Modeling a striped pseudogap state

Mats Granath, Brian M. AndersenPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study investigates the electronic structure within a system of phase-decoupled one-dimensional superconductors coexisting with stripe spin and charge-density-wave order. The model successfully reproduces a nodal Fermi surface in the form of a hole pocket (Fermi arcs) and an antinodal pseudogap. We find that states at the Fermi energy are extended, while states near the pseudogap energy exhibit localization lengths as short as the interstripe spacing. This state serves as a stripe-ordered caricature of the pseudogap phase in underdoped cuprates, reconciling coexisting spin, charge, and pair-density-wave correlations.

Introduction: The Pseudogap Enigma

In high-temperature cuprate superconductors, the "pseudogap" remains a central mystery. This state, appearing above the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$), is characterized by a partial suppression of the electronic density of states. Historically, two competing theories have dominated the debate: the "pre-formed pairs" scenario, where local superconductivity exists without global phase coherence, and the "competing order" scenario, where phases like "stripes" (unidirectional density waves) suppress superconductivity.

A significant challenge for any theory is explaining the "momentum-space dichotomy"—the observation that nodal regions of momentum space behave like a normal metal with "Fermi arcs," while antinodal regions are heavily gapped and incoherent. This paper proposes a model where stripes and local pairing coexist to reconcile these observations.

Methodology

The authors employ a tight-binding model on a square lattice to simulate electronic behavior. The "caricature" model incorporates:

  • Striped Order: A static field representing Spin Density Waves (SDW) and Charge Density Waves (CDW) with an eight-lattice-site period.
  • Local Pairing: A BCS-like pairing term ($\Delta$) restricted to hole-rich stripes.
  • Phase Decoupling: The phase of the superconducting pairing is randomized between stripes, representing local pairing without global coherence.
  • Analysis: The spectral function $A(k, \omega)$, Density of States (DOS), and Inverse Participation Ratio (IPR) are calculated to compare with ARPES and STM data.

Results and Discussion

The model's primary success lies in reproducing the momentum-space dichotomy. As shown in the spectral function plots, the system generates "Fermi arcs" (the front side of a hole pocket) in the nodal region while maintaining a robust gap in the antinodes.

Spectral function $A(k, \omega)$ showing the emergence of Fermi arcs and the antinodal gap.

A key insight is the role of localization. States at the Fermi energy (nodal regions) are extended across the system, making them appear metallic. Conversely, states near the pseudogap energy are localized to the stripes. Because the nodal states are extended, the random phases between stripes cause the pairing potential to average to zero, leaving them ungapped. Antinodal states, being confined to stripes, "feel" the local pairing and become gapped.

Furthermore, the spatially averaged Density of States (DOS) shows a clear pseudogap suppression at the Fermi level. When a small, uniform $d$-wave pairing term is introduced—simulating the onset of global coherence at $T < T_c$—a "subgap peak" ($\Delta_0$) emerges within the larger pseudogap, matching experimental STM observations.

Density of States (DOS) exhibiting the pseudogap suppression and the subgap peak $\Delta_0$.

The model also predicts that coherent superconducting weight is concentrated in the nodal regions, and results are largely independent of whether $d$-wave or $s$-wave local pairing is used, suggesting the local nature of pairing is the dominant factor.

Conclusion

This model provides a compelling framework for understanding the pseudogap as an effect of local pair correlations within a striped environment. While the current "caricature" uses static stripes and a 1D approximation, it captures the essential physics of the cuprate phase diagram. Future work will involve incorporating more realistic stripe disorder and extending the model to finite temperatures to explore the scaling of Fermi arcs.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the electronic structure within a system of phase-decoupled one-dimensional superconductors coexisting with stripe spin and charge-density-wave order. This system has a nodal Fermi surface (Fermi arc) in the form of a hole pocket and an antinodal pseudogap. The spectral function in the antinodes is approximately particle-hole symmetric contrary to the gapped regions just outside the pocket. We find that states at the Fermi energy are extended whereas states near the pseudogap energy have localization lengths as short as the interstripe spacing. We consider pairing which has either local $d$-wave or $s$-wave symmetry and find similar results in both cases, consistent with the pseudogap being an effect of local pair correlations. We suggest that this state is a stripe-ordered caricature of the pseudogap phase in underdoped cuprates with coexisting spin-, charge-, and pair-density-wave correlations. Lastly, we also model a superconducting state which (1) evolves smoothly from the pseudogap state, (2) has a signature subgap peak in the density of states, and (3) has the coherent pair density concentrated to the nodal region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{granath2010modeling,
  author = {Mats Granath and Brian M. Andersen},
  title = {{Modeling a striped pseudogap state}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.81.024501},
}
Figure