Modeling biochar effects on soil organic carbon on croplands in a microbial decomposition model (MIMICS-BC_v1.0)

Mengjie Han, Qing Zhao, Xili Wang, Ying‐Ping Wang, Philippe Ciais, Haicheng Zhang, Daniel S. Goll, Lei Zhu, Zhe Zhao, Zhixuan Guo, Chen Wang, Wei Zhuang, Fengchang Wu, Wei LiGeoscientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces MIMICS-BC_v1.0, a new model that simulates the complex effects of biochar on soil organic carbon (SOC) in croplands. By incorporating microbial dynamics, sorption processes, and soil moisture, the model accurately predicts short- and long-term SOC changes, offering a crucial tool for evaluating biochar's role in climate change mitigation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil organic carbon (SOC) is a massive carbon reservoir, and understanding how it changes is vital for climate modeling. Biochar, a carbon-rich material produced from biomass pyrolysis, is proposed as a way to sequester carbon and improve soil health. However, most existing land models don't adequately represent biochar's impact on SOC dynamics. This gap prevents us from accurately quantifying biochar's potential for climate change mitigation under various conditions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and validating a more comprehensive model for biochar's effects on cropland SOC.

Methods

The researchers built upon the existing MIMICS (MIcrobial-MIneral Carbon Stabilization) model, which already accounts for microbial roles in SOC decomposition and stabilization. They introduced several key enhancements:

  • Density-Dependent Microbial Turnover: This accounts for how microbial activity is regulated by population size and competition, making the model more realistic.
  • Adsorption Processes: They incorporated the physical and chemical binding of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) to mineral surfaces, a crucial process for SOC stabilization that was previously missing.
  • Soil Moisture Effects: The model now explicitly considers how soil moisture influences microbial activity and decomposition rates, using empirical functions from established models.
  • Biochar Integration: Biochar itself was integrated by accounting for its effects on microbial decomposition and SOC sorption/desorption. This involved optimizing specific biochar-related parameters.

The model was developed in stages, with versions like MIMICS-T (density-dependent turnover), MIMICS-TS (adding sorption), and MIMICS-TSM (adding soil moisture) being tested before the final biochar-integrated versions (MIMICS-BC).

Datasets

The study utilized a substantial collection of field data:

  • Global Cropland SOC Data: 285 sites were used for calibrating and validating the MIMICS model's performance in simulating cropland SOC without biochar. This dataset combined data from the current study (58 sites) with three other published global datasets.
  • Paired Biochar Measurements: 134 paired SOC measurements (with and without biochar addition) from 58 sites were used specifically for calibrating and validating the biochar-related parameters in the MIMICS-BC model.
  • Auxiliary Data: Soil properties (clay content, bulk density, soil moisture), climatic conditions (temperature, precipitation), biological variables (net primary productivity), and biochar characteristics (application rate, age, feedstock, temperature) were collected to inform model inputs and analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biochar's Complexity: Biochar's impact on SOC isn't simple. It can have both positive and negative "priming effects" (influencing the decomposition of native SOC), and these effects can change over time.
  • Microbial Dynamics Matter: Simply accounting for microbial growth isn't enough; their turnover rates and how they interact (density-dependence) are crucial for accurate SOC modeling.
  • Sorption is Key for Stabilization: The physical binding of organic carbon to soil minerals is a significant factor in stabilizing SOC, and its omission in previous models was a major limitation.
  • Soil Moisture is a Major Regulator: The model's ability to capture SOC dynamics is significantly improved by explicitly including how soil moisture affects microbial processes.
  • Model Validation is Crucial: The study highlights the importance of validating models with both short-term and long-term data to capture the full picture of biochar's impact.

Key Results

  • Improved SOC Prediction: The developed MIMICS-biochar model (specifically MIMICSTSMb-BCDV) demonstrated strong performance in reproducing both short-term (≤ 6 years) and long-term (8 years) SOC changes after biochar application.
  • Short-term: R² = 0.79, RMSE = 3.73 g kg⁻¹
    • Long-term: R² = 0.97, RMSE = 6.08 g kg⁻¹
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The study found that biochar application rate (Rate_BC) and soil clay content were particularly influential factors in predicting SOC changes.
  • Model Performance: While MIMICS-T performed best for simulating cropland SOC without biochar, the biochar-integrated versions (especially MIMICSTSMb-BCDV) showed significant improvements in capturing biochar's effects.
  • Negative Priming: The model's parameters suggest that biochar can lead to negative priming effects, reducing the decomposition of native SOC, likely due to adsorption and physical protection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Constraints: The authors acknowledge that while new processes were added, the model parameters were primarily constrained by total SOC observations. Direct measurements of microbial biomass, enzyme activity, or sorption processes would further improve model calibration.
  • Cropland Management: The model currently doesn't explicitly account for complex agricultural management practices like tillage, fertilization, or irrigation, which can significantly influence SOC dynamics and may explain some model underestimations.
  • Biochar Heterogeneity: While the model accounts for biochar's general effects, the diverse properties of biochar (feedstock, pyrolysis temperature) and their specific impacts on microbial communities and soil properties could be further explored.
  • Long-term Data Needs: The study relied on extending short-term data to simulate long-term effects. More comprehensive, long-term field experiments are needed to fully validate the model's predictions of biochar's long-term SOC stability.
  • Vertical Profile: The model currently treats SOC as a homogenous pool and doesn't explicitly simulate vertical profiles, which could be important for understanding carbon transport and sequestration.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on incorporating more detailed microbial processes, soil physicochemical properties (like pH and ionic strength), and agricultural management practices to enhance the model's accuracy and predictive power.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biochar (BC) application to croplands aims to sequester carbon and improve soil quality, but its impact on soil organic carbon (SOC) dynamics is not represented in most land models used for assessing land-based climate change mitigation; therefore, we are unable to quantify the effects of biochar application under different climate or land management conditions. Here, to fill this gap, we implement a submodel to represent biochar in a microbial decomposition model named MIMICS (MIcrobial-MIneral Carbon Stabilization). We first calibrate and validate MIMICS with new representations of the density-dependent microbial turnover rate, adsorption of available organic carbon on mineral soil particles, and soil moisture effects on decomposition using global field-measured cropland SOC at 285 sites. We further integrate biochar in MIMICS by accounting for its effect on microbial decomposition and SOC sorption/desorption and optimize two biochar-related parameters in these processes using 134 paired SOC measurements with and without biochar addition. The MIMICS-biochar version can generally reproduce the short-term (≤ 6 years) and long-term (8 years) SOC changes after adding (mean addition rate of 25.6 t ha−1) biochar (R2= 0.79 and 0.97, respectively) with a low root-mean-square error (RMSE = 3.73 and 6.08 g kg−1, respectively). Our study incorporates sorption and soil moisture processes into MIMICS and extends its capacity to simulate biochar decomposition, providing a useful tool to couple with dynamic land models to evaluate the effectiveness of biochar application with respect to removing CO2 from the atmosphere.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2024modeling,
  author = {Mengjie Han and Qing Zhao and Xili Wang and Ying‐Ping Wang and Philippe Ciais and Haicheng Zhang and Daniel S. Goll and Lei Zhu and Zhe Zhao and Zhixuan Guo and Chen Wang and Wei Zhuang and Fengchang Wu and Wei Li},
  title = {{Modeling biochar effects on soil organic carbon on croplands in a microbial decomposition model (MIMICS-BC\_v1.0)}},
  booktitle = {Geoscientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5194/gmd-17-4871-2024},
}
Figure