Modeled changes to the Great Plains low‐level jet under a realistic irrigation application

S. E. Arcand, Lifeng Luo, Shiyuan Zhong, Liang Pei, Xindi Bian, Julie A. WinklerAtmospheric 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how realistic agricultural irrigation impacts the Great Plains low-level jet (LLJ) using a sophisticated weather model. The findings reveal that irrigation significantly increases LLJ speeds and slightly lowers jet core height, highlighting the crucial role of accurate human activity representation in climate modeling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Great Plains (GP) of the United States are characterized by low-level jets (LLJs), which are crucial for transporting moisture and influencing nocturnal convection and precipitation. Agricultural irrigation is a major anthropogenic influence on the GP's surface moisture and energy budget, yet its precise impact on LLJs has been based on simplified, often unrealistic, modeling assumptions. Previous studies have either oversimplified irrigation (e.g., saturating entire soil columns) or focused on limited aspects, leaving a gap in understanding the nuanced effects of realistic irrigation practices on LLJ dynamics. This paper aims to address this by incorporating a dynamic and spatially distributed irrigation scheme into a weather model to simulate its impact on LLJs.

Methods

The researchers employed the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model, a widely used numerical weather prediction system. A key innovation in this study is the integration of a dynamic and realistic irrigation scheme developed by Pei et al. (2016). This scheme simulates irrigation as added precipitation, triggered by plant available water in the soil and applied at a specific rate and duration. The model was configured with a 30-km horizontal grid resolution and 30 vertical layers, driven by the North American Regional Reanalysis (NARR) dataset. Two simulations were conducted for the exceptionally dry summer of 2012: one with the irrigation scheme activated (IRR) and one without (NOIR). LLJs were identified using a modified version of Bonner's (1968) criteria. The study also involved validation against NARR reanalysis data and rawinsonde observations to assess the model's ability to capture LLJ climatology.

Datasets

  • North American Regional Reanalysis (NARR): Used to drive the WRF model simulations, providing atmospheric and surface data.
  • Rawinsonde Observations: Utilized for validation of the WRF model's simulated LLJ profiles during specific events.
  • USGS Water-Use Report (Maupin et al., 2014): Used by Pei et al. (2016) to validate the realism of the irrigation scheme's spatial distribution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Realistic Irrigation Matters: The study strongly emphasizes that the way irrigation is modeled significantly influences the simulated LLJ response. Simple, unrealistic irrigation schemes can lead to overestimations of LLJ changes.
  • Irrigation as a Forcing Mechanism: Even a "relatively modest amount of added irrigation water provides a strong forcing to alter regional to synoptic scale circulations and influence the LLJ." This underscores the importance of considering human activities in climate modeling.
  • Overnight Warming and Thermal Wind: The simulated warming in irrigated areas during overnight hours is identified as a potential driver for enhanced LLJ strength, likely through increased thermal wind contributions.
  • Downstream Effects: The study highlights that irrigation impacts are not confined to the irrigated regions but extend downstream, influencing atmospheric patterns across a broader area.

Key Results

  • Increased LLJ Speed: The IRR simulation showed a statistically significant increase in mean LLJ core speed, on the order of approximately 1 m/s, over the most heavily irrigated regions of the GP.
  • Lowered Jet Core Height: A decrease in the mean jet core height of about 50 m was simulated during overnight hours in the IRR scenario.
  • Increased Jet Frequency: While not statistically significant, the IRR simulation showed a 5-10% increase in LLJ occurrence frequency over irrigated areas.
  • Weaker Response than Previous Studies: The magnitude of the simulated changes was generally weaker than reported in earlier studies that used more extreme irrigation assumptions, reinforcing the importance of realistic parameterization.
  • Temperature and Geopotential Height Changes: The IRR simulation showed localized warming over irrigated areas and downstream cooling, along with altered geopotential height gradients that could contribute to the observed wind changes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Dry Year Focus: The study focused on the exceptionally dry summer of 2012 to maximize the irrigation signal. Future work should investigate the LLJ response in climatologically normal and wet years, as the feedback between irrigation and atmospheric circulation may be dependent on background climate conditions.
  • Regional Focus: The irrigation scheme parameters were tuned for the GP, and the analyses are thus most accurate for this region. Expanding the analysis to other irrigated regions or refining the scheme for broader applicability would be beneficial.
  • Model Configuration: While the WRF model and its physics schemes were carefully selected, the authors acknowledge that differences in model configuration could contribute to variations in results compared to previous studies.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors suggest future studies should explore the impact of varying climatological conditions and further refine the representation of irrigation in operational forecast models. They also emphasize the need for more explicit representation of irrigation in atmospheric models for improved climate projections.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low-level jets (LLJs) are relatively fast-moving streams of air that form in the lower troposphere and are a common phenomenon across the Great Plains (GP) of the United States. LLJs play an important role in moisture transport and the development of nocturnal convection in the spring and summer. Alterations to surface moisture and energy fluxes can influence the planetary boundary layer (PBL) development and thus LLJs. One important anthropogenic process that has been shown to affect the surface energy budget is irrigation. In this study, we investigate the effects of irrigation on LLJ development across the GP by incorporating a dynamic and realistic irrigation scheme into the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model. WRF simulations were conducted with and without the irrigation scheme for the exceptionally dry summer of 2012 over the GP. The results show irrigation-introduced changes to LLJ features both over and downstream of the most heavily irrigated regions in the GP. There were statistically significant increases to LLJ speeds in the simulation with the irrigation parameterization. Decreases to the mean jet core height on the order of 50 m during the overnight hours were also simulated when irrigation was on. The overall frequency of jet occurrences increased over the irrigated regions by 5-10%; however, these differences were not statistically significant. These changes were weaker than those reported in earlier studies based on simple representations of irrigation that unrealistically saturate the soil columns over large areas over a long period of time, which highlights the importance and necessity to represent human activity more accurately in modeling studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arcand2019modeled,
  author = {S. E. Arcand and Lifeng Luo and Shiyuan Zhong and Liang Pei and Xindi Bian and Julie A. Winkler},
  title = {{Modeled changes to the Great Plains low‐level jet under a realistic irrigation application}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1002/asl.888},
}
Figure