Modeling Community Residents’ Exercise Adherence and Life Satisfaction: An Application of the Influence of the Reference Group

Huimin Song, Wei Zeng, Ting-ting ZengInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how social influences (reference groups) and urban environments (strategic and cultural fit) impact community residents' exercise adherence and life satisfaction. It reveals that these external factors, mediated by personal investment and life satisfaction, are crucial drivers for consistent physical activity, offering valuable insights for public health initiatives.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In an era where physical inactivity is a global health concern, understanding the motivations behind consistent exercise adherence is critical. While individual factors are often studied, this paper focuses on the often-overlooked external influences that shape our health behaviors. Specifically, it addresses the question of how social environments, like the people we associate with (reference groups), and the broader urban context (strategic and cultural fit) can be leveraged to encourage regular exercise. The study aims to bridge the gap in research by applying the Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) framework to understand how these external "stimuli" influence individuals' internal states ("organism") and ultimately their behavior ("response") of exercise adherence, particularly in the context of community-level initiatives.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach, utilizing survey data from 734 residents in two Chinese cities, Xiamen and Fuzhou. They applied several statistical techniques:

  • Factor Analyses: Used to validate the measurement scales for constructs like reference group influence (informational, utilitarian, and value-expressive), personal investment, strategic and cultural fit, life satisfaction, and exercise adherence.
  • Regression Analysis: Employed to examine the direct effects of the independent variables (reference group, strategic/cultural fit) on the dependent variables (personal investment, life satisfaction, exercise adherence) and the mediating roles of personal investment and life satisfaction.
  • t-test Analysis: Conducted to compare the means of key variables between the two cities (Xiamen and Fuzhou), highlighting differences in their social and urban environments.
  • Bootstrapping: Used to test the chain mediating effects of personal investment and life satisfaction between the external stimuli and exercise adherence, providing robust statistical evidence for these indirect pathways.

The study also conducted a pilot test to ensure the reliability and internal consistency of the questionnaire items, with Cronbach's alpha values generally exceeding the acceptable threshold of 0.7.

Datasets

The study utilized survey data collected from 734 Chinese residents across two cities: Xiamen and Fuzhou. The data was gathered through both online and offline questionnaires, with a response rate of over 88% for both cities. The paper does not introduce any new benchmark datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Social Circles: The study strongly suggests that our friends, family, and colleagues (our reference groups) significantly influence our decision to exercise. This influence operates through providing information, shaping norms, and offering a sense of belonging.
  • Urban Environment Matters: The "strategic and cultural fit" of a city's approach to promoting exercise (e.g., infrastructure, media campaigns) is not just about aesthetics; it actively encourages residents to engage in physical activity. This highlights the role of urban planning and policy in public health.
  • Internal Drivers are Key Mediators: While external factors are important, their impact on exercise adherence is significantly channeled through internal psychological states. Personal investment (time, effort, money) and life satisfaction act as crucial bridges, translating external influences into sustained exercise behavior.
  • Chain Reaction of Influence: The research demonstrates a compelling chain: reference groups and urban fit influence personal investment and life satisfaction, which in turn drive exercise adherence. This suggests a multi-layered approach is needed for effective health promotion.
  • City Culture Shapes Behavior: Differences between Xiamen (a leisure-oriented city) and Fuzhou reveal how distinct urban cultures and development levels can lead to variations in residents' exercise awareness, personal investment, and adherence.

Key Results

  • Reference Group and Strategic/Cultural Fit Impact: Both reference group influences (informational, utilitarian, and value-expressive) and strategic/cultural fit were found to have significant positive effects on residents' personal investment, life satisfaction, and exercise adherence in both Xiamen and Fuzhou.
  • Personal Investment and Life Satisfaction as Mediators: Personal investment and life satisfaction were confirmed to have a positive chain mediating effect between the reference group and strategic/cultural fit, and exercise adherence. This means these internal factors are essential for the external influences to translate into actual exercise behavior.
  • Life Satisfaction Predicts Adherence: Life satisfaction was a significant predictor of exercise adherence, indicating that happier individuals are more likely to engage in healthy behaviors.
  • City-Specific Differences: The t-test analysis revealed significant differences between Xiamen and Fuzhou. Xiamen residents showed lower informational influence but higher personal investment and utilitarian influence, along with higher education and income, and a stronger leisure culture, which correlated with a longer exercise history but lower frequency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reference Group Influence Degree: The study acknowledges that it did not differentiate the degree of influence from different reference groups (e.g., family vs. friends). Future research could explore how varying levels of influence from different social circles impact exercise behavior.
  • Generalizability: While the study included two cities, future work could expand to a wider range of cities to capture more diverse cultural and developmental contexts.
  • Dynamic Nature of Influence: The study captures a snapshot in time. Future research could explore how these influences evolve over longer periods.
  • Intervention Design: The findings provide a strong basis for designing targeted interventions that leverage reference groups and improve urban exercise environments to boost adherence and life satisfaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

To expand the application area of the reference group and enrich exercise theoretical research, based on Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) framework, this study examines the external factors that motivate adherence to exercise. Taking reference group and strategy and cultural fit as the main stimuli, and personal investment and life satisfaction as mediating variables, this study explores the influence of external stimuli on residents' exercise behavior. In order to enrich the sample size, two surveys of 734 Chinese residents in two cities (Xiamen vs. Fuzhou) were conducted using factor analyses, regression analysis, and <i>t</i>-test analysis. The results indicated that the reference group and strategic and cultural fit as external stimuli impact on residents' personal investment, life satisfaction and exercise adherence, and that personal investment and life satisfaction as the organism has an impact on residents' exercise adherence. Personal investment and life satisfaction play a chain mediating role between the reference group and exercise adherence, and between strategy and cultural fit and exercise adherence. Moreover, the <i>t</i>-test determined the differences between Xiamen and Fuzhou residents' exercise adherence and life satisfaction. Residents' surroundings affect their exercise behavior and life satisfaction. These findings have implications for policymaking aimed at promoting national exercise, which could gradually improve residents' physical fitness, particularly in light of the current coronavirus emergency.
BibTeX
@article{song2022modeling,
  author = {Huimin Song and Wei Zeng and Ting-ting Zeng},
  title = {{Modeling Community Residents’ Exercise Adherence and Life Satisfaction: An Application of the Influence of the Reference Group}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192013174},
}
Figure