Modeling Enablers of Environmentally Conscious Manufacturing Strategy: An Integrated Method

Lin Ma, Wenyan Song, Yanru ZhouSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel integrated method combining DEMATEL and rough set theory to identify and analyze the crucial enablers of Environmentally Conscious Manufacturing Strategy (ECMS). By accounting for interdependencies and handling vague expert judgments, the method pinpoints "Corporate Social Responsibility motivation" as the most critical enabler for an equipment manufacturing company.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Implementing an Environmentally Conscious Manufacturing Strategy (ECMS) is crucial for businesses aiming for sustainability, but identifying and understanding the factors that drive its success (enablers) is challenging. Previous research often overlooks the complex interrelationships between these enablers and struggles to handle the inherent ambiguity and subjectivity in expert opinions during the decision-making process. This leads to inaccurate identification and prioritization of enablers, hindering effective ECMS implementation.

Methods

The core of this paper is an integrated rough DEMATEL method. This approach combines:

  • DEMATEL (Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory): A technique for visualizing complex causal relationships and understanding the interactions between factors.
  • Rough Set Theory: A mathematical framework adept at handling uncertainty and vagueness in data, particularly useful when dealing with subjective expert judgments without requiring prior assumptions about data distributions or membership functions.

The method involves:

  1. Establishing a Direct-Relation Matrix: Experts assess the influence of each enabler on every other enabler using a defined scale.
  2. Transforming to Rough Interval Form: Expert judgments, which are often vague, are converted into rough interval numbers to represent uncertainty.
  3. Constructing the Integrated Rough Direct-Relation Matrix: Individual expert assessments are aggregated into a group direct-relation matrix using rough intervals.
  4. Constructing the Total-Relation Matrix: This step normalizes the direct-relation matrix and then calculates the total-relation matrix, which captures both direct and indirect influences between enablers.
  5. Identifying Critical Enablers: Rough intervals are converted into concrete values, and "Prominence" (overall influence) and "Relation" (cause/effect) scores are calculated. This allows for the prioritization of enablers and the creation of an impact-relation map.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 12 ECMS experts within an equipment manufacturing company. These experts included three ECMS researchers and nine managers (four production managers, two technical managers, and three senior managers). The experts provided pairwise assessments of the influence between 12 identified ECMS enablers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interdependencies are Key: Simply listing enablers isn't enough; understanding how they influence each other is critical for effective ECMS implementation.
  • Embracing Vagueness: Expert opinions are inherently uncertain. The proposed method's ability to handle this vagueness using rough set theory provides a more realistic and robust analysis than traditional methods.
  • CSR as a Primary Driver: "Corporate Social Responsibility motivation" emerged as the most critical enabler, highlighting its foundational role in driving other ECMS initiatives.
  • Cause-and-Effect Mapping: The impact-relation map visually distinguishes between enablers that drive change (causes) and those that are influenced by it (effects), offering a clear strategic roadmap.

Key Results

The application of the integrated rough DEMATEL method to an equipment manufacturing company yielded the following key results:

  • Top Enabler: "Corporate Social Responsibility motivation" (E12) was identified as the most critical enabler, with a Prominence score of 7.062.
  • Prioritized Enablers: The enablers were ranked, with E12 > E11 > E3 > E10 > E5 > E9 > E1 > E2 > E7 > E4 > E8 > E6.
  • Cause Group: E1 (Environmental protection equipment), E2 (Environmental design technology), E3 (Environmental protection willingness), E4 (Managerial support), E6 (Environmental protection expenditure), and E7 (Resource efficiency) were identified as causal factors.
  • Effect Group: E5 (Company image), E8 (Emission of air pollutants), E9 (Solid waste), E10 (Employee's health), E11 (Living environment), and E12 (Corporate social responsibility motivation) were identified as effect factors.
  • Critical Interactions: The study highlighted specific critical relationships, such as E1 and E2 influencing E5 (Company image), and E7 (Resource efficiency) impacting E11 (Living environment).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • No Positive/Negative Differentiation: The current method classifies enablers into cause and effect groups but does not differentiate between positive and negative relationships among enablers.
  • Critical Path Exploration: Identifying the critical path of influence requires further exploration.
  • Single Case Study: The study was conducted on one company, limiting its generalizability.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Incorporating the distinction between positive and negative relationships for a more accurate analysis.
  • Exploring methods to identify critical influence paths.
  • Conducting more case studies across different industries to validate the external validity of the approach.

Summary updated

Abstract

Environmentally conscious manufacturing (ECM) has become an ever-more important strategy for most manufacturing companies to enhance the sustainability of their business. The successful adoption of environmentally conscious manufacturing strategy (ECMS) requires identifying a variety of crucial enablers and understanding their relationships of ECM strategy. However, most previous studies do not consider the interrelationships between enablers, and lack the mechanism of manipulating the vagueness in the decision-making process, which leads to the inaccurate identification of enablers. Thus, to solve these problems, an integrated method based on DEMATEL (Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory) and rough set theory is developed in this paper. The method integrates the strength of DEMATEL in dealing with interactions between factors and the ability of rough set theory to manipulate uncertainty. Finally, the method is applied to analyze the enablers of ECMS in an equipment manufacturing company to reveal the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed approach. The “corporate social responsibility motivation” is identified as the most critical enabler for the case company in implementing ECMS, and it is influenced by other ECMS enablers including “environmental protection equipment” and “environmental design technology”.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2018modeling,
  author = {Lin Ma and Wenyan Song and Yanru Zhou},
  title = {{Modeling Enablers of Environmentally Conscious Manufacturing Strategy: An Integrated Method}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10072284},
}
Figure