Modeling Constraints for the On-Site Assembly Process of Prefabrication Housing Production: A Social Network Analysis

Pan Gong, Yue Teng, Xiao Li, Lizi LuoSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses Social Network Analysis (SNA) to model the complex interrelationships between trades and constraints in prefabrication housing production (PHP) on-site assembly. By identifying critical constraints like labor availability and installation planning, it offers practical insights for improving project schedules and proposes a Smart Work Packaging (SWP) system for dynamic constraint management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Prefabrication Housing Production (PHP) offers numerous benefits like improved quality and reduced construction time. However, its on-site assembly process is often plagued by poor interoperability and fragmentation, leading to various constraints that hinder project progress. These constraints, arising from the interactions between different trades and tasks, are complex and difficult to manage. Existing research often treats constraints and trades as separate entities, failing to capture their intricate network of relationships. This paper aims to bridge this gap by modeling these trade-associated constraints and their interdependencies to better understand and manage them for improved schedule control in PHP projects, particularly in high-density urban environments like Hong Kong.

Methods

The study employs a three-step methodology:

  1. Identification of Trade-Associated Constraints: This involved a literature review and semi-structured interviews with professionals involved in PHP projects. A chain-referral sampling method was used to identify 10 key trades and 31 associated constraints, which were then categorized into informational and physical types.
  2. Determination of Constraint Links: A questionnaire survey was conducted with the interviewed trades to determine the existence, direction, intensity, and likeliness of links between constraints. The Delphi method was used to refine these links and minimize bias.
  3. Network Visualization and Quantitation: Social Network Analysis (SNA) was applied using NetMiner 4 software to visualize and quantify the identified constraints and their relationships. Six SNA indicators (network density, degree centrality, closeness centrality, betweenness centrality, status centrality, and eigenvector centrality) were used to identify critical constraints and their influence within the network.

Datasets

Not explicitly detailed as a "dataset" in the traditional machine learning sense. The primary data sources were:

  • Semi-structured interviews: Conducted with three representatives from contractors of a typical PHP project in Hong Kong.
  • Delphi survey: Used to refine the identified links between constraints.
  • Questionnaire survey: Administered to interviewees to quantify the intensity and likeliness of constraint links.
  • Literature review: Provided a basis for initial constraint identification.

The study also mentions validation by 14 professionals with extensive experience in PHP projects in Hong Kong.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interconnectedness is Key: The study highlights that constraints in PHP are not isolated issues but are deeply interconnected, forming a complex network. Understanding these relationships is crucial for effective management.
  • Labor and Planning are Critical Bottlenecks: The research strongly points to the availability of labor resources and optimal installation planning as the most significant challenges impacting PHP schedules.
  • Communication is Paramount: Effective communication mechanisms among different trades are identified as a critical factor for smooth on-site assembly.
  • SNA as a Powerful Tool: Social Network Analysis proves to be an effective method for visualizing and quantifying the complex web of constraints, revealing critical nodes and their influence.
  • Proactive Constraint Management: The paper advocates for a shift towards proactive constraint identification and dynamic management, moving beyond static analysis.

Key Results

  • Seven Critical Constraints: The study identified seven trade-associated constraints that warrant significant attention for schedule control in PHP.
  • Three Major Challenges: The analysis distilled these into three overarching challenges:
  • Communication barriers among different trades.
    1. Lack of optimal installation planning.
    2. Unavailable labor and equipment resources.
  • Critical Links Identified: The analysis revealed critical interactions, such as the link between "Unavailable lifting and placing location" (T4C15) and "Lack of collision-free path planning" (T6C14), which had the highest link betweenness centrality (109.8).
  • Node Centrality: The constraint "Unavailable and unassigned labor resources" (T1C4) sourced from the site superintendent emerged as a highly influential node, exhibiting strong out-degree and out-status centrality.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Case Study: The study acknowledges that it was based on a limited single case study in Hong Kong. Future empirical studies should adopt a multi-case study approach to compare findings and develop more robust strategies.
  • Static Nature of SNA: The current constraint identification process using SNA is static. The authors suggest exploring automated constraint identification and dynamic constraint relationship mapping under different scenarios.
  • Dynamic Constraint Management: Future work should focus on achieving dynamically, timely, and efficient improvement and continual prediction of constraints.
  • Constraint Optimization: Advanced optimization algorithms are recommended for efficient layout design and sequencing, and different action strategies should be developed based on real-time constraint monitoring.
  • SWP-Enabled Strategies: The paper proposes a Smart Work Packaging (SWP)-enabled system for automatic constraint identification and dynamic mapping, which requires further development and validation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although prefabrication housing production (PHP) has been widely advocated with advantages like ensured good quality and secured workplaces, its poor interoperability and fragmentation still causes various constraints, limiting the progress of projects. This paper aims to model the constraints and their relationships in task executions of different trades during the on-site assembly process of PHP. It was conducted through a typical PHP case study in Hong Kong to identify the critical trade associated constraints and their links during the on-site assembly process. Original data were collected by semi-structured interview, Delphi survey and questionnaire with representative professionals from the case. Social Network Analysis (SNA) was used to model the constraints and their interrelationships. The results indicated that seven trade-associated constraints were worth more attention. Three significant challenges were determined, indicating that the on-site team should focus on the availability of labor resources, optimal installation planning and effectiveness of communication mechanism. Smart work packaging (SWP)-enabled system for achieving automatic constraint identification and dynamic constraint relationship mapping under different constraint scenarios was suggested. This paper offers practical insights for scholars to conduct a trade-associated constraint identification study in the network manner and is expected to benefit practitioners on using the results for decision-making.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2019modeling,
  author = {Pan Gong and Yue Teng and Xiao Li and Lizi Luo},
  title = {{Modeling Constraints for the On-Site Assembly Process of Prefabrication Housing Production: A Social Network Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11051387},
}
Figure