Modeling and Experimental Testing of an Unmanned Surface Vehicle with Rudderless Double Thrusters

Chunyue Li, Jiajia Jiang, Fajie Duan, Wei Liu, Xianquan Wang, Lingran Bu, Zhongbo Sun, Guoliang YangSensors 2019 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel three-degree-of-freedom (DOF) dynamic model and a simplified propeller thrust model for unmanned surface vehicles (USVs) that use rudderless double thrusters. By reducing the complexity of the thrust model and integrating it with the dynamic model, the authors successfully developed and experimentally validated a control system for precise path-following, demonstrating a practical approach for this increasingly common USV configuration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional unmanned surface vehicles (USVs) often rely on a combination of thrusters and rudders for propulsion and steering. However, this configuration can be mechanically complex and prone to wear, particularly with the rudder. The paper addresses the challenge of modeling and controlling USVs that utilize a "rudderless double thruster" system, where steering is achieved solely through differential thrust from two propellers. This design offers potential advantages in simplicity and reliability, but requires a tailored modeling approach that has been less explored. The authors aim to fill this gap by developing an accurate dynamic model and a robust control strategy for such USVs.

Methods

The core of the paper involves developing a three-DOF dynamic model (surge, sway, and yaw) for the rudderless double thruster USV. This model simplifies the complex six-DOF motion of marine craft by assuming that heave, roll, and pitch are inherently stable and can be neglected for planar motion. A key innovation is the simplification of the propeller thrust model. Instead of identifying six parameters, the authors reduce it to two unknown parameters, making system identification more efficient. This simplified thrust model is then integrated into the dynamic model.

For parameter identification, the authors employ a series of experimental tests:

  • Acceleration Test: Used to estimate the linear drag coefficient in the surge direction.
  • Circle Test: Conducted to estimate the yaw and sway drag coefficients.
  • Zigzag Test: Utilized to further validate the identified model parameters and assess maneuvering characteristics.

Finally, a Proportional-Derivative (PD) controller combined with a Line-of-Sight (LOS) guidance algorithm is implemented for path-following control. The PD controller adjusts the differential thrust of the thrusters, while the LOS guidance provides the desired heading based on the USV's position relative to the desired path.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it relies on data collected from experimental tests conducted on a custom-built 1.5m, 50kg USV. These tests, including acceleration, circle, and zigzag maneuvers, generated the necessary data for system identification and model validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simplified Thrust Model: Reducing the propeller thrust model to two unknown parameters significantly streamlines the system identification process, making it more practical for real-world applications.
  • Rudderless Advantage: The rudderless double thruster design inherently simplifies the mechanical structure and enhances reliability, as the steering is managed by differential thrust. This eliminates a common point of failure.
  • Coupling of Velocity and Yaw: The paper highlights the coupling between forward velocity and yaw rate in rudderless double thruster systems, which needs to be accounted for in the dynamic model.
  • PD+LOS for Path Following: The combination of PD control and LOS guidance proves effective for robust path-following, even in the presence of simulated environmental disturbances.

Key Results

  • A three-DOF dynamic model and a two-parameter propeller thrust model were successfully established for the USV.
  • System identification experiments (acceleration, circle, zigzag tests) yielded model parameters with good accuracy. For instance, the linear drag coefficient $X_u$ was identified as 151.46 N/(m/s).
  • The developed model and control algorithm were validated through simulations and experiments, achieving path-following with small root mean square errors (RMSEs). For example, RMSEs for line, circle, and zigzag paths were 0.33 m, 0.86 m, and 0.54 m, respectively, in experiments, which are considered acceptable given the GPS accuracy of 1 m.
  • The controller demonstrated good performance in both line and curve path-following, indicating its versatility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Disturbances: While simulated time-dependent disturbances were included in path-following simulations, the experimental validation was conducted in a relatively calm environment (a lake). The paper acknowledges that real-world conditions can introduce deviations.
  • Model Simplifications: The kinetic model was simplified by ignoring nonlinear drag terms and off-diagonal terms in the mass and drag matrices. While these simplifications are justified for slow speeds and calm environments, their impact on performance in more dynamic conditions might warrant further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future work could involve extending the model to include more DOFs, investigating more complex environmental conditions, and exploring advanced control algorithms for enhanced performance and robustness. The established model is presented as a foundation for further research in rudderless double thruster USV control.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motion control of unmanned surface vehicles (USVs) is a crucial issue in sailing performance and navigation costs. The actuators of USVs currently available are mostly a combination of thrusters and rudders. The modeling for USVs with rudderless double thrusters is rarely studied. In this paper, the three degrees of freedom (DOFs) dynamic model and propeller thrust model of this kind of USV were derived and combined. The unknown parameters of the propeller thrust model were reduced from six to two. In the three-DOF model, the propulsion of the USV was completely provided by the resultant force generated by double thrusters and the rotational moment was related to the differential thrust. It combined the propeller thrust model to represent the thrust in more detail. We performed a series of tests for a 1.5 m long, 50 kg USV, in order to obtain the model parameters through system identification. Then, the accuracy of the modeling and identification results was verified by experimental testing. Finally, based on the established model and the proportional derivative+line of sight (PD+LOS) control algorithm, the path-following control of the USV was achieved through simulations and experiments. All these demonstrated the validity and practical value of the established model.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019modeling,
  author = {Chunyue Li and Jiajia Jiang and Fajie Duan and Wei Liu and Xianquan Wang and Lingran Bu and Zhongbo Sun and Guoliang Yang},
  title = {{Modeling and Experimental Testing of an Unmanned Surface Vehicle with Rudderless Double Thrusters}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=vxd5gh9P3v},
}

Loading related content...

Figure