TAL14, TAL21, and LmrA. This data represents dose-response curves of induced and regulated proteins across different plasmid copy numbers. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Saturation is Key: The core insight is that protein production saturation at high plasmid copy numbers is a critical factor that traditional models miss, leading to their inaccuracies.
  • Multiple Saturation Mechanisms: The stochastic model revealed that various physical mechanisms can lead to this observed saturation, making it difficult to pinpoint a single cause from experimental data alone.
  • Binning as a Solution: The bin-dependent model elegantly addresses saturation by acknowledging that cells with different plasmid copy numbers behave differently, rather than assuming a uniform response.
  • Minimal Parameter Increase: The bin-dependent model achieves improved accuracy with only one additional parameter compared to standard models, making it practical for integration into larger circuit models.
  • Plasmid Correlation Matters: The study highlighted the significant role of initial correlations between co-transfected plasmids in influencing saturation effects.

Key Results

  • The bin-dependent model achieved up to twice the accuracy in fitting flow cytometry data compared to traditional Hill-function-based models.
  • Cross-validation showed that the bin-dependent model had 1.5-2 times better fitting and testing errors than the Hill-function-based models.
  • The bin-dependent model provided a good fit across the entire dataset (all plasmid copy numbers) while requiring only one additional parameter.
  • The study demonstrated that the bin-dependent model can be used to accurately predict the behavior of more complex genetic circuits (cascades and feed-forward circuits) when composed from individually fit modules.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanistic Ambiguity: The authors acknowledge that single-time point flow cytometry data cannot definitively disentangle the precise physical mechanisms causing saturation. Their bin-dependent model is phenomenological, capturing the effect without specifying the cause.
  • Need for More Data: Developing a more physically detailed model would ideally require additional experimental data, particularly time-resolved measurements.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that the bin-dependent model provides a valuable framework for building characterized libraries of regulatory switches. These libraries can then be used for constructing more complex in silico models of biological circuits, improving predictions of circuit behavior in transiently transfected mammalian cells. The authors also note the importance of accounting for batch effects in future model compositions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Binning cells by plasmid copy number is a common practice for analyzing transient transfection data. In many kinetic models of transfected cells, protein production rates are assumed to be proportional to plasmid copy number. The validity of this assumption in transiently transfected mammalian cells is not clear; models based on this assumption appear unable to reproduce experimental flow cytometry data robustly. We hypothesize that protein saturation at high plasmid copy number is a reason previous models break down and validate our hypothesis by comparing experimental data and a stochastic chemical kinetics model. The model demonstrates that there are multiple distinct physical mechanisms that can cause saturation. On the basis of these observations, we develop a novel minimal bin-dependent ODE model that assumes different parameters for protein production in cells with low versus high numbers of plasmids. Compared to a traditional Hill-function-based model, the bin-dependent model requires only one additional parameter, but fits flow cytometry input-output data for individual modules up to twice as accurately. By composing together models of individually fit modules, we use the bin-dependent model to predict the behavior of six cascades and three feed-forward circuits. The bin-dependent models are shown to provide more accurate predictions on average than corresponding (composed) Hill-function-based models and predictions of comparable accuracy to EQuIP, while still providing a minimal ODE-based model that should be easy to integrate as a subcomponent within larger differential equation circuit models. Our analysis also demonstrates that accounting for batch effects is important in developing accurate composed models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019modeling,
  author = {Junmin Wang and Samuel A. Isaacson and Călin Belta},
  title = {{Modeling Genetic Circuit Behavior in Transiently Transfected Mammalian Cells}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acssynbio.8b00166},
}
Figure